Viral social media post about Trump rally totally made up


A viral tweet allegedly sent from the ground of an election night rally for President-elect Donald Trump said that “thousands” of his supporters were chanting a racist message.

The claim was fake.

This is what the tweet said: I am at a Trump rally in Manhattan, and thousands are chanting “We hate Muslims, we hate blacks, we want our great country back”. Disgusting

— Simon Rowntree (@SRowntreeNews) November 9, 2016

As Buzzfeed and others have reported, the tweet was sent from the account of a fake British sports journalist who has a history of making allegations about racist chants in mass crowds.

Another “Simon Rowntree” account was suspended over the summer, but Buzzfeed managed to screenshot his Twitter bio, which said he was a soccer writer for Forest Echo News. The site‘s account has also been suspended but it declared itself to be a parody in its bio, per Buzzfeed’s screenshot.

The parody news site was the creation of a group of friends who set up fake sports journalist accounts, a person who responded on behalf of Forest Echo News told Buzzfeed. Rowntree is likely a Forest Echo fan jumping on the bandwagon.

Here are some examples of Rowntree tweets alleging chants of racial epithets at British soccer games from his current account.

I am at Old Trafford and I can hear racist #MCFC fans chanting “You’re just an expensive dabbing golliwog” at Paul Pogba. This is disgusting.

— Simon Rowntree (@SRowntreeNews) October 26, 2016

Atmosphere at Hampden Park building up. #RFC fans have now started to chant “Refugee scum, … back to Calais”. Absolutely disgusting.

— Simon Rowntree (@SRowntreeNews) October 23, 2016

Racist chants are not uncommon at British soccer matches, so Rowntree’s tweets are believable though unverified and likely satirical (see Poe’s law for internet parodies).

As for Rowntree’s allegation about the Trump rally, we have not found video footage or other evidence supporting it.

Trump held his victory party at the New York Hilton in Midtown Manhattan, which can accommodate 3,300 in its grand ballroom.

Rowntree claimed the chant began at 7:04 p.m., about 30 minutes after the event had began. According to videos, the crowds were rather subdued around that time.

News reports indicate Trump supporters inside and outside the Hilton did not get rowdy until about 10 p.m., when projections began favoring Trump as the winner.

A few dozen — not “thousands” — supporters roaming Midtown shouted “T-R-U-M-P, we will beat Hill-ar-y,” “U-S-A” and “CNN sucks” at about 10:25 p.m., according to Patch New York. And Trump supporters inside the Hilton began to chant “lock her up” around 2 a.m., CBS’ Sopan Deb and NBC’s Katy Tur both reported.

Our ruling

A viral tweet said, “thousands” of people at a Manhattan rally for Trump chanted, “We hate Muslims, we hate blacks, we want our great country back.”

The widely shared claim is baseless. It was sent from a fake account tied to a parody British soccer news site.

We rate it Pants on Fire.

For the full fact-check, please see www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2016/nov/09/social-media/no-evidence-support-rumors-we-hate-muslims-chant-t/



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Georgia Politics

Senators vote to open debate on health care law
Senators vote to open debate on health care law

Republican senators voted Tuesday to open debate on revising U.S. health care law, advancing a signature campaign pledge following a tense and dramatic week on Capitol Hill. But the party voted to do so only with the barest of margins, an illustration of the challenges ahead as leaders look to unite a divided and unruly caucus. Johnny Isakson and David...
Georgia senators vote with GOP to open debate on health care repeal
Georgia senators vote with GOP to open debate on health care repeal

Georgia’s two senators, Johnny Isakson and David Perdue, voted with the GOP’s bare majority Tuesday afternoon to open debate on revising U.S. health care law. In a dramatic nail-biter, the GOP senate leadership won a vote that many thought they could lose. But Isakson’s and Perdue’s votes on this step were never seen as in doubt...
Senators on hot mic: Trump is 'crazy,' 'I'm worried'
Senators on hot mic: Trump is 'crazy,' 'I'm worried'

At the end of a Senate subcommittee hearing on Tuesday morning, Chairman Susan Collins, R-Maine, didn't switch off her microphone. Apparently speaking to Sen. Jack Reed, R.I., the ranking Democrat of the committee, Collins discussed the federal budget — and President Donald Trump's lack of familiarity with the details of governing...
White House purge: 'I'm going to fire everybody,' Scaramucci says
White House purge: 'I'm going to fire everybody,' Scaramucci says

WASHINGTON — Anthony Scaramucci, the new White House communications director, threatened on Tuesday to fire his entire staff in an effort to stem the leaking that has plagued President Trump's administration since almost the first day he took office. "I'm going to fire everybody, that's how I'm going to do it," Scaramucci said...
Your Tuesday political briefing: Health care vote; Carter on single-payer; replacing Sessions
Your Tuesday political briefing: Health care vote; Carter on single-payer; replacing Sessions

Here is what is trending in politics around Georgia and across the nation on Monday. 1. Health care vote set for Tuesday The Senate has scheduled a procedural vote Tuesday on the Republican health care bill. The vote would allow debate to begin on a bill that could repeal and replace the Affordable Care Act. Sen. John McCain, (R-Arizona), will be traveling...
More Stories