Bill approved protecting private probation companies


The Legislature gave final approval Thursday to a bill that was designed to protect the private probation business in Georgia and grew to block key information about the industry from public view.

House Bill 837 was drafted to address issues that a Richmond County judge raised in September in a ruling in 14 pending lawsuits that the industry feared would destroy it.

The lawyer who brought the suits said HB 837 should have no effect on the suits or an appeal of Judge Daniel Craig’s ruling before the Georgia Supreme Court.

Private companies have managed probation supervision in state and local courts since 2001 for people found guilty of misdemeanors or violating local ordinances.

An Atlanta Journal-Constitution investigation earlier this year found that such companies have pocketed large fees while, in at least some cases, doing little to supervise those under their watch.

For the most part, people who have been convicted of minor offenses — such as traffic violations, public drunkenness, possession of small amounts of marijuana — are placed on probation because they don’t have the money to pay their court fines all at once. As they pay off their fines, they also pay monthly supervision fees to the probation companies of $35 to $45, along with other costs that might involve electronic monitoring or drug and alcohol testing.

Last year, 14 former probationers filed lawsuits in Richmond County claiming they were charged for electronic monitoring and drug testing that the courts did not order. They said their probation officers threatened to have them jailed if they didn’t pay, despite their claims that they didn’t have the money. Each one said in the suits that they were arrested years after they thought they had completed their sentences, and that they were held in jail, at local taxpayers’ expense, until they paid their debts to the company. In this case, that was Sentinel Offender Services, the largest of the probation companies operating in the state and the contractor for Richmond County.

A key issue in the suits is the practice of tolling, which involves courts, at the behest of the private probation companies, stopping the clock on sentences for probationers who have stopped reporting and are no longer paying their supervision fees.

Craig ruled that it was unconstitutional to stop the clock from running on probationers supervised by a private company. He also said private probation companies could not provide electronic monitoring.

Though the lawsuits only named Sentinel, the other 33 companies operating in Georgia joined in the legislative fight out of concern over Craig’s ruling.

HB 837 would allow tolling to continue and permit companies to charge for electronic monitoring, but Jack Long, the Augusta lawyer who brought the 14 suits in Richmond County, said the bill won’t affect his cases.

The biggest impact of the bill, he said, “is it further restricts the open records statute.”

HB 837 would keep secret from the public such basic information as how many low-level offenders are under the companies’ supervision, how much they collected in court fines and how many arrest warrants have been issued as a result of tolling. If a court asks, the companies must tell it how much they collected in fees for supervision, electronic monitoring, and drug and alcohol testing, but the public cannot see that information.

Sarah Geraghty, an attorney with the Southern Center for Human Rights, has said that she can think “of no rational reason to hide such information from members of the public.”

The industry also fought off an effort to include a cap on supervision fees in HB 837.

The Private Probation Association of Georgia declined to comment on the bill’s final passage. The bill now awaits the signature of the governor before it becomes law.

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Georgia Politics

First American title pawn pays $225K for alleged violations against Georgia customers
First American title pawn pays $225K for alleged violations against Georgia customers

A Georgia title pawn company is paying about $225,000 to settle allegations that it sued customers who defaulted on loans, threatened customers with arrest warrants and misrepresented itself in advertisements. Georgia Attorney General Chris Carr announced last week that First American Title Lending of Georgia will make the payment in response...
The Left warns that GOP tax reform will help no one but the rich
The Left warns that GOP tax reform will help no one but the rich

Tax reform bills offer a break, the left says, but they are a break for businesses, not families. A roundup of editorials Monday takes a look at the issue.Opinions from the Left:1. For tax reform worthy of the name, make it pro-employmentFrom The Hill: Now, just how is this plan going to help American workers? 2. Tax-Cut Bill to Make Scrooge...
The Right looks forward to the relief promised by tax reform
The Right looks forward to the relief promised by tax reform

Will tax reform bills in Congress offer Americans families a break? A roundup of editorials Monday takes a look at the issue. From The Oregonian: Oregon Sen. Jeff Merkley warns that the tax reform bill isn’t what you may think it is. From The Democrat-Gazette: Arkansas State Sen. Jason Rapert says the tax reform plan is the best shot for reinvestment...
Some ACA premiums fall while others spike; enrollment keeps surging
Some ACA premiums fall while others spike; enrollment keeps surging

Tyrone Jenkins sat in his insurance agent’s office on Friday, relieved about his health insurance. After all the upheaveal and news over skyrocketing Obamacare premiums, Jenkins will actually see his coverage costs plummet next year. He’ll pay less than half in 2018 what he did in 2017 for similar coverage. How can this be? Jenkins doesn&rsquo...
Democrats aim for suburbs in Alabama ahead of Deep South votes
Democrats aim for suburbs in Alabama ahead of Deep South votes

Amanda Wilson has watched with a mix of glee and uncertainty as the imposing homes along this wealthy suburban town’s zigzagging streets has suddenly sprouted Democratic signs. “I’m a blue dot in a big red state,” said Wilson, a 64-year-old retiree. “But I don’t feel as lonely anymore.” Republican U.S. Senate...
More Stories