You have reached your limit of free articles this month.

Enjoy unlimited access to myAJC.com

Starting at just 99¢ for 8 weeks.

GREAT REASONS TO SUBSCRIBE TODAY!

  • IN-DEPTH REPORTING
  • INTERACTIVE STORYTELLING
  • NEW TOPICS & COVERAGE
  • ePAPER
X

You have read of premium articles.

Get unlimited access to all of our breaking news, in-depth coverage and bonus content- exclusively for subscribers. Starting at just 99¢ for 8 weeks

X

Welcome to myAJC.com

This subscriber-only site gives you exclusive access to breaking news, in-depth coverage, exclusive interactives and bonus content.

You can read free articles of your choice a month that are only available on myAJC.com.

Who wins clemency in Georgia?


Since 1976, the Georgia Board of Pardons and Paroles commuted the death sentences of these men on grounds similar to those put forward by lawyers for Kelly Gissendaner. The board granted clemency to three others on grounds of insanity or mental incapacity, factors not present in Gissendaner’s case. Years noted in parentheses are the years in which clemency was granted.

Samuel David Crowe (2008)

» The crime: Crowe was convicted of shooting an employee to death during a robbery of a firm where Crowe once worked.

» Arguments for clemency: Friends, pastors and a former corrections officer testified about Crowe’s exemplary behavior and deep remorse while on death row.

Freddie Davis (1988)

» The crime: Davis and another man were accused of raping and killing a woman. The other man testified against Davis in return for a life sentence but later recanted and said Davis was not in the room when the woman was killed.

» Arguments for clemency:Davis’ death sentence was disproportional to the life sentence given to his equally or more culpable codefendant.

Daniel Greene (2012)

» The crime: Greene, a recent high school graduate, was convicted of killing a former classmate and then attacking an elderly couple and a store clerk as he stole money to buy crack cocaine.

» Arguments for clemency: The prosecutor testified that he would have sought life without parole if that option had existed when Greene was sentenced. Community members and prison officials testified that Greene had otherwise led a peaceful and upstanding life.

Willie James Hall (2004)

» The crime: Hall was convicted of stabbing to death his estranged wife. The victim had called 911; the killing was recorded on tape.

» Arguments for clemency: Six jurors testified they would have chosen life without parole if it had been offered at trial. Hall’s excellent behavior in prison and no criminal record prior to the murder were also cited.

Charles Harris Hill (1977)

» The crime: Hill and two other men were involved in a burglary that went awry, resulting in a murder. The actual killer plead guilty and received a life sentence.

» Arguments for clemency: Death sentence was disproportional to the sentence given to his equally or more culpable codefendant, the actual killer.

William Moore (1990)

» The crime: Moore killed an elderly man in the course of a robbery. He pleaded guilty and was sentenced to death.

» Arguments for clemency: Moore’s exemplary prison record, remorse, religious conversion and the pleas for clemency from the victim’s family.

Tommy Waldrip (2014)

» The crime: Waldrip and two accomplices, including his son, were convicted of killing a man who was set to testify against Waldrip’s son in an armed robbery case. Both accomplices received life sentences.

» Arguments for clemency: The disproportionality of Tommy Waldrip’s sentence, given that he was not the impetus for the crime and that his son actually committed it.

Harold Williams (1991)

» The crime: Williams and his uncle were charged with the bludgeoning death of Williams’ grandfather. The uncle pleaded guilty to voluntary manslaughter and received a 10-year sentence.

» Arguments for clemency: Williams’ death sentence was disproportional to the sentence given to his accomplice, who took full responsibility for the crime.

Sources: Death Penalty Information Center, American Bar Association, court documents in the Kelly Gissendaner case, news reports.


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Sheriff: 18 arrested in metro Atlanta meth ring bust
Sheriff: 18 arrested in metro Atlanta meth ring bust

A months-long investigation led to the dismantling of a methamphetamine trafficking ring in metro Atlanta, officials say. Eighteen people were arrested during raids conducted last week, Douglas County sheriff’s spokesman Sgt. Jesse Hambrick said in a news release. Investigators with the Douglas County Sheriff’s Office identified...
Witness to crash that killed 4 teens: ‘There was nothing we could do’
Witness to crash that killed 4 teens: ‘There was nothing we could do’

She wasn’t sure exactly what was in the middle of the road Monday afternoon. Then, Tilafayea Walker realized it was an SUV that had crashed, and she could see someone inside. “Oh my God, there’s someone in the car,” Walker remembers telling her sister, who was driving on Ga. 92 in south Fulton County. Without hesitating, Walker...
2 injured in Bartow County plane crash ID’d
2 injured in Bartow County plane crash ID’d

The pilot and passenger in a Bartow County plane crash were identified Monday, a week after they were taken to hospitals with injuries.  Euharlee police identified pilot Danil Cadena and passenger Alan Villanuva on Monday. Officials did not know their ages or where they are from.  Little is known about Tuesday’s crash, but officials...
Teen arrested in deadly gas station shooting
Teen arrested in deadly gas station shooting

Police arrested one of the people they believe is connected to a shooting that killed a teenager at a Texaco in southwest Atlanta on Friday. Darryl Oliver, 19, is believed to be the person who shot 17-year-old Daronaldo Wilkerson at the gas station on the 1900 block of Sylvan Road, Channel 2 Action News reported. Wilkerson was inside a stolen car at...
More early voting sites may be added for Congress runoff
More early voting sites may be added for Congress runoff

Election officials said Monday they’ll probably increase the number of early voting sites in anticipation of the high-profile runoff election for Georgia’s 6th Congressional District. Nearly 30 residents crammed into a meeting of the DeKalb Board of Registration & Elections to express concerns about the number of early voting sites available...
More Stories