You have reached your limit of free articles this month.

Enjoy unlimited access to myAJC.com

Starting at just 99¢ for 8 weeks.

GREAT REASONS TO SUBSCRIBE TODAY!

  • IN-DEPTH REPORTING
  • INTERACTIVE STORYTELLING
  • NEW TOPICS & COVERAGE
  • ePAPER
X

You have read of premium articles.

Get unlimited access to all of our breaking news, in-depth coverage and bonus content- exclusively for subscribers. Starting at just 99¢ for 8 weeks

X

Welcome to myAJC.com

This subscriber-only site gives you exclusive access to breaking news, in-depth coverage, exclusive interactives and bonus content.

You can read free articles of your choice a month that are only available on myAJC.com.

Georgia governor slams ‘religious liberty’ change to adoption bill


Gov. Nathan Deal on Monday said he opposes a late Senate effort to add “religious liberty” protections to an unrelated bill dealing with adoptions, a change that could allow private adoption agencies receiving public money to refuse to place children with LGBT families.

The governor’s message could stall the measure in the Legislature’s final days of the 2017 session, and it suggests the bill would face his veto if it passed with the change intact. But, with negotiations over dozens of bills ongoing in the waning days, no bill is dead for sure until the gavel falls on the final day.

“I certainly don’t want that to happen, and I would hope they would reconsider the addition to this language that could put the whole bill in jeopardy,” Deal said.

House Bill 159, a bipartisan bill to modernize Georgia’s adoption laws, was changed late Thursday in the Senate Judiciary Committee to include language that would protect private adoption agencies that receive state money but don’t want to place children with all families.

The move on a 7-4 vote would essentially protect agencies that may have a faith-based mission and do not want to place children with same-sex couples, although it could be applied broadly. All seven votes in favor were from Republican senators; the four voting “no” were Democrats.

Supporters of the change on the committee said it could also apply to an agency with a mission to place children with African-American families, for example.

“It’s just a matter of what options you can provide in the placement of children,” said state Sen. William Ligon, R-Brunswick, who authored the change. “We should do all that we can to ensure those needs are met. It is recognizing the diversity in our culture.”

Others who supported the measure said anyone concerned by the move needed to consider how it could help more children find homes.

“Isn’t it true there are adoption agencies that place children with homosexual families?” asked state Sen. Hunter Hill, R-Smyrna. By not allowing agencies to discern who they want to serve, he said, it meant that “everybody’s just got to be vanilla with no passion.”

State Sen. Greg Kirk, R-Americus, who sponsored a major religious liberty bill last year that Deal eventually vetoed, called it a “big” bill for the chamber to move forward.

Kirk also asked state officials whether they already worked with agencies under similar arrangements. They said no.

Bobby Cagle, the director at the state’s Division of Family and Children Services, said the agency uses state and federal money working with some adoption agencies that have particular specialties, such as those that help place developmentally disabled children. But he said none of the 89 agencies the department works with are allowed to specialize in placing children with families of a single race, for example.

Cagle also said while the department works with agencies that are affiliated with churches, the rules say those agencies cannot discriminate against the religion of the child or purposely weed out those who don’t have the same faith.

The committee’s decision, he added, would endanger “hundreds of millions of dollars” the agency received from the federal government because they appear to violate federal nondiscrimination laws.

Cagle’s office said he was referring to the department’s requirement to comply with the Civil Rights Act to receive federal funds.

The DFCS director handed out a Justice Department memo to Senate Judiciary Committee members before the vote that said the law’s Title VI provision is an “overarching anti-discrimination statute that applies to the programs and activities of all entities receiving federal financial assistance.”

The changes to HB 159 were done over the objections of its sponsor, state Rep. Bert Reeves, R-Marietta, who said he had been notified of them less than two hours before Thursday’s hearing. Reeves on Monday said he was aware of Deal’s comments and said he and the governor “are on the same page.”

Georgia’s top business leaders condemned the Senate’s move.

“We are opposed to the recent changes made to HB 159 that could allow groups receiving state taxpayer dollars to discriminate against other Georgians,” the public policy directors of the Metro Atlanta Chamber and Georgia Chamber of Commerce said in a joint statement.

Democrats on the Judiciary Committee said it’s wrong for public dollars to subsidize discrimination. If an adoption agency enters “into a contract with the government that is taxpayer-funded, they are bound to provide it in a nonsecular fashion,” said state Sen. Elena Parent, D-Atlanta.

“It’s inappropriate for your tax dollars to discriminate against you,” she said.

Lost in the fight over the amendment was the need for Reeves’ original version of the bill. The second-term lawmaker has worked for the past two years to modernize the state’s adoption laws. Melissa Carter, the director of the Barton Child Law and Policy Center at Emory University, said Reeves’ bill is needed.

“Over time things get outdated, and it’s time to step back and look at the entirety of the (adoption) code,” Carter said. “As a legal practice, adoption is a highly technical area. Over time it needs to be updated and modernized.”

Carter said she is concerned both that the bill passes as amended and that the entire bill is defeated because of Ligon’s change.

“It’s certainly a possibility that the entire bill could be lost as a casualty of these efforts,” she said.

The bill is now before the Senate Rules Committee, which will decide whether it will get a floor vote. That panel did not add HB 159 to the Senate’s agenda for Wednesday, which is when lawmakers next meet.

Staff writer Greg Bluestein contributed to this article.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Georgia Politics

Georgia’s ready for its close-up after earning a No. 1 film ranking
Georgia’s ready for its close-up after earning a No. 1 film ranking

Georgia has spent hundreds of millions of dollars rolling out its red carpet for movie-makers. And a new report says it’s paid off, with the state being named the No. 1 filming location worldwide. More top 100 feature films released at the domestic box office in 2016 were made in Georgia than any other place, according to a new industry study...
Boosters slam feds’ decision to withhold money from Savannah project
Boosters slam feds’ decision to withhold money from Savannah project

Georgia’s public officials were caught off guard Thursday after the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, the federal agency tasked with overseeing the project to deepen Savannah’s harbor, decided against giving the effort any extra money. Boosters of the state’s top development project were counting on the federal agency to send...
Savannah port boosters decry feds’ move to withhold additional funds
Savannah port boosters decry feds’ move to withhold additional funds

Georgia’s public officials were caught off guard Thursday after the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, the federal agency tasked with overseeing the project to deepen Savannah’s harbor, decided against giving the effort any extra money. Boosters of the state’s top development project were counting on the federal agency to send tens of...
Why Stacey Evans is running for Georgia governor
Why Stacey Evans is running for Georgia governor

Democratic state Rep. Stacey Evans entered the race for Georgia governor on Thursday with a pledge to make technical colleges tuition-free and a vow to fight for struggling Georgians ignored by the powerful. The Smyrna attorney’s campaign sets up what will likely be a divisive Democratic primary for the state’s top job in 2018. House Minority...
Analysis: Could Donald Trump issue himself a pardon?
Analysis: Could Donald Trump issue himself a pardon?

Shortly before the 2016 presidential election, an interesting constitutional thought experiment emerged: If Hillary Clinton did deserve to be locked up, in the eloquent articulation of Donald Trump supporters, could she use the power of the presidential pardon on … herself? On Nov. 8, the question became pointless, as we learned that Clinton...
More Stories