Opinion: Can the GOP avoid more losses like Alabama next year?

Now we know what it takes for the Republicans to lose in a deep-red state like Alabama.

Start with a special election. Add an interim replacement whose appointment came amid somewhat sketchy circumstances. Mix in a now-standard fight between the establishment and the self-proclaimed “swamp drainers.” Let the two factions go to a run-off while the Democrats raise money and organize. Watch in amazement as the president supports the interim replacement, but strongly hints he actually favors the challenger. Nominate the challenger, a man who already has a history of faring more poorly than other GOP candidates in statewide races. Watch in shock as that man is credibly accused by multiple women of sexual misconduct when they were teenagers and he was a grown man. Let the shock deepen as the nominee stumbles but refuses to step down, even though there’s time to find a Plan B. Let additional details and accusations drip, drip, drip.

And that — all of it — is how you get Sen.-elect Doug Jones, D-Alabama.

There is no Sen.-elect Jones without GOP nominee Roy Moore. And unless GOP primary voters across America decide to nominate a slew of candidates in next year’s midterm elections as fatally flawed as Moore, Jones’ shocking win in Tuesday’s run-off isn’t much of a template for other long-shot Democrats.

Yes, Democrats organized furiously, pumped in the funding and boosted turnout far above what’s typical in a special election. But they did virtually the same thing in Georgia’s 6th Congressional District earlier this year and fell short. Had the Alabama GOP nominated a candidate the caliber of Karen Handel — or simply kept the unloved interim senator, Luther Strange — we’d probably be talking about a different outcome.

Even the closest analogue in recent memory, Scott Brown’s stunning win in deep-blue Massachusetts to replace Ted Kennedy in 2010, doesn’t quite cover it. Yes, the Democrat in that race, Martha Coakley, was an awful candidate who, for starters, didn’t know a Red Sox World Series hero (Curt Schilling) from a Yankees fan. But that election also turned in large part on the policy debates at the time — especially the one over Obamacare — and voter angst over Democrats’ filibuster-proof majority in the Senate.

There is virtually no sign that was the case in Alabama. According to an exit poll, half of voters Tuesday wanted the GOP to control the Senate, vs. 44 percent who preferred Democrats. But about 8 percent of those who favored GOP control didn’t vote for Moore, including 2 percent who wrote in a candidate.

It takes a bad candidate running a bad campaign to turn off voters who want that candidate’s party to be in charge. Roy Moore was that candidate.

Not that the GOP should be complacent, or Democrats less than exuberant about 2018. The No. 1 fundamental in our current politics is voter unease with giving either of our widely disliked major parties too much power for too long. If that isn’t specifically why Jones beat Moore in Alabama, it still remains a very relevant fact going into next year.

The GOP will have to work hard at candidate recruitment and vetting, staying unified and on message, and the usual elements of organization and fund-raising — not to mention notching some legislative wins in Congress — if it’s to avoid the usual fate of the majority party in midterms. The results from Alabama suggest the party’s not ready to do all that.

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Opinion

Opinion: What is the real message of #MeToo?

The feminist website Babe published an account of a date gone bad. The pushback has been swift and sharp. I share some of the concerns of the critics, but I also think young women are sending a message that is being missed. The account by the anonymous “Grace” about a bad date with comedian Aziz Ansari was, if not “3,000 words of...
Readers Write: Jan. 22

Perdue on wrong side of history It is now clear that U.S. Sen. David Perdue has no intention of separating himself from the racist attitudes on immigration that President Trump recently articulated. That is because Trump represents Perdue’s own attitudes and positions. However it may appear to him at this moment, history teaches us clearly that...
Readers Write: Jan. 21

Nonpartisan committee needed for districting maps News about gerrymandering seems to be everywhere … in the AJC, on radio and TV. A decision of the federal court in North Carolina overturned maps because of extreme partisan gerrymandering. Two cases currently before the Supreme Court involve Republican gerrymandering in Wisconsin and Democratic...
Opinion: Journalists must give light; public can find its way

I was wrong. Years ago, people used to ask me what journalists should do to combat the nation’s drift toward “factish” and “truthy” logic. What was needed, I’d reply with misplaced confidence, is robust fact-checking. If news media were more aggressive in calling people out for lying, I predicted, they’d be...
Opinion: Choosing immigration criteria is a Sisyphean task

WASHINGTON — In 1790, the finest mind in the First Congress, and of his generation, addressed in the House of Representatives the immigration issue: “It is no doubt very desirable that we should hold out as many inducements as possible for the worthy part of mankind to come and settle amongst us.” Perhaps today’s 115th Congress...
More Stories