Georgia Legislature: Should school recess be mandatory or optional?

Proposed school recess mandate could become a recommendation instead


Legislation that mandates recess in Georgia elementary schools could instead become just a recommendation. 

When House Bill 273 passed the House of Representatives 147-17 on March 3, it required an average of 30 minutes per day of recess in kindergarten through fifth grade, except on days with physical education or other “structured activity.”

At a hearing in the Senate Education and Youth Committee on Monday, though, Sen. Lindsey Tippins, R-Marietta, the committee chairman, asked that the mandate be replaced with a recommendation: instead of saying schools “shall” give recess, he asked that the bill say schools should “strive” to do it.

Tippins said most schools already provide recess, but one mother and former teacher who testified said she preferred a mandate.

Lisa Coronado, a former high school math teacher in DeKalb County, recalled how five years ago her students told her that as elementary school students they didn’t get much recess.

Deleting the word “shall,” she said, “takes all the teeth out of it.”

The bill was held for amendments and another hearing. Author Rep. Demetrius Douglas, D-Stockbridge, seemed amenable to the change, saying Tippins’ request was “fair.”

Children and one expert lobbied lawmakers last month to approve the bill, saying it is counterproductive to focus on academics all day without a break to play. Critics of the measure say schools are already squeezed for time to meet existing mandates to reach milestones on schedule for learning reading, writing and math.


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Education

College Jimmy Carter attended dedicates plaza to him
College Jimmy Carter attended dedicates plaza to him

Georgia Southwestern State University held a dedication ceremony Friday for a plaza named after former President Jimmy Carter. Carter attended the university in 1941 and 1942. The former president and former First Lady Rosalynn Carter, also an alumni of the university, attended. The plaza, at the main entrance to the campus, includes a mounted signature...
DeKalb will extend school day by 20 minutes for days lost to Hurricane Irma
DeKalb will extend school day by 20 minutes for days lost to Hurricane Irma

The DeKalb County School District will lengthen its school days by 20 minutes through December to make up for closing four days last week due to Hurricane Irma. This has been done before by other metro districts. Gwinnett and Decatur extended their school days for 30 minutes in 2014 ...
South Georgia college to unveil plaza named after Jimmy Carter
South Georgia college to unveil plaza named after Jimmy Carter

Georgia Southwestern State University has a dedication ceremony set Friday for a plaza named after former President Jimmy Carter. Carter attended the university in 1941 and 1942. The former president and former First Lady Rosalynn Carter, also an alumni of the university, are scheduled to attend. The plaza will be located at the main entrance to campus...
Atlanta school board adopts millage rate
Atlanta school board adopts millage rate

After months of budget uncertainty, the Atlanta Board of Education set a millage rate for the current fiscal year of 21.74 mills. The board held a final public hearing Thursday before unanimously voting to approve the fiscal year 2018 rate. The rate reflects an increase due to reassessments of about .098 of a mill, according to numbers provided to...
KKK roleplaying and crude rap lyrics: Mistakes but should they end careers?
KKK roleplaying and crude rap lyrics: Mistakes but should they end careers?

Education professor Peter Smagorinsky peppers his University of Georgia undergraduate students with daily email compendiums of teachers-gone-wrong news stories under the heading “Don’t try this at home.” “I share these stories any time a teacher gets in hot water due to poor judgment so my...
More Stories