Next Story

Trump’s Cobb defeat creates headaches for GOP

Reports correct that Gingrich backed switch from Electoral College


Newt Gingrich, a loyal Donald Trump surrogate and former Georgia congressman who became speaker of the U.S. House of Representatives, is poised to play a key role in the 45th president’s new administration.

But if Gingrich, who is a key player on the Trump transition team, had gotten what he wanted not so long ago, things would be different.

According to news reports, Gingrich just a few years ago backed electing U.S. presidents through the so-called popular vote and not the Electoral College, which propelled Trump to victory last week over Democrat Hillary Clinton.

Clinton is still leading the popular vote count. But under our current system that is irrelevant. It is the candidate who gets 270 Electoral College votes who wins. The person who wins the Electoral College wins the presidency. That is the way it has been throughout U.S. history.

PolitiFact was curious. Had Gingrich backed vanquishing the Electoral College in favor of the popular vote — a change that might have shoved him into political obscurity instead of where he stands now at center stage?

The easy answer: Yes, he did.

U.S. citizens only indirectly vote for the president and vice president. The U.S. Electoral College was established by Article II of the United States Constitution. Under that system, voters in each state choose a slate of “electors” pledged to vote for a party’s candidate.

In the 2016 election, Trump is expected to get 306 electoral votes to Clinton’s 232.

In a Nov. 10 article, Mother Jones pointed to a 2014 letter to the group National Popular Vote by Gingrich. The nonpartisan group promotes legislation that would guarantee the presidency to the candidate who receives the most popular votes nationally.

In the letter, Gingrich writes, “America would be better served with a presidential election process that treated citizens across the country equally.”

We reached out to Gingrich spokesman Joe Desantis. He pointed us to a statement made by Gingrich on Sunday’s “Face The Nation.” When asked whether he was still a fan of getting rid of the Electoral College, Gingrich said, “I think in the long run you want to find a whole way to have the country represented.”

But for now, the only competitions that matter are the ones in the swing states. The GOP, Gingrich said, all but writes off traditional Democratic states such as California, which have huge popular vote totals.

“Remember, in 49 states, he (Trump) had a 2.2 million-vote majority, and then there’s California,” Gingrich said during his Sunday interview. “We don’t compete in California.

He said GOP strategists don’t invest in California because they assume the party will not carry the state.

“So it gets worse every year,” he said. “If this had been a general election, where the total vote mattered, we would have competed in California”.

Kerwin Swint, a political scientist at Kennesaw State University in metro Atlanta, said Gingrich and a number of others, both Republican and Democrat, have voiced support for the National Popular Vote Compact. Under that compact, member states would pledge to cast its electoral votes for the winner of the nationwide popular vote.

“The compact kicks in when enough states join the agreement that would equal 270 electoral votes,” Swint said in an email “So far, enough states have joined that would equal 165 electoral votes, and they are all Democratic states.”

Swint said abolishing the Electoral College would require a two-thirds vote in both houses of Congress. Then comes the really tough part — 38 out of 50 states would have to ratify it.

“Not bloody likely, at least not in our lifetimes,” he said. “Even Donald Trump criticized the Electoral College in 2012, but I bet he wouldn’t now!”

University of Virginia political scientist Larry Sabato said he doubts there is any new momentum to abolish the Electoral College by the party soon to be in charge of the White House and both chambers of Congress.

“Not only have two GOP presidents been elected in the past 16 years by the College, despite losing the popular vote, but all five cases in history of the popular vote winner being denied the Presidency disadvantaged Democrats (1824, 1876, 1888, 2000, 2016),” Sabato wrote in an email.

“Somehow I don’t think reforming or abolishing the Electoral College will be a high priority going forward, even though Gallup has repeatedly shown that large majorities of Americans want the popular vote to pick the President.”

Our ruling

Several media outlets have recently reported that Newt Gingrich previously advocated for electing U.S. presidents by popular vote instead of the Electoral College.

Our research shows Gingrich was definitely an advocate of the popular vote option.

We rate the media reports True.


Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Georgia Politics

The Right reacts to Graham-Cassidy
The Right reacts to Graham-Cassidy

A roundup of editorials Thursday takes a look at the Graham-Cassidy health care proposal. Will the bill strike the right balance between the federal government’s role in health care and what states will be expected to do? Here are some opinions from the Right. From Roll Call: The problem with the Graham-Cassidy plan is lack of momentum. A majority...
The Left slams Graham-Cassidy health care bill
The Left slams Graham-Cassidy health care bill

A roundup of editorials Thursday takes a look at the Graham-Cassidy health care proposal. Despite a heavy agenda, the bill is likely to come up on the Senate floor next week. Here are some opinions from the Left. 1. Cassidy-Graham is attractive in theory. But it has a giant flaw. From The Washington Post: An experiment in democracy is interesting...
Georgia AG gets 53 forms in probe of voter registration group
Georgia AG gets 53 forms in probe of voter registration group

Fifty-three allegedly forged voter applications are being referred to the state Attorney General’s Office for possible prosecution, a decision by the State Elections Board that effectively closes the Secretary of State Office’s 2014 fraud investigation involving an attention-grabbing registration drive by the New Georgia Project. The...
Battle over the fate of Dreamers flares in Georgia
Battle over the fate of Dreamers flares in Georgia

Jaime Rangel vividly recalls the day the letter arrived five years ago in his family’s mailbox in Chatsworth, an event that prompted his mother to burst into tears. A Mexican native who was brought to America as an infant, Rangel learned from the letter that he had been accepted into the Obama administration’s Deferred Action for Childhood...
Georgia AG gets 53 forms in fraud probe of Stacey Abrams' voter registration group
Georgia AG gets 53 forms in fraud probe of Stacey Abrams' voter registration group

The State Elections Board on Wednesday referred 53 allegedly forged voter applications to the Attorney General’s Office for possible prosecution, essentially closing a 2014 fraud investigation involving a massive registration drive by the upstart New Georgia Project.  The decision allows the office to decide whether to prosecute those involved...
More Stories