PolitiFact: Ossoff presumes too much about GOP health care bill


The treatment of pre-existing conditions has emerged as one of the thorniest issues in health care, which dominated the final debate in the special election to fill Georgia’s 6th Congressional District seat.

Democrat Jon Ossoff said the House Republican’s American Health Care Act, “guts protections against massive price hikes for Georgians with pre-existing conditions.”

Both the existing Affordable Care Act and the proposed American Health Care Act require insurance companies to sell everyone a plan who wants to buy it. The rules under the two approaches are different, however.

Both say carriers can’t base rates on a person’s health status but the American Health Care Act lets states get a waiver that allows companies to charge more for people with higher health care risks who have a break in their insurance coverage.

The GOP’s health care bill allows states to use two approaches that could affect people with pre-existing conditions. States could let insurance companies base rates on a person’s health status, and they could trim the list of health services every plan must offer. The Affordable Care Act requires 10 basic services including maternity care and mental health treatment. Those two are mentioned often as being at risk if states decide to trim the list.

The bill sets aside $8 billion that states with waivers could use in a number of ways. They could use some of it to help cover the costs of high-risk people. There would be additional billions for all states to write down the costs of maternity and mental health care.

No one can say for sure how this would play out.

The Congressional Budget Office, the nonpartisan analytic arm of Congress, estimated that one-sixth of Americans would live in states that chose both to trim the required health services and to let insurers charge sicker people more. In those places, the CBO said “less healthy people would face extremely high premiums, despite the additional funding that would be available.”

“Over time, it would become more difficult for less healthy people (including people with pre-existing medical conditions) in those states to purchase insurance because their premiums would continue to increase rapidly,” the CBO said.

Health policy analyst Joe Antos at the American Enterprise Institute, a market-oriented think tank, said no one knows which states would ask for waivers, much less whether Georgia would. Also unknown is how states would change the rules for insurance companies.

But even if states let companies charge higher rates for people with pre-existing conditions who let their coverage lapse, he said the maximum number of people who would be adversely affected would be relatively small.

“If they have insurance, they will try to keep it, because they know exactly that they will be big spenders and they want someone else to pay for it,” Antos said.

Antos said there’s a “distinct possibility” some people would face higher costs, but political pressure would limit how far states would go.

Another mitigating actor is the billions of dollars in the American Health Care Act for states to set up high-risk pools. That money would move the most expensive patients off the private insurance rolls. Gail Wilensky, a top health care adviser to President George H.W. Bush, said that with enough funding, this could give such people better care than they get today.

But Wilensky doesn’t think the current bill has set aside enough money.

“Protections are greater under the Affordable Care Act,” Wilensky said. “That’s why it costs as much as it does.”

Our ruling

No expert we reached said the proposed American Health Care Act insulates people from higher rates as much as the current Affordable Care Act does. They differed on the scale of the impact. Ossoff pushed too far on the specifics for Georgia.

We rate this claim HalfTrue.


Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Georgia Politics

The left is warning that the tax reform bill is a wolf in sheep’s clothing
The left is warning that the tax reform bill is a wolf in sheep’s clothing

As the tax reform bill heads for a vote this week, the left is sounding the alarm on the legislation’s long-term effects. A roundup of editorials Monday takes a look at the issue. Opinions from the left: From The Miami Herald: Rubio may have gotten his way, but any gain from the proposed bill will be modest, at best, and it will not last long...
The right is asking just who is investigating the investigator when it comes to Mueller
The right is asking just who is investigating the investigator when it comes to Mueller

As the methods Robert Mueller’s office has used in investigating Russian collusion claims are challenged, should someone be investigating the investigators? A roundup of editorials Monday takes a look at the issue. Opinions from the right: From The Orange County Register: With allegations of a tainted investigation swirling, the American people...
Malware disables Georgia Agriculture Department website
Malware disables Georgia Agriculture Department website

Someone infected the Georgia Department of Agriculture’s computer network with malware this week, bringing down the agency’s websites and seeking to extort a ransom payment, according to the department. The department remained offline Friday, the third day since malware spread throughout its network, spokesman Alec Asbridge said. An email...
How high-speed internet could be extended across Georgia
How high-speed internet could be extended across Georgia

A plan to bring high-speed internet to rural Georgia combines state funding and lower costs for broadband providers. Connecting internet across the state is a priority for lawmakers who see it as a key component for recruiting jobs and residents to rural areas. About 16 percent of Georgians lack access to high-speed internet service. The...
Georgia lawmakers want to pay you to move to the country
Georgia lawmakers want to pay you to move to the country

Georgia legislators are considering giving generous tax breaks to individuals and families who move to rural areas. The combination of state income tax incentives and local property tax discounts could be worth tens of thousands of dollars over the years for anyone who chooses country living. The relocation payments are meant to repopulate rural...
More Stories