Opinion: Gwinnett chief’s actions reflect well on a department and profession

Recently released cellphone videos showing two Gwinnett County police officers hitting a man in the face and kicking him in the head while handcuffed set off a firestorm of criticism and condemnation.

The first cellphone video that went viral clearly showed a non-resisting man on the ground with the supervisor who had just finished applying handcuffs. Then, a second officer, presumably his backup, arrived and runs over to the prone man and literally stomps on his face. The second video that went viral showed the supervisor removing the man from his car. The man is seen to place his hands above his head when the supervisor strikes him in the face with his forearm.

Here, the videos of the Gwinnett incident were clear and presented compelling evidence for the police chief to act decisively and without delay. The information both officers wrote in their reports about their use of physical force, coupled with the cellphone videos is imperative to understanding the police chief’s reasoning for taking firm, necessary and quick action to terminate the employment of both officers. With the above facts known, the chief commenced an independent criminal investigation into the actions of the two officers.

The actions taken by Chief Ayers of the Gwinnett County Police Department were administrative and involved departmental policies, procedures, and employment rules. The burden of proof in administrative cases is a “preponderance of the evidence”. This is a much-lower threshold than that required in the prosecution of a criminal case, which is “beyond a reasonable doubt.”

When any chief has clear and convincing evidence of a serious policy violation or violations of the law, they must act swiftly in administrative situations that may cause termination or reprimand. Therefore, the public should understand that not every case of alleged police misconduct can be handled as quickly as it occurred in the Gwinnett case.

A criminal investigation will generally take longer than an administrative or internal affairs investigation. Videos must be more closely examined for they may or may not accurately depict the entire circumstances of the police/citizen encounter. Also, with criminal investigations, witnesses and officers must be interviewed and an investigation once completed is reviewed by a prosecutor.

Using force, even lawful use of force, is not the desired approach law enforcement prefers to use. However, force is lawful when it is necessary, reasonable and furthers a legal police objective. If a person resists a lawful arrest, the officer may then use force to overcome that resistance. Once the resistance stops, the officer’s use of force must also stop.

The swift action and statements made by Chief Ayers clarify that such behavior is outside policy and will not be tolerated. The actions taken by Chief Ayers is one reason the Gwinnett County Police Department is deemed to be an outstanding Nationally Accredited and State Certified law enforcement agency.

Police officers in Gwinnett and in countless number of departments across the nation are doing their jobs in a professional and ethical manner. I encourage you to praise our 21st-century centurions for their commitment to professional policing and to the citizens they serve.

Frank V. Rotondo is executive director, Georgia Association of Chiefs of Police.

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Opinion

Readers Write: Dec. 15

Salt, sand great for roads but bad for cars Wow! Our first decent snowfall in years. The state and city seem to have responded pretty well to mitigating the snow and ice conditions on our roads. One thing I learned from my winters in Maine is when the road crews start putting down brine, rock salt and sand, while they do a great job of providing traction...

(YouTube) I swear, these people have lost their ever-lovin’ minds. They have snipped their last tethers to reality and gone floating off into a fantasy land of their own creation. Take our own U.S. Rep. Doug Collins, Republican from Georgia. In a House Judiciary Committee hearing on Wednesday, Collins joined his GOP colleagues...
Opinion: What should we fight for?

“We will never accept Russia’s occupation and attempted annexation of Crimea,” declaimed Rex Tillerson last week in Vienna. “Crimea-related sanctions will remain in place until Russia returns full control of the peninsula to Ukraine.” Tillerson’s principled rejection of the seizure of land by military force &mdash...
COMMENTARY: Alabama, sweet home of progress

Alabama. Who knew it would become one of the most beautiful words in American politics? It turns out there could have been no better place to test the limits of indecency, the limits of Trumpism, the limits of Republican partisanship and, yes, the limits of racial subjugation. If the angry ideology of the far right cannot make it in one of our most...
Opinion: Can the GOP avoid more losses like Alabama next year?

Now we know what it takes for the Republicans to lose in a deep-red state like Alabama. Start with a special election. Add an interim replacement whose appointment came amid somewhat sketchy circumstances. Mix in a now-standard fight between the establishment and the self-proclaimed “swamp drainers.” Let the two factions go to a run-off...
More Stories