Gingrich right: Death used to beat most people to Social Security age


Social Security today is not the program President Franklin D. Roosevelt had in mind when he signed it into law in 1935, according to former Georgia congressman and House Speaker Newt Gingrich.

“We adopted the modern Social Security system at a time when the average person died before they were old enough to get Social Security,” he said during a Dec. 2 interview on “The John Fredericks Show,” broadcast in Virginia.

“We now have some people who are living 50 years on Social Security,” Gingrich said. “Nobody ever tried to design a system like this, and we’re going to have to rethink our whole approach.”

PolitiFact wondered if Gingrich was right about life expectancy falling short of Social Security age in 1935.

The bill signed by Roosevelt offered benefits to retirees when they turned 65.

U.S. life expectancy for a person born in 1935 was just under 62 years, according to records from the federal Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. On average, girls were expected to live to 64 and boys to 60.

We were curious whether the retirement age was set purposely at 65 to deprive most people of receiving Social Security. Did Roosevelt make this calculation?

“Certainly the Roosevelt administration did not,” said Edward Berkowitz, a professor of public policy at George Washington University and author of several books on Social Security.

“My understanding, that I received from longtime Social Security actuary Robert Myers, was that the age 65 had no particular significance and was chosen because a choice needed to be made and (it) seemed reasonable.”

Myers, who died in 2010, helped to write the Social Security law and in a 1992 memoir offered a simple explanation for how the Roosevelt administration chose the qualifying age for benefits.

“Age 65 was picked because 60 was too young and 70 was too old,” he wrote. “So we split the difference.”

Berkowitz told us that life expectancy at birth - then and now - “is not a good measure of how many people who are working and paying into Social Security will die before age 65.” That’s because the life expectancy average is skewed by infant deaths. After infancy is survived, life expectancy goes up.

That said, we’ll give you one final set of numbers. Average U.S. life expectancy from birth in 2015 was 78.8 years, according to figures just released by the National Center for Health Statistics. It declined from 78.9 in 2014 - the first drop since 1993.

Average life expectancy for men last year was 76.3 years; for women, 81.2.

Our ruling

Gingrich said, “We adopted the modern Social Security system at a time when the average person died before they were old enough to get Social Security.”

We rate his statement True.

For the full fact-check with all sourcing, please see www.politifact.com/virginia/statements/2016/dec/12/newt-gingrich/gingrich-correct-life-expectancy-initially-fell-sh/



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Georgia Politics

Senators vote to open debate on health care law
Senators vote to open debate on health care law

Republican senators voted Tuesday to open debate on revising U.S. health care law, advancing a signature campaign pledge following a tense and dramatic week on Capitol Hill. But the party voted to do so only with the barest of margins, an illustration of the challenges ahead as leaders look to unite a divided and unruly caucus. Johnny Isakson and David...
Georgia senators vote with GOP to open debate on health care repeal
Georgia senators vote with GOP to open debate on health care repeal

Georgia’s two senators, Johnny Isakson and David Perdue, voted with the GOP’s bare majority Tuesday afternoon to open debate on revising U.S. health care law. In a dramatic nail-biter, the GOP senate leadership won a vote that many thought they could lose. But Isakson’s and Perdue’s votes on this step were never seen as in doubt...
Senators on hot mic: Trump is 'crazy,' 'I'm worried'
Senators on hot mic: Trump is 'crazy,' 'I'm worried'

At the end of a Senate subcommittee hearing on Tuesday morning, Chairman Susan Collins, R-Maine, didn't switch off her microphone. Apparently speaking to Sen. Jack Reed, R.I., the ranking Democrat of the committee, Collins discussed the federal budget — and President Donald Trump's lack of familiarity with the details of governing...
White House purge: 'I'm going to fire everybody,' Scaramucci says
White House purge: 'I'm going to fire everybody,' Scaramucci says

WASHINGTON — Anthony Scaramucci, the new White House communications director, threatened on Tuesday to fire his entire staff in an effort to stem the leaking that has plagued President Trump's administration since almost the first day he took office. "I'm going to fire everybody, that's how I'm going to do it," Scaramucci said...
Your Tuesday political briefing: Health care vote; Carter on single-payer; replacing Sessions
Your Tuesday political briefing: Health care vote; Carter on single-payer; replacing Sessions

Here is what is trending in politics around Georgia and across the nation on Monday. 1. Health care vote set for Tuesday The Senate has scheduled a procedural vote Tuesday on the Republican health care bill. The vote would allow debate to begin on a bill that could repeal and replace the Affordable Care Act. Sen. John McCain, (R-Arizona), will be traveling...
More Stories