Georgia Legislature: Should school recess be mandatory or optional?

Proposed school recess mandate could become a recommendation instead


Legislation that mandates recess in Georgia elementary schools could instead become just a recommendation. 

When House Bill 273 passed the House of Representatives 147-17 on March 3, it required an average of 30 minutes per day of recess in kindergarten through fifth grade, except on days with physical education or other “structured activity.”

At a hearing in the Senate Education and Youth Committee on Monday, though, Sen. Lindsey Tippins, R-Marietta, the committee chairman, asked that the mandate be replaced with a recommendation: instead of saying schools “shall” give recess, he asked that the bill say schools should “strive” to do it.

Tippins said most schools already provide recess, but one mother and former teacher who testified said she preferred a mandate.

Lisa Coronado, a former high school math teacher in DeKalb County, recalled how five years ago her students told her that as elementary school students they didn’t get much recess.

Deleting the word “shall,” she said, “takes all the teeth out of it.”

The bill was held for amendments and another hearing. Author Rep. Demetrius Douglas, D-Stockbridge, seemed amenable to the change, saying Tippins’ request was “fair.”

Children and one expert lobbied lawmakers last month to approve the bill, saying it is counterproductive to focus on academics all day without a break to play. Critics of the measure say schools are already squeezed for time to meet existing mandates to reach milestones on schedule for learning reading, writing and math.


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Education

Clark Atlanta official departs from university
Clark Atlanta official departs from university

A high-ranking Clark Atlanta University administrator who some students wanted fired is no longer with the university, officials say. Vice President for Student Affairs Tanaya Walters left the university on June 30, said spokeswoman Donna Brock. Brock declined to discuss about her departure, saying the university doesn’t discuss personnel matters...
Alarmed National PTA to Georgia PTA: We can’t allow you to further tarnish our brand
Alarmed National PTA to Georgia PTA: We can’t allow you to further tarnish our brand

After a power play that ousted a popular president and caused local units to consider abandoning the Georgia PTA, the state leadership now seems bent on self-destruction. Already on probation, the group has run afoul of National PTA again by its clumsy manipulation of the election process. In a strong letter sent today...
As school starts, parents wrangle for best teachers
As school starts, parents wrangle for best teachers

  Principals have already assigned most students to classrooms for the start of school, but as parents learn who’ll be teaching their child, some will try to wrangle a change.  The right teacher can have a profound effect on how much a student learns — whether he or she excels or stumbles, with implications for years...
Deadlines approaching for Georgia students to take Aug. 26 SAT 
Deadlines approaching for Georgia students to take Aug. 26 SAT 

Students who want to take the SAT on Aug. 26 are running out of time to sign up to take the college entrance exam. The initial deadline is Friday, July 28, according to the College Board, which organizes the SAT. The final deadline to sign up electronically or by telephone is Aug. 15. College Board officials are offering the SAT for the first time...
Opinion: Next week is too early to go back to school. Bring back summer.
Opinion: Next week is too early to go back to school. Bring back summer.

Camila Knowles is the mother of four, a supporter of Save Georgia Summers, and commissioner of the Georgia Department of Community Affairs. In this column, she asks a question shared by many Georgia parents buying school supplies this week in 90 degree weather: Is there any compelling reason for Georgia schools to end the summer...
More Stories