Mandate on contraception coverage could be weakened further


Georgians reacted with dismay and cheer Friday to news that the Trump administration is moving to roll back a mandate that health insurance policies cover contraception.

The mandate already exempted houses of worship, and it was weakened following a court case filed by the company Hobby Lobby, which is owned by evangelical Christians who did not want to include contraception in the insurance it offered employees. The administration is quickly acting to broaden that exemption well beyond small private companies such as Hobby Lobby.

Staci Fox, the president of Planned Parenthood Southeast, said if fully implemented, the result is likely to result in more abortions.

“I think what happens when women don’t have access to contraception is the rates of unintended pregnancy go up,” Fox said. “Plain and simple, a woman’s most basic and personal decision, when and where to have a child, could be impacted by their boss.”

Republican state Sen. Renee Unterman framed it as a cost issue. “My opinion is if you’re ever going to get insurance costs down, I think the consumers should have the choice on what they want to pick and choose from,” said Unterman, the chairwoman of the Senate’s health committee.

As to the notion it will increase abortions, she said, “If you don’t have money to pay your insurance premium, you don’t have money for an abortion.”

The news website Vox obtained a leaked copy of the rule. Rather than go through common lengthy procedures, the proposal could become a done deal as soon as it’s published in the Federal Register. The May 23 version posted by Vox would essentially allow any employer to apply for a moral or religious exemption. Vox said there was no way of knowing how much it would resemble the final version.

U.S. Secretary of Health and Human Services Tom Price issued a statement in early May saying he welcomed the opportunity to revisit the contraception mandate, saying “religious liberty is our country’s first freedom.”

Leaders of the Southern Baptist Convention welcomed the news of the coming rule change with “gratitude and hope” in comments published in the Baptist Press. The Southern Baptist Ethics & Religious Liberty Commission’s president, Russell Moore, espied an end to “the audacity of a state that believes it can annex the human conscience.”

Price and his wife, Betty, worship at Johnson Ferry Baptist Church, a key member of the Convention.

What insurance should cover is a vexing question. Insurance companies’ worst nightmare would be if people could just request coverage of what they need — cancer patients, for example, could sign up just for chemotherapy coverage. Insurance works because people pay for things they probably won’t need.

But no one loves paying for coverage they don’t use. Many women, for example, have policies with companies that cover drugs for male sexual disorders.

A study in Health Affairs found that the contraception coverage mandate had saved U.S. women $1.4 billion in out-of-pocket costs per year on the pill alone.

Religious concerns, however, have brought the contraception issue to the fore. President Donald Trump’s order that Price and two other Cabinet secretaries revisit the rule told them “to address conscience-based objections to the preventive-care mandate.”

Women’s rights groups are likely to challenge the proposal in court.

All of that has made it a tricky issue for politicians.

The representatives of some — Republican U.S. Sen. David Perdue and congressional candidates Karen Handel, a Republican, and Jon Ossoff, a Democrat — declined to comment to The Atlanta Journal-Constitution on Friday or said they would need more time.

U.S. Rep. Hank Johnson, a Democrat, said in a statement that pulling back the coverage would result in unintended pregnancies. He called it “mindless” when combined with the administration’s proposal to cut back on a federal nutrition program for infants and children.


Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Georgia Politics

Trump sends sexually suggestive and demeaning tweet about female senator
Trump sends sexually suggestive and demeaning tweet about female senator

WASHINGTON — President Donald Trump attacked Sen. Kirsten Gillibrand, D-N.Y., in a sexually suggestive tweet Tuesday morning that implied Gillibrand would do just about anything for money, prompting an immediate backlash. "Lightweight Senator Kirsten Gillibrand, a total flunky for Charles E. Schumer and someone who would come to my office...
In Alabama, the left wonders if there can even be a winner
In Alabama, the left wonders if there can even be a winner

What is the race for the Alabama Senate seat really about? A roundup of editorials Tuesday takes a look at the issue. From The New York Times: The race isn’t necessarily between Roy Moore and Doug Jones. From ABC: If we gather in our own tribes can we ever get to a consensus on anything? From St. Louis Post Dispatch: What would be next? Firing...
Is the price for a vote in the Senate one the right wants to pay?
Is the price for a vote in the Senate one the right wants to pay?

Election Day is here, and we have to look at the cost of Roy Moore as a United States senator. A roundup of editorials Tuesday takes a look at the issue. From Newsmax: The RNC is trading its soul for a vote in the Senate. From The National Review: Alabamians, Moore has done nothing to earn your vote. From al.com: Will Alabama be remembered as a place...
Last WWII veteran in Georgia Legislature, John Yates, dies
Last WWII veteran in Georgia Legislature, John Yates, dies

John Yates, the last World War II veteran to serve in the Georgia General Assembly, has died. He was 96. Yates became one of a small number of Republicans in the Georgia House at the time he was first elected in 1988. After losing re-election, he ran again in 1992 and remained in office until 2016 representing a district based in Griffin. Yates...
8 candidates file to run for vacant Ga. House and Senate seats
8 candidates file to run for vacant Ga. House and Senate seats

Four candidates are running in each of the two special elections Jan. 9 to fill vacancies in the Georgia Senate and House of Representatives. The elections are being held to fill the seats of former Sen. Rick Jeffares and former Rep. Brian Strickland. Jeffares, R-McDonough, resigned to run for lieutenant governor, and Strickland, R-McDonough,...
More Stories