Historian: Civil War debate is about ‘who controls history’


The demotion of Rep. Tommy Benton, R-Jefferson, following his decision to distribute to colleagues an article challenging that slavery was the root cause of the Civil War raises an interesting question.

Why did he do it?

After all, the Civil War ended more than 150 years ago. Why is a Georgia state legislator so bent out of shape about its causes?

“All of this is about how we think about history,” said Kevin Levin, a Civil War historian and author of the blog “Civil War Memory” blog.

Levin said the debate over the causes of the Civil War has always been as much about contemporary politics and power as it has been about history.

“Who controls history also controls the present,” he said. “It’s about who we are today and who gets to control what.”

Among serious historians, there is little dispute that slavery is the overwhelming cause of the conflict. But Levin said the theory — advanced largely by Southern politicians since the end of Reconstruction — that the Confederates fought for a virtuous “Lost Cause” that didn’t revolve around slavery has been a powerful idea.

The idea has gained new life in recent years as the display of Confederate flags and icons has come under great assault since the 2015 massacre of black church goers in Charleston, S.C., by a white supremacist. And the election of President Donald Trump has emboldened some to make their feelings about white Southern heritage known, including Benton himself.

“We just elected a president that said he was tired of political correctness,” Benton, told a radio station in March. “We think that our heritage is just as important as everybody else’s.”

But is this what we elect our state lawmakers to do? Read more in this week’s AJC Watchdog column here.


Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Georgia Politics

With Atlanta mayor vote, a fabled bipartisan alliance comes to an end
With Atlanta mayor vote, a fabled bipartisan alliance comes to an end

The Republican governor and Democratic mayor shared the stage — and shared plenty of credit — at the opening of Mercedes-Benz Stadium a few months ago. The sense of relief was close to palpable. “I’ll tell you, I sure am happy now. It’s certainly one of the happiest days I’ve been on this job,” said the mayor...
Mayor Reed puts airport exec on leave amid concerns over contracts
Mayor Reed puts airport exec on leave amid concerns over contracts

A high-ranking official at Hartsfield-Jackson International Airport has been placed on administrative leave after the mayor’s office learned that his wife is doing business with an airport subcontractor. A spokeswoman for Mayor Kasim Reed said Friday that the action was taken against Cortez Carter, deputy general manager at the airport, whose...
The Week: Blank says kneeling should not be seen as disrespect
The Week: Blank says kneeling should not be seen as disrespect

Atlanta Falcons owner Arthur Blank offered his own interpretation of protests NFL players have staged this season by kneeling during the national anthem. “It’s very clear that the players have no interest whatsoever in being disrespectful to the flag or the anthem,” Blank told GPB’s Ricky Bevington this past week. &ldquo...
Dunwoody man goes from battling brain cancer to DNR hunting consultant
Dunwoody man goes from battling brain cancer to DNR hunting consultant

When Chip Madren was in seventh grade, doctors told his family the type of brain cancer he had gave him about two more years to live. It was his love of hunting that caused him to fight for his life, his mother said, after being promised a trip to Montana when he got better. “He was not fighting well up until that time,” Lea Madren said...
Move for freer political speech divides Georgia’s religious community
Move for freer political speech divides Georgia’s religious community

It’s a regular ritual on Sundays before big votes: Candidates fan out to churches across the state, take prominent perches near the pulpit and receive warm applause from parishioners. And preachers inevitably shower them with kind words, though they stop short of much more lest they cross an invisible line. That’s exactly what happened...
More Stories