Waffle House sex tapes case: Is your bedroom a private place?

Georgia Supreme Court hears arguments on indictments


Another piece of the litigation surrounding the intimate relationship of Waffle House chairman Joe W. Rogers Jr. and his housekeeper/personal assistant went before the Georgia Supreme Court on Monday.

In this iteration, the state was asking the high court to reinstate felony charges against the housekeeper, Mye Brindle, and her two attorneys, David Cohen and John Butters. The three were indicted on extortion charges after Cohen sent a letter to Rogers informing him that Brindle had secretly videotaped their sexual trysts. The letter recommended that Rogers reach a settlement with Brindle before she filed a suit and exposed their relationship.

Monday’s hearing focused on whether a threat to sue may be interpreted as extortion and on whether Rogers’ had an expectation of privacy in his bedroom.

A ruling is expected later this year.

Representing Cohen, Atlanta attorney Brian Steel cited case law that says “neither the threat to file a lawsuit nor the filing of a lawsuit constitutes an attempted extortion or a conspiracy to commit extortion.”

Arguing in behalf of the Fulton County District Attorney’s Office, which obtained the indictment of Brindle and her lawyers, F. McDonald Wakeford said Brindle and her lawyers “came up with a plan to break laws in order to bring this lawsuit.”

Wakeford also expressed disbelief about the issue of privacy, particularly in places like a bedroom and a bathroom where the alleged misbehavior occurred.

To say that these rooms were not private places flies in the face of common sense and decades of Georgia case law,” Wakeford said.

He said he disagreed with Steel’s contention that it was not a crime to record what was going on inside Rogers’ home if only one person — Brindle, in this instance — consented to the recordings. Fulton County Superior Court Judge Henry Newkirk made such a finding when dismissing the indictment last fall.

“The state is here to say that the consent of all persons observed in a private place is required in order for the recording of activities to be OK,” Wakeford said, referring specifically to a videotape.

Steel countered that “a private place is defined … as a place where one is entitled to reasonably expect to be safe from casual or hostile intrusion or surveillance.” In his filing with the court, Steel had argued, “A person engaged in an extramarital relationship loses his right to privacy as to the extramarital conduct.”

Justice Harold Melton asked: “Is there any place where people can engage in these activities that would be private, if not in their own home?”

The indictments charging Brindle, Cohen and Butters with conspiracy to commit extortion, conspiracy to commit unlawful eavesdropping or surveillance and unlawful eavesdropping or surveillance. After Newkirk dismissed the case, the Fulton DA’s office appealed.

On Sept. 17, 2012, Rogers sued Brindle in Cobb County, seeking to stop her from making the recordings public. Two days later, Brindle sued Rogers in Fulton County, alleging that she had “made audio and video recordings of some of the incidents of sexual harassment and battery including the sexual battery at the Sea Island home.”

That suit prompted Rogers to publicly acknowledge the relationship, saying he had “infrequent sexual encounters” with Brindle. But he denied sexually harassing her.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Getting ready for metro Atlanta’s next transportation revolution
Getting ready for metro Atlanta’s next transportation revolution

An electric driverless shuttle produced by EasyMile drives, as part of an experiment, in Paris on Friday. The fully electric autonomous vehicle is made by French company EasyMile, one of multiple French driverless car projects. AP/Christophe Ena Please seal this column in an envelope and give it a place on a back shelf for the next 20...
Cops: DUI crash leaves motorcyclist in hospital with life-threatening injuries
Cops: DUI crash leaves motorcyclist in hospital with life-threatening injuries

An alleged drunken driver is in the Cobb County jail after police say he hit a motorcyclist outside an apartment complex. Clarence Blackshear, 47, of Marietta, is accused of hitting Jacob Schirm, 20, of Alpharetta, outside the Silver Creek Apartments on Roswell Road about 9:30 p.m. Thursday, Marietta police Officer Jared Rakestraw said.  Blackshear...
Former Atlanta fire chief claims discrimination in civil rights suit
Former Atlanta fire chief claims discrimination in civil rights suit

A federal judge on Friday had questions about why Mayor Kasim Reed dismissed Atlanta’s fire chief in 2015, asking attorneys representing the city if the decision was based primarily on the contents of the chief’s controversial book or his insubordination. Fire chief Kelvin Cochran was terminated after he wrote and distributed a book that...
Recount shows Michael Julian Bond might retain Atlanta Council seat
Recount shows Michael Julian Bond might retain Atlanta Council seat

Michael Julian Bond will apparently retain his at-large council seat, but just barely, according to the unofficial results of a Fulton County vote recount on Friday. For the past couple of weeks, the outcome of the race wasn’t clear. First, there was supposed to be a recount, then a runoff, then a recount again. Earlier this week, election officials...
‘Political Rewind’ replay: Shirley Franklin on the ATL race for mayor

With former mayor Shirley Franklin in the house, today’s edition of GPB’s “Political Rewind” couldn’t help but start out with a look at the Atlanta mayor’s race between Keisha Lance Bottoms and Mary Norwood. Franklin repeated her contention that trust was a basic issue in the campaign &ndash...
More Stories