Why Georgia’s water wars fight is far from over

Fresh off a key legal victory in the decades-long water war with Florida, Georgia leaders are scrambling to shore up glaring weaknesses exposed by the litigation while bracing for a new fight in Congress that could undercut the state’s courtroom success.

A judicial official in February urged the U.S. Supreme Court to reject strict new water consumption limits that Georgia said would have devastated the state’s economy, but his findings also highlighted vast problems with the state’s agricultural water use that could dog the state in future court battles.

At the same time, Georgia’s congressional delegation is on guard for another attempt by federal lawmakers from Alabama and Florida to weaken the state’s position. And they are readying for the possibility that the high court ignores the judicial recommendation or calls for a new round of litigation.

For state officials who have already spent roughly $30 million on the litigation, the fight is far from over.

“We’ve won one skirmish,” said Gerald Long, president of the Georgia Farm Bureau. “There are many, many battles ahead of us. So we’ve got to be vigilant.”

‘Unrestrained’ water use

It was a big skirmish. Ralph Lancaster, a Maine attorney appointed by the U.S. Supreme Court as a special master to handle the case, found in February that Florida had “failed to show that a consumption cap” was needed after five weeks of hearing testimony in the case.

But his 70-page report found problems with Georgia’s agricultural water use, in part after Florida shifted the focus of its argument away from metro Atlanta’s consumption and toward that of farmers in the southern part of the state.

Lancaster concluded that Georgia’s agricultural water use was “largely unrestrained” and cited Florida’s count that the amount of irrigated acreage in Georgia ballooned from 75,000 acres in 1970 to more than 825,000 acres in 2014.

“In the face of this sharp increase in water use, Georgia has taken few measures to limit consumptive water use for agricultural irrigation,” he wrote, adding that agriculture permits issued by the state often don’t limit the amount of irrigation that can be used by farmers.

Lancaster also criticized the state Environmental Protection Division for refusing to declare a drought in 2011 despite ample warnings, finding that Georgia officials were “clearly not wishing to incur the cost of preventative action.”

‘There’s work to be done’

As drought squeezed the state’s water supply, he said, the state issued only a temporary moratorium on new irrigation permits to South Georgia farmers.

“Georgia’s position — practically, politically, and legally — can be summarized as follows: Georgia’s agricultural water use should be subject to no limitations, regardless of the long-term consequences” for the river basin, he wrote.

Gov. Nathan Deal and other state officials have taken notice. Deal said in a recent interview that “internal work” is needed to fortify the state’s weaknesses, including new ways to measure agricultural water use.

“We have continued to try to press to get more of the irrigated land metered so we have a better idea of the volume of usage,” Deal said. “That’s one of our better mechanisms of defense. We need to prove with actual numbers what the amount of water is that’s being consumed.”

He said Florida “just picked numbers, I think out of air” to report how much water was being used by Georgia for agricultural purposes and claim the state has 100,000 acres of irrigated land with no meters. And Georgia couldn’t effectively counter, he said, because “unfortunately, we don’t totally know.”

“There’s work to be done. It’s a sensitive issue,” Deal said. “It’s a property rights issue in the eyes of many people. So we have to work with the agricultural community to find what best fits Georgia’s situation.”

Georgia agriculture leaders are starting the behind-the-scenes work now.

“We’ve got to be responsible as farmers on metering so we can continue to prove not only to Florida but to the rest of the nation and federal agencies that we are trying to conserve water and we’re doing our part,” said Long, the head of the Farm Bureau.

‘Legislative gymnastics’

The state is also hunkering down for a new round of intrigue in Congress. Deal dispatched his top aide, Chris Riley, to Washington last week to brief the congressional delegation on water policy. The message: The state needs to be prepared for a legislative assault.

It wouldn’t be the first time. There are perennial attempts by Georgia’s neighbors to target the state’s water policy, most recently a directive initially tucked into a wide-ranging $10 billion water bill that tells the governors of Georgia, Alabama and Florida to negotiate a settlement or risk Congress’ intervention.

Georgia’s contingent in Washington united to erase the directive, making a case that Congress should have no role in the water dispute, and the law passed late last year without the provision. Still, for many lawmakers it was a reminder to stay vigilant.

“The Georgia delegation is well aware of the kinds of legislative gymnastics that our Alabama and Florida neighbors employ in hopes of gaining ground in the water dispute,” said U.S. Rep. Doug Collins, R-Gainesville.

He and others are quick to point to Lancaster’s finding, which came after years of litigation and decades of fighting between the states.

Georgia’s two neighbors have long argued that the Peach State has drawn more than its share from the Chattahoochee and Flint rivers, posing a threat to the ecological system and harming the livelihoods of their residents.

Georgia countered that the state’s water use had little to do with the collapse of the Apalachicola oyster industry, and Lancaster’s finding appeared to vindicate its position.

But it’s not final, as the high court can reject Lancaster’s recommendation, order another round of arguments or take another route. Further lawsuits can’t be ruled out either.

“We have some work to be done,” Deal said. “This isn’t over.”

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Georgia Politics

The Week: Blank says kneeling should not be seen as disrespect
The Week: Blank says kneeling should not be seen as disrespect

Atlanta Falcons owner Arthur Blank offered his own interpretation of protests NFL players have staged this season by kneeling during the national anthem. “It’s very clear that the players have no interest whatsoever in being disrespectful to the flag or the anthem,” Blank told GPB’s Ricky Bevington this past week. &ldquo...
Dunwoody man goes from battling brain cancer to DNR hunting consultant
Dunwoody man goes from battling brain cancer to DNR hunting consultant

When Chip Madren was in seventh grade, doctors told his family the type of brain cancer he had gave him about two more years to live. It was his love of hunting that caused him to fight for his life, his mother said, after being promised a trip to Montana when he got better. “He was not fighting well up until that time,” Lea Madren said...
Move for freer political speech divides Georgia’s religious community
Move for freer political speech divides Georgia’s religious community

It’s a regular ritual on Sundays before big votes: Candidates fan out to churches across the state, take prominent perches near the pulpit and receive warm applause from parishioners. And preachers inevitably shower them with kind words, though they stop short of much more lest they cross an invisible line. That’s exactly what happened...
Group blames low EPD funding for Georgia’s water pollution problems
Group blames low EPD funding for Georgia’s water pollution problems

Members of a group of clean water advocates said the General Assembly’s failure to fully fund the Environmental Protection Division is a recurring theme of the organization’s annual list of problematic waterways and policies. Joe Moore, a member of the Georgia Water Coalition, said the Legislature harms the state’s waterways when...
Georgia’s craft brewers would win big in Senate tax bill
Georgia’s craft brewers would win big in Senate tax bill

The U.S. Senate’s new tax bill would give Georgia’s small craft breweries some holiday cheer months after a watershed state law provided a major economic boon to beer makers and liquor distillers. The would-be Christmas present comes in the form of a proposed tax decrease, which industry advocates say would put thousands of dollars into...
More Stories