You have reached your limit of free articles this month.

Enjoy unlimited access to myAJC.com

Starting at just 99¢ for 8 weeks.

GREAT REASONS TO SUBSCRIBE TODAY!

  • IN-DEPTH REPORTING
  • INTERACTIVE STORYTELLING
  • NEW TOPICS & COVERAGE
  • ePAPER
X

You have read of premium articles.

Get unlimited access to all of our breaking news, in-depth coverage and bonus content- exclusively for subscribers. Starting at just 99¢ for 8 weeks

X

Welcome to myAJC.com

This subscriber-only site gives you exclusive access to breaking news, in-depth coverage, exclusive interactives and bonus content.

You can read free articles of your choice a month that are only available on myAJC.com.

This NCAA tournament’s Talking Point - 10th-seeded Wichita State


Every NCAA tournament has a Talking Point Team. Last year’s was Syracuse, which didn’t deserve to be there – its RPI was 71, the highest ever for an at-large invitee — but made the Final Four. This year’s TPTer might again be Syracuse, which had six victories teams among the RPI’s top 50 but went uninvited, which irked Jim Boeheim and delighted the denizens of Greensboro, N.C. But by now we’re all weary of Whiny Jim, and there’s a more intriguing team in the grid.

That team is Wichita State, a colossus among mid-majors. The Shockers crashed the 2013 Final Four and nearly felled champ-to-be Louisville in the semis. They entered the 2014 tournament unbeaten. The Shockers beat Kansas in Round 2 in 2015. They clipped Arizona in Round 1 last year. In sum, this is not a program without profile. Which is why the Shockers’ seeding was so shocking.

Make your Mark Bradley Bracket Fiasco picks

Wichita State, which is 30-4 and champion of the Missouri Valley Conference, is a No. 10 seed. That’s lower than Vanderbilt, a No. 9 carrying a record-for-an-at-large 15 losses. That’s lower than South Carolina, a No. 7 that has lost six of its past nine. That’s lower than Michigan State, a No. 9 with a road record of 2-7.

For once, we can’t blame RPI. Wichita State’s RPI is 32, which trumps Vandy’s (38), South Carolina’s (43) and Michigan State’s (50). Yet the NCAA basketball committee deemed the Shockers the 38th-best team in the field. The knock on Wichita State: It was 2-4 against teams in the RPI top 50, with both victories coming against Illinois State, which didn’t make the field. The only team in this NCAA tournament the Shockers have beaten is South Dakota State.

No, Wichita State didn’t play a great schedule. It beat Oklahoma, which fell from last year’s Final Four to 11-20. It beat LSU, which lost 21 games and finally fired Johnny Jones. It lost to Louisville and Michigan State in the Bahamas. It lost at home to Oklahoma State. It lost to the aforementioned Illinois State, which went 27-6 and has an RPI of 33 but was omitted. (Which poses an even more tantalizing question: Had the Shockers flubbed the Valley final, would they have made the Big Dance at all?)

Here’s where Ken Pomeroy’s efficiency rankings have Wichita State – seventh, which is three spots ahead of No. 1 seed Kansas and five ahead of No. 2 seed Duke. Here’s where Dr. Joel Sokol’s LRMC ratings have the Shockers – sixth, which is one spot behind No. 1 seed North Carolina and six ahead of No. 2 Louisville. We know the committee consults to these more advanced analytics. Why did it apparently disregard them?

If it’s righteous indignation you seek, Sokol isn’t your man. Said the Georgia Tech professor: “I’m not sure I can see their point of view as far as putting them as low as a No. 10 seed. I can see their point as far as the games they’ve played. They lost to Louisville, Michigan State and Oklahoma State — the three best teams they played by far. For the committee, that’s not an unreasonable point of view.”

So what explains LRMC’s lofty view of the Shockers? Sokol: “When they’ve played the everybody-elses, they haven’t just beaten them — they’ve beaten them by a lot. But I don’t know that I’d have had them as a No. 2 seed. I might have said somewhere around a No. 7 or a No. 8.”

Gonzaga is both No. 1 in Sokol’s rankings and a No. 1 seed. “Saint Mary’s is really the only difference in schedule quality between the two teams,” Sokol said. “Gonzaga beat Florida, Iowa State and Arizona. The difference was that Wichita State lost all three (big non-conference) games.”

Sokol sniffs no vast conspiracy to keep down the mid-majors: If such a thing exists, how is Gonzaga No. 1 in the West? How is Butler No. 4 in the South? As much as he likes his numbers, Sokol is a realist. Sometimes those numbers can flatter a team. He’s leery of West Virginia, the nation’s third-best team according to LRMC. “They were beating people badly for a while. They haven’t been doing that lately. Our rankings don’t take that into account.”

The upshot of Wichita State being seeded No. 10 means that the Shockers – provided they handle No. 7 Dayton in Round 1 – could face a Round 2 date with second-seeded Kentucky. “If you go by our ratings, they’ll lose to (No. 4 per LRMC) Kentucky,” Sokol said, “and we’ll wonder what the fuss was about.”

Yep. That’s how this works. Until the games begin, we fuss about seedings. Once the playing starts, we shut up and watch.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Atlanta Hawks

How the Hawks season came to an end despite near miraculous comeback
How the Hawks season came to an end despite near miraculous comeback

Five observations from the Hawks’ 115-99 loss to the Wizards in Game 6 of the Eastern Conference quarterfinal playoff series. The Wizard won the series, 4-2. 1. Turnovers kill. The Hawks committed 22 turnovers for the game – but it was the 15 first-half turnovers that led to the 22-point deficit they were never able to completely erase...
Inside the box score: Wizards 115, Hawks 99
Inside the box score: Wizards 115, Hawks 99

Inside the box score and more of the Hawks’ 115-99 loss to the Wizards in Game 6 of the Eastern Conference quarterfinal series Friday: Key players * John Wall scored a game-high and his career playoff high with 42 points for the Wizards. * Bradley Beal added 31 points for the Wizards. * Paul Millsap led the Hawks with 31 points and 10 rebounds...
Hawks’ quick playoff exit affirms change is needed
Hawks’ quick playoff exit affirms change is needed

Two years ago, the Hawks won two playoff series. Last year, they won one. This year, none. Sometimes you don’t need advanced analytics to tell you there’s a problem. The Hawks didn’t just lose a game and a series to the Washington Wizards on Friday night. They affirmed in defeat that, despite generally exceptional coaching, despite...
Hawks eliminated, Wizards nearly blow 22-point lead
Hawks eliminated, Wizards nearly blow 22-point lead

They say the closeout game is the toughest to win in the playoffs. It was for the Wizards. The Wizards nearly blew a 22-point second-half lead before a series-clinching 115-99 victory over the Hawks in Game 6 of the Eastern Conference quarterfinals series Friday night at Philips Arena. The Wizards won the series 4-2. “It’s the toughest...
Game Thread: Wizards at Hawks Game 6
Game Thread: Wizards at Hawks Game 6

Atlanta Hawks guard Dennis Schroder dribbles against Washington Wizards guard Bradley Beal during the second half in Game 5 of a first-round NBA basketball playoff series, Wednesday, April 26, 2017, in Washington.
More Stories