Turtles — and the Sea Island spit — back in court


Coastal and environmental groups are appealing a judge’s ruling allowing development of posh Sea Island homes claiming harm to loggerhead turtles and pristine beaches.

A state administrative law judge ruled in August that the Sea Island company can build eight expensive homes — lots begin at $3.5 million — on a “spit” of land below the famed Cloister Hotel. The beach practically disappears at high tide.

The Altamaha Riverkeeper, represented by GreenLaw, and One Hundred Miles, represented by the Southern Environmental Law Center, are appealing the judge’s ruling in Fulton Superior Court. They argue that the administrative judge impropely ruled that a proposed 350-foot-long rock groin would keep endangered turtles from laying eggs and hatchlings from returning to the Atlantic Ocean. They add that the sliver of beach could be renourished without a groin.

“As sea-level rise and related shoreline retreat are increasingly impacting our coast, it’s critical to look to solutions that will provide the greatest benefit to the environment and to the people and wildlife that depend on healthy shorelines and beaches,” Megan Hinkle, staff attorney for the law center, said in a statement. “Groins and other structures that result in the loss of shorelines and valuable ecosystems are not an acceptable solution for the Georgia coast.”

Sea Island, a favorite coastal retreat for well-heeled Atlantans, where suites at The Cloister run $1,000 a night, is selling home lots with unparalleled ocean views. Between 2003 and 2013, though, the beach alongside the planned development shrank by 108 feet. The spit is the only spot on Sea Island ineligible for federal flood insurance.

Environmentalists also say the groin, and a sand dune built with as much as 120,000 cubic yards of sand, will cause the beach to shift and could also impact nearby St. Simons Island.

Administrative Law Judge Kristin Miller, in her August ruling, said: “Weighed against Sea Island’s interest in protecting its valuable upland property, the modest adverse impacts of the permitted project are not unreasonable.”

The U.S. Army Corps of Engineers is also reviewing the permit application. Earlier, a sea turtle expert with the Georgia Department of Natural Resources, testified that the proposed groin would “unreasonably” interfere with conservation of the endangered turtles.

Sea Island Co. representatives were disappointed Tuesday with the appeal, labeling Judge Miller’s ruling “very thorough and careful.”

In a statement, Scott Steilen, the company’s president, said: “Sea Island has a responsibility to protect its property from continuing erosion, by investing our own funds, using approved methods, and securing all required permits, and we hope to be able to move forward soon to construct the project.”


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Ex-DeKalb corrections officer convicted of rape may be hiding in South Georgia
Ex-DeKalb corrections officer convicted of rape may be hiding in South Georgia

A convicted former DeKalb corrections officer who fled during his rape trial may be hiding in Glynn County, authorities said.  Charles Pinckney has been on the run since Oct. 27, the day of closing arguments in his trial, The Atlanta Journal-Constitution previously reported. Pinckney was convicted and subsequently sentenced to 45 years for raping...
Tyler Perry buys car for mother of toddler who needs kidney transplant
Tyler Perry buys car for mother of toddler who needs kidney transplant

A Gwinnett County mother whose toddler has been waiting for a kidney transplant his whole life was gifted a car on Tuesday. Carmellia Burgess brought her son home from Children’s Healthcare of Atlanta on Nov. 8, where he’d been since Oct. 29.  The family expected to wait for the news that his father, Anthony Dickerson, would be permitted...
Alpharetta officer hit by alleged DUI driver
Alpharetta officer hit by alleged DUI driver

A 25-year-old man is facing DUI charges after allegedly hitting an Alpharetta police car on Ga. 400 Friday night. Joseph Gipe is accused of crashing into Officer Dustin Bak, who was heading home after a shift with the DUI task force, Alpharetta police spokesman Jason Muenzer told Channel 2 Action News. Muenzer said Bak was going about the speed limit...
Atlanta mayor candidates piling up endorsements
Atlanta mayor candidates piling up endorsements

The two rivals for Atlanta mayor scrambled Tuesday to lock up support from political power brokers, each jockeying to secure in the runoff election the giant chunk of the city’s electorate that declined to back them in the first round of the vote. Councilwoman Keisha Lance Bottoms announced the endorsements of several well-known white Democrats...
Woman on way to church shot in Atlanta neighborhood
Woman on way to church shot in Atlanta neighborhood

A 61-year-old woman was shot in her southwest Atlanta neighborhood as she drove to church, officials said. “I was on my way to church to clean the church,” she told Channel 2 Action News. Now, police are searching for the gunmen who fired as many as five shots last Thursday on Oak Drive.  A bullet came through the windshield and hit...
More Stories