‘Breakdown’ S06, Ep. 1: A Jury of His Peers


The four men – two in each car – had a rendezvous at a gas station near I-285. Then they decided to drive both cars across the road to the new Burger King.

It was a few minutes before midnight, closing time for the restaurant. The two vehicles pulled in. Two men got out of the black sedan – the car has never been identified – and joined the two men sitting in the blue Pontiac.

» Listen to earlier seasons of “Breakdown”

» Photos: Images from Season 6 of ‘Breakdown’

What happens next is the subject of the sixth season of our “Breakdown” podcast, hosted this season by Kevin Riley, the editor of The Atlanta Journal-Constitution, and the AJC’s legal affairs writer, Bill Rankin. The first episode went live on Monday.

And here’s what happened next: Almost immediately, the man who had just gotten into the rear passenger-side seat started shooting. He got off 10 shots from a .40-caliber Glock, shooting the man directly in front of him in the head twice at nearly point-black range. The shooter’s companion also was hit. He would later die en route to the hospital.

The driver of the car, who apparently had just been giving a friend a ride, leaped from the Bonneville and fled. Police eventually caught him running on I-285 North; in fact, a police car ran into him.

The fourth man, the one with the Glock, got out of the Bonneville, hopped into the black sedan and disappeared.

Reginald Coicou, 24, and Quincy “Fat” Wytche, 24, were killed just before midnight on April 24, 2016. So began a homicide investigation and then a prosecution that eventually pulled a very diverse group of people into its orbit. One of them was Kevin Riley, the AJC’s editor.

Riley gained extraordinary access to police and prosecutors in this double-murder case, and he teams with Bill Rankin, the AJC’s legal affairs writer, to tell the story in Season 6 of “Breakdown.”

You can download the podcast from iTunes, Stitcher or your favorite podcasting platform. Or you can stream it on your computer in the player below.

JOIN THE DISCUSSION: Join the Breakdown Podcast Facebook group for more AJC coverage and behind-the-scenes looks at previous Breakdown seasons.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Democrat Jones scores once-unthinkable victory in Alabama Senate race
Democrat Jones scores once-unthinkable victory in Alabama Senate race

Doug Jones and Roy Moore. AP file. Democrat Doug Jones scored a once-unthinkable victory, several media outlets projected Tuesday, winning a U.S. Senate seat in deep-red Alabama fueled by a surge in turnout and a wave of Republicans who couldn’t support former judge Roy Moore’s candidacy after he was accused of sexual misconduct...
Man shoots himself as deputies respond to homicide
Man shoots himself as deputies respond to homicide

A Spalding County woman who was shot early Tuesday died after being flown to Atlanta, officials said. Grady Jack Norton, who deputies believe shot 42-year-old Amber Rae Brown, was holding a weapon next to Brown’s body as deputies entered the 600 block of Cheatham Road in Griffin about 9:15 a.m., Spalding County sheriff’s spokesman...
Family of electrocuted man: ‘It should have been enough time to cut that power off’ 
Family of electrocuted man: ‘It should have been enough time to cut that power off’ 

Like many this past snowy Friday night, Tevin Gullatt had gotten off work early.   The 18-year-old was headed home when he stepped on a downed power line in the 1300 block of Northwest Drive, was electrocuted and died, Atlanta police said in a report.  Charles Baker, 51, who witnessed the entire thing, tried warning Gullatt about the...
FBI says man in ‘Punisher’ shirt robbed 5 metro Atlanta banks
FBI says man in ‘Punisher’ shirt robbed 5 metro Atlanta banks

A man in his mid to late 30s has been robbing banks throughout metro Atlanta for months, the FBI says.  He wore a gray “Punisher” T-shirt in a Dec. 7 robbery at a bank on Roswell Road in Marietta, FBI Agent Stephen Emmett said in a news release.  The “Punisher” is a Marvel Comics character who has been portrayed...
WATCH: Teens assaulted hearing-impaired student, filmed incident
WATCH: Teens assaulted hearing-impaired student, filmed incident

Two teenagers accused of beating a disabled student at an Atlanta high school face harsher charges after video of the attack surfaced on social media, Channel 2 Action News reported Tuesday.  The teens were initially suspended for a day and forced to apologize for the Nov. 30 beating by officials at Maynard Jackson High School, the disabled student&rsquo...
More Stories