At Issue: Who owns monument in Decatur Square?


In the past two months the Confederate monument on Decatur’s square has probably received more attention than ever, at least since it was commemorated in April 1908.

This 30-foot tall obelisk, like monuments everywhere, is unquestionably a symbol. But a symbol of what?

For those who erected it, nearly 43 years to the day after Appomattox, the Civil War was as fresh as the earthworks still lining the city square. They saw this as honoring the nearly two generations of Southern men wiped out by an unimaginably brutal war. In a nation of 31.5 million (north and south combined) a total 623,000 died, exceeding all this nation’s wars combined through Vietnam. Nearly as many Americans were wounded and permanently debilitated.

But Sara Patenaude, a PhD candidate in history who helped found Hate Free Decatur, sees it much differently.

“[Hate Free Decatur is] about dismantling the system the monument represents, dismantling white supremacy in Decatur,” she said recently.

And lately the obelisk has become a symbol of entangled local bureaucracy.

This week the DeKalb Commission will almost certainly pass a resolution calling for removal of the monument, which was erected in four sections. Decatur’s commission approved a similar resolution last month.

But the county is now saying it’s uncertain about who owns the monument and who owns the land it sits on, and that a month-long title search has proved inconclusive. Meantime Decatur insists, as it has all along, both land and landmark are owned by DeKalb.

Then there’s the state law passed in 2001 that appears to prohibit such monuments, regardless of who owns it, from being “relocated, removed, concealed, obscured, or altered in any fashion.”

So how do you sort out this situation? Who owns it, what does it stand for, where does it go and if it does go who pays for it and is it worth the cost?

Send comments to communitynews@ajc.com. Replies may be edited for length and/or context and may be published in print or other platforms.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Here’s what we know will be closed in Atlanta due to weather Thursday
Here’s what we know will be closed in Atlanta due to weather Thursday

The snow had stopped falling by the time most intown Atlanta residents awoke Wednesday, but enough of it was left behind to disrupt the city’s normal business practices.  Expect more of the same on Thursday. Atlanta government offices and municipal courts will remain closed due to bad road conditions that kept cops busy with nearly...
Thursday another snow day for DeKalb with no school and bad roads
Thursday another snow day for DeKalb with no school and bad roads

One snow day down. At least one more to go. DeKalb County is once again shutting down Thursday, as it did Wednesday when snow blanketed the roads in the morning.  With forecasters calling for the roads to ice-over overnight, DeKalb County Schools went ahead and called Thursday off. County offices, senior centers, libraries and recreation...
Baby taken from gas station in car found in Clayton County 
Baby taken from gas station in car found in Clayton County 

A 1-month-old was found abandoned on the side of the road in her car seat after a suspect stole her mom’s car, Clayton County police said.  The mother, identified by Channel 2 Action News as Precious Wilmer, said her daughter Ava is being  taken to Southern Regional Medical Center in Riverdale. The child was found on South Fulton...
Cops believe hypothermia caused 2 recent deaths in downtown Atlanta 
Cops believe hypothermia caused 2 recent deaths in downtown Atlanta 

In the past three weeks, Atlanta police have responded to two deaths they believe were caused by hypothermia.  In each case, the bodies were found wrapped in blankets in downtown Atlanta. Police said the man and woman, found weeks apart within a mile of each other, were both homeless.  The most recent death was discovered two days ago. An...
257 traffic accidents, 9 hit-and-runs reported during snow in DeKalb
257 traffic accidents, 9 hit-and-runs reported during snow in DeKalb

DeKalb County roads were perilous after snow fell Tuesday night into Wednesday morning. The 911 center reports it took 257 calls about auto accidents, including 9 hit-and-runs, between 10 p.m. Tuesday and 5 p.m. Wednesday.  There were 270 other traffic-related calls. That includes abandoned vehicles, hazards, stalled vehicles and so on. One...
More Stories