Historian: Civil War debate is about ‘who controls history’


The demotion of Rep. Tommy Benton, R-Jefferson, following his decision to distribute to colleagues an article challenging that slavery was the root cause of the Civil War raises an interesting question.

Why did he do it?

After all, the Civil War ended more than 150 years ago. Why is a Georgia state legislator so bent out of shape about its causes?

“All of this is about how we think about history,” said Kevin Levin, a Civil War historian and author of the blog “Civil War Memory” blog.

Levin said the debate over the causes of the Civil War has always been as much about contemporary politics and power as it has been about history.

“Who controls history also controls the present,” he said. “It’s about who we are today and who gets to control what.”

Among serious historians, there is little dispute that slavery is the overwhelming cause of the conflict. But Levin said the theory — advanced largely by Southern politicians since the end of Reconstruction — that the Confederates fought for a virtuous “Lost Cause” that didn’t revolve around slavery has been a powerful idea.

The idea has gained new life in recent years as the display of Confederate flags and icons has come under great assault since the 2015 massacre of black church goers in Charleston, S.C., by a white supremacist. And the election of President Donald Trump has emboldened some to make their feelings about white Southern heritage known, including Benton himself.

“We just elected a president that said he was tired of political correctness,” Benton, told a radio station in March. “We think that our heritage is just as important as everybody else’s.”

But is this what we elect our state lawmakers to do? Read more in this week’s AJC Watchdog column here.


Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Georgia Politics

Oxendine suit claims ethics charges are rooted in unconstitutional law
Oxendine suit claims ethics charges are rooted in unconstitutional law

Former Georgia Insurance Commissioner John Oxendine has filed a federal lawsuit against the state ethics commission saying its newest charges against him — that he illegally benefited personally from campaign funds raised for his unsuccessful 2010 gubernatorial run — stem from an unconstitutionally vague state law. Oxendine has been battling...
The Left is condemning the culture of harassment; calls for Conyers to go
The Left is condemning the culture of harassment; calls for Conyers to go

More people are calling for U.S. Rep. John Conyers to resign in the wake of the news of secret payments for congressional sexual harassment claims. A roundup of editorials Wednesday takes a look at the issue. From The Detroit Free Press: Voters in Michigan should have been told of the payoffs to women who claimed Conyers sexually harassed. From The...
The Right is calling for Congress to end secret payments for bad behavior
The Right is calling for Congress to end secret payments for bad behavior

It’s morals run amok in some corners of Congress. And, guess what? Taxpayers get to foot the bill to hush it up. A roundup of editorials Wednesday takes a look at the secret settlement fund. Opinions from the Right: From The Detroit News: Voters were cheated when they were kept in the dark about payments to silence women who accused Conyers of...
Trump promises Americans ‘huge tax cut’ for Christmas
Trump promises Americans ‘huge tax cut’ for Christmas

President Donald Trump on Monday promised a tax overhaul by Christmas, a day after the White House signaled its willingness to strike a health care provision from Senate tax legislation if it’s an impediment to passing the tax bill. Speaking before a Cabinet meeting, Trump said: “We’re going to give the American people a huge tax...
President Trump discounts accusations against Roy Moore
President Trump discounts accusations against Roy Moore

President Donald Trump discounted allegations of sexual assault against Alabama Republican Senate nominee Roy Moore and said Tuesday that voters should not support Moore’s “liberal” rival. Trump addressed the swirling controversy surrounding Moore for the first time since top Republican leaders called on Moore to step aside more than...
More Stories