‘Super liens’ no longer a super threat to Georgia homeowners

Georgia homeowners who fall behind on their property taxes now have a new protection. No longer can cunning investors quickly snatch away their homes and everything the owners had paid on it.

For years, such investors and their attorneys, armed with only a piddling second unpaid bill, used a loophole in Georgia law to override safeguards designed to help struggling taxpayers. The maneuver was so powerful it was dubbed a “super lien.”

But this month, a Georgia Supreme Court decision stripped the super lien of its super powers. Homeowners still gripped in the process may get immediate relief.

“I think this party’s over,” said Hugh Wood, a real estate attorney who has defended clients against super liens. “I don’t think they’re going to game the system anymore, because they can’t guarantee that they will get the land and the excess proceeds. It’s too dangerous.”

2013 investigation by The Atlanta Journal-Constitution exposed how several Atlanta law firms, working on behalf of investors, had put such claims against hundreds of properties. The practice was based on a series of court decisions between 2003 and 2010.

It would happen so fast, homeowners often didn’t know what hit them.

Jessica Sims and her brother, James Davis, lost their late father’s Cherokee County home three years ago after $14,000 in taxes went unpaid and a Florida company called Trintec imposed a super lien. They said the company used an outside debt to do it — their uncle’s unpaid medical bill, since he was a part-owner in the property.

Sims and Davis hired an attorney to challege the action but ended up settling for a fraction of the home’s value. After paying their attorney’s fee, they said, they wound up with $5,000 each for a house valued at more than $200,000.

“It feels like losing hope,” Sims said. “I’m a single mom with a special needs child, and I do it by myself. So that was my little bit of hope, that I would be able to provide something for her for the future.”

Critics accused such investors of exploiting homeowners in dire straits — particularly the sick and the elderly — who may not understand Georgia’s convoluted foreclosure laws.

“I call them pirates,” said attorney Mark Thompson, who waged a successful argument against the process before the state Supreme Court. “The result that they’re trying to achieve is extremely inequitable, and it provides a financial bonanza for the pirates.”

But purveyors of super liens said homeowners were left in the same position as any person whose property goes to tax sale: free to take the property back if they can come up with the tax sale sum and pay off their debts and penalties. They just have less time to do it, since super lien holders can fast-track a foreclosure

Attorney Robert Proctor, who coined the term super lien during a 2003 lawsuit, said the maneuver speeded up a tax deed buyer’s ability to obtain clean title to a property. The state Supreme Court decision, he said, will primarily benefit banks that hold mortgages, not homeowners.

“So this just makes it a longer process, during which the title will not be marketable, and the delinquent will still be in possession of the property,” Proctor said. “Frequently, a lot of bad things happen because of that. Houses tend to get stripped. People don’t focus on that.”

Understanding how the Georgia Supreme Court’s decision weakens super liens requires understanding how they operate in the first place. One of their strengths has been in their dizzying mechanics.

Taxpayer protections neutralized

When a property owner doesn’t pay tax bills, a county, a city or a private lien-holder can auction the property on the courthouse steps to settle the account.

After the property is sold, the owner has one year to compensate the auction buyer and pay the buyer the tax sale penalty, which is 20 percent of the sale price.

If the property owner can’t pay, he or she can instead apply to the government for the excess funds, which is the difference between the auction price and the taxes, fees and penalties. The owner loses the property but at least recovers some of the equity.

But the homeowner could be left with nothing if there was a second lien on the property owner — not necessarily on the property itself. That’s because case law allowed the holder of the second lien to quickly “redeem” the property and claim the excess funds, if the homeowner couldn’t quickly pay off an inflated tab. The second-lien holder can proceed to foreclosure, so the homeowner doesn’t have a year to come up with the money.

And here’s why homeowners stood little chance: Usually, the investor who bought the property at tax sale and the investor who owned the second lien worked in tandem, so they might drive up the bid price to make the property more difficult to redeem. Since the investors would get the excess funds back from the goverment, their money on the table would be minimal compared to the value of the home. 

The AJC’s 2013 investigation found the same three companies repeatedly involved in dozens of super lien cases in Fulton and Gwinnett. Often, they were linked to Vesta Holdings, the largest buyer of tax liens in those counties.

The M7ven ruling

The bonanza appears to be over, though, thanks to the final sentence of a unanimous Supreme Court ruling handed down May 15: “… a redeeming creditor of a tax-sale property does not have a priority lien against excess funds arising from that sale.”

The decision allows super lien holders to do everything they did before, except seize the excess funds.

“This changes things dramatically,” Thompson, the attorney, said. His opposing attorney, John Clark, pointed out the the decision keeps things as they’ve been for more than a year, since super liens cooled off after the Court of Appeals sided with Thompson’s client in 2015.

The case started when the executive director of M7ven Supportive Housing and Development, a nonprofit, discovered that Carroll County had auctioned two houses she planned to rehab in Villa Rica. Beverly Creagh said the county notified her she was entitled to excess funds of about $105,000.

But then a company called Design Acquisition LLC paid about $1,400 for a Fulton County tax lien against the nonprofit for another property it owned. Design Acquisition then redeemed the Carroll County properties, laying claim to the excess funds. M7ven stood to get nothing.

“I was just like, ‘What are you talking about, this super lien?’ It didn’t make any sense to me,” Creagh said. “How can you get the property and the excess funds, too? That doesn’t even make any sense.”

Her attorney demanded that the Carroll County tax commissioner hand over the excess funds.

Siding with her, the Supreme Court said that a lien-holder who redeems a property can claim just the property itself.

“I’m grateful to God that we had the ability to fight them,” Creagh said. “Because so many others, based on the way this has been used, have lost their equity, lost their home, and these greedy investors have just come in and preyed upon them.”

The ruling came too late for Sims and Davis, who grew up spending holidays at their grandparents’ former home. They said their uncle still lives there, apparently as a tenant of the company that imposed the super lien.

“Me and my sister totally got screwed out of an inheritance,” Davis said. “I think it’s an awesome thing that they got rid of (super liens), I just wish it would have happened sooner.”

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in AJC Investigates

Chiropractors getting hundreds of millions in improper Medicare payments
Chiropractors getting hundreds of millions in improper Medicare payments
Make off with millions by going small and flying under the government radar. That seems to be the takeaway in a new report by a government watchdog. Every year, Medicare is shelling out hundreds of millions of dollars for massages, acupuncture and other ineligible or medically unnecessary services that are billed by chiropractors, says the report,...
Georgia doctor got a pass from DEA once. Will she get one again?
Georgia doctor got a pass from DEA once. Will she get one again?
Did the opioid epidemic cause a Georgia weight-loss doctor to fall off the DEA's radar?  That’s at least one of the explanations offered by the federal drug enforcement agency for why it didn’t make a case against Dr. Jan McBarron four years ago when it had detailed information that the flamboyant Columbus physician had prescribed...
Larry Nassar isn’t the only bad doc at the Tucson pen
Larry Nassar isn’t the only bad doc at the Tucson pen
At Larry Nassar’s new residence – the federal penitentiary in Tucson – he’s not the only inmate with both a medical degree and a horrifying criminal history. Nassar, the doctor who was recently convicted for sexually abusing young gymnasts, is now at the same prison where Dr. Craig A. Morgenstern is serving time for his...
Real estate agent bilked investors of millions, feds say
Real estate agent bilked investors of millions, feds say
Every which way she could, an Atlanta real estate agent bilked a group of foreign investors out of millions of dollars, the government alleges in a criminal complaint.  She embezzled some $930,000. Inflated sale prices to pocket another $1.1 million. But the big money, a criminal complaint alleges, came from even more brazen schemes. She fleeced...
Lack of medical records stymies state’s case against Children’s Healthcare pediatrician
Lack of medical records stymies state’s case against Children’s Healthcare pediatrician
More than 30 women came forward about Dr. Jose Rios, telling police that the Children’s Healthcare of Atlanta pediatrician groped and humiliated them, sometimes in full view of their children.  But more than two years after Rios’ arrest, DeKalb County prosecutors say they still can’t start a trial in the case because they...
More Stories