FBI once thought this Christmas classic was Communist propaganda


Every holiday season, millions of people cozy up near a warm fireplace or at least a warm television to watch a familiar black-and-white tale, the 1946 classic "It's a Wonderful Life."

The film, which director Frank Capra considered his best, follows the down-on-his-luck George Bailey. He's a businessman in the fictional town of Bedford Falls, who is about to lose his loan company to the rich, evil banker Mr. Potter. Bailey considers committing suicide on Christmas Eve, deciding his family and the townspeople would be better off without him. But a guardian angel appears. The angel presents Bailey an alternative timeline in which he doesn't exist, showing the suicidal man how much he's helped those around him.

With stars Jimmy Stewart and Donna Reed, the movie was a commercial and critical success, earning five Oscar nominations, including one for best picture. In 1990, the Library of Congress inducted the film into the National Film Registry. It's the perfect flick for the holidays: a touching story of how our actions affect everyone around us, and how everyone is an integral part of a community's fabric.

The FBI didn't see it that way.

Instead, J. Edgar Hoover's Communist-hunting agents thought it was a Trojan horse sneaking anti-American propaganda to the masses. This argument was compiled in a memo written by an unnamed special agent in the FBI's Los Angeles field office about "communist infiltration" of the motion picture industry.

From 1942 to 1958, the Los Angeles field office investigated more than 200 movies, fearing they had been turned into weapons of Communist propaganda, as John A. Noakes wrote in "The Cold War and the Movies." The FBI generally looked into films connected to personalities associated with the Communist Party, which is what drew them to "It's a Wonderful Life."

The FBI claimed that two of its screenwriters, Frances Goodrich and Albert Hackett, "were very close to known Communists and on one occasion in the recent past . . . practically lived with known Communists and were observed" eating lunch every day with "known Communists."

So an agent watched the movie and wrote a report claiming it "represented a rather obvious attempt to discredit bankers."

For example, the report said, the film cast Lionel Barrymore as Mr. Potter, the "'scrooge-type' so that he would be the most hated man in the picture." On its face, that's true: the plot wouldn't work if the crowd were cheering for Potter to repossess Bailey's business. But, the FBI agent claimed that according to "informants," this was "a common trick used by Communists."

The report claimed the movie "deliberately maligned the upper class, attempting to show the people who had money were mean and despicable characters."

The FBI argued the movie could have portrayed Mr. Potter as "following the rules as laid down by the State Bank Examiners in connection with making loans."

Though the film was deemed subversive, not much came of the investigation. The FBI gave a report to the House Un-American Activities Committee, an investigative subcommittee of the House of Representatives established to suss out organizations and individuals with suspected communist ties. But HUAC, as it was called, chose not to take any action and allowed the movie to keep playing, according to Smithsonian magazine.

While the suspicion of the film was typical for the FBI during that era, a movie as popular as "It's a Wonderful Life" will always launch a thousand interpretations.

For example, Birmingham City University criminology professor David Wilson wrote in the Guardian that he pops open a bottle of wine and watches the movie without his family every year because it's "the closest an atheist can get to heaven." Wilson called it "the least religious but most humanist film that you could ever see."

On the other hand, Anne Morse wrote in the Christian Post the movie is "a magnificent cinematic depiction of the words of Jesus: 'For what will it profit a man if he gains the whole world and forfeits his own soul?' (Matthew 16:26)."


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Flu deaths reach 12 in Georgia as flu remains widespread
Flu deaths reach 12 in Georgia as flu remains widespread

The number of flu deaths continues to climb in Georgia as the flu outbreak remains widespread here and across the country.  Influenza activity has increased sharply in Georgia and across the United States during recent weeks, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. During the second week of the year, which runs from Jan....
DeKalb commissioners add moratorium on municipalities to session goals
DeKalb commissioners add moratorium on municipalities to session goals

DeKalb commissioners will ask members of their legislative delegation to support a bill that creates a three-year moratorium on new municipalities and annexations in the county. Commissioners are also asking legislators to require that future cityhood referendums include all voters in unincorporated DeKalb, not just those living within the proposed...
Deputies: Florida man tries to order burrito from bank, gets charged with DUI
Deputies: Florida man tries to order burrito from bank, gets charged with DUI

Police in Florida arrested a 28-year-old man on suspicion of driving under the influence of drugs or alcohol after authorities said he attempted to order a burrito from a Bank of America after confusing it for a Taco Bell, according to multiple reports. Records from the Hernando County Sheriff’s Office show authorities arrested Douglas Jon Francisco...
Cobb location of local Mexican restaurant chain fails health check
Cobb location of local Mexican restaurant chain fails health check

One of Cobb County’s multiple Cielo Blue Cantina restaurants just failed a health inspection. The Mexican restaurant at 1080 Windy Hill Road in Smyrna scored a 69 on its Friday health check, records show. Any score below a 70 is considered failing. An inspector noted uncooked onions being improperly stored beneath raw chicken, beef and fish...
Carter Center working to kill this disease
Carter Center working to kill this disease

The Carter Center and its partners reported continued progress in the global Guinea worm eradication campaign. The nonprofit targeted the parasitical disease in 21 countries of Africa and Asia in 1986 and took a leadership role to make it happen. If successful, it will be only the second disease in history, after smallpox to be eradicated. A count...
More Stories