Study finds merit pay for teachers could have merit

Georgia teachers are currently paid by traditional measures, such as seniority


Georgia hasn’t gone there, but not so long ago the idea of moving the state’s public school teachers into a “merit” pay system was a topic of heated debate, with none other than the Gov. Nathan Deal pushing the notion.

The governor wanted a portion of teachers’ pay to “go to how good a teacher they are,” but he also acknowledged the political reality that teacher advocacy groups were opposed, claiming it would undermine teamwork in schools.

That was over a year ago, and Deal has backed off. Teachers are still paid based on traditional measures, such as seniority.

Now, a new review of research on the issue suggests Deal might have been onto something, though there are caveats.

A Vanderbilt “meta-analysis” of 44 studies -- an analysis of other researchers’ work -- finds that basing pay on students test results can “improve the composition of the workforce” and produce a “modest” but statistically significant association with performance.

The report by doctoral students Lam D. Pham and Tuan D. Nguyen was co-led by Matthew G. Springer, assistant professor of public policy and education at Vanderbilt’s Peabody College of education and human development. They combed through more than 19,000 research reports before settling on the 44 primary studies that informed their key finding, which was that merit pay has an effect equal to four additional weeks of learning. They attribute this to increased motivation of teachers and the ability to attract and attain more effective teachers.

They offer cautions about both the research they used and the nature of merit pay systems studied. The schemes that appeared to be most effective, they found, seemed to reflect the concerns of Georgia teachers: the best results derived from rewarding group, rather than individual, performance.


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Education

In tracking student leaders on social media, is Georgia Tech off track?
In tracking student leaders on social media, is Georgia Tech off track?

Matt Wolfsen was a high school junior in 2012 when a fired teacher stormed into his private high school in Jacksonville, Fla., and shot the headmistress to death and killed himself. In the building when the shooting occurred, Wolfsen said he realized he had to look up from his calculus and become more politically active. He...
Feds question legality of Georgia school plan
Feds question legality of Georgia school plan

Georgia’s plan to comply with new federal education law has hit a bump in the road, with the U.S. Department of Education saying at least one of the state’s proposals doesn’t comply with federal law. State officials characterized much of Washington’s 7-page letter as minor requests for “clarification” that can easily...
In tracking student leaders on social media, is Georgia Tech off track?
In tracking student leaders on social media, is Georgia Tech off track?

Matt Wolfsen was a high school junior in 2012 when a fired teacher stormed into his private high school in Jacksonville, Fla., and shot the headmistress to death and killed himself. In the building when the shooting occurred, Wolfsen said he realized he had to look up from his calculus and become more politically active. He...
Olens resigns at KSU; national search for successor planned
Olens resigns at KSU; national search for successor planned

Kennesaw State University student and faculty leaders critical of Sam Olens hope its next president will be picked based on the person’s academic qualifications, not a political resume. Georgia’s Board of Regents will conduct a national search to replace Olens, who announced Thursday he will resign, effective Feb. 15. Many faculty and students...
Sam Olens to leave Kennesaw State University
Sam Olens to leave Kennesaw State University

Sam Olens announced Thursday he’s stepping down as Kennesaw State University’s president on Feb. 15, after mounting criticism of his handling of a protest by some cheerleaders and other decisions. A state report released last month found Olens ignored guidelines on how to respond to student protests concerning the national anthem....
More Stories