Court asked to expand discrimination protections to gays, lesbians


The federal appeals court in Atlanta was asked Thursday to expand workplace discrimination protections to members of the LGBT community.

The potential landmark case was argued on behalf of Jameka Evans, a former security guard at Georgia Regional Hospital. She sued the hospital last year, alleging it harassed and fired her because she is a lesbian. A federal judge dismissed her suit on grounds the Civil Rights Act of 1964 does not protect discrimination based on sexual orientation.

The appeal was argued before a three-judge panel of the 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals. Georgia Regional chose not to present its arguments, leaving only Lambda Legal attorney Greg Nevins and an Equal Employment Opportunity Commission attorney to argue on Evans’ behalf.

At the outset, Judge Bill Pryor noted that a 1979 decision issued by the court, and which said sexual orientation claims are not recognized, is binding precedent.

“It looks to me we’re bound by that precedent on that point,” Pryor said.

Nevins disagreed. “This court can, and must, revisit that,” he said. “I think this court should reassess that decision.”

Judge Robin Rosenbaum appeared to agree with Nevins that the 11th Circuit can recognize sexual orientation clams. The third judge, visiting judge Jose Martinez, did not ask any questions.

Evans, who lives in Savannah, attended the arguments.

“I’m confident and I hope that everything will go well,” she said.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Facebook to give Congress Russian-linked 2016 election ads
Facebook to give Congress Russian-linked 2016 election ads

Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg said on Thursday that the social media company will turn over to Congress thousands of ads believed to have been bought by Russian agents attempting to influence last year’s presidential election. Facebook officials said earlier this month that more than 3,000 ads were uncovered that ran between 2015 and 2017 and...
Man indicted on child molestation and rape charges, held for immigration
Man indicted on child molestation and rape charges, held for immigration

A Cherokee County man was indicted on child molestation and statutory rape charges Thursday, officials said.  Halario Matias Perez of Canton was originally charged only with statutory rape when deputies said they found him having sex with a 15-year-old girl in a parked car about 8:30 a.m. on June 19, according to the arrest report. The child molestation...
Summerhill, Midtown projects win tax breaks from Invest Atlanta
Summerhill, Midtown projects win tax breaks from Invest Atlanta

The board of Atlanta’s economic development agency approved more than $17 million in tax incentives for several developers on Thursday, but tax breaks for a pair of projects at the former Turner Field caused a clash among board members, with one saying the agency needs to re-think its public investment strategy. The board of Invest Atlanta narrowly...
‘We never give up’: Police intent on solving murder of Gainesville teen
‘We never give up’: Police intent on solving murder of Gainesville teen

Five years after Gainesville High School student Hannah Truelove was found fatally stabbed near Lake Lanier, her death remains a mystery that police expect to one day solve. “Understand, we never give up,” Lt. Dan Franklin of the Hall County Sheriff’s Office told The Atlanta Journal-Constitution recently. Truelove’s body was...
Gang member sentenced for killing Cobb father during 2015 robbery
Gang member sentenced for killing Cobb father during 2015 robbery

Almost exactly two years after a Mableton father was shot to death, one of his gang-affiliated killers was sentenced to life in prison without parole. Darius Jarrell Dunn, 25 of Austell, was sentenced Thursday on malice murder and other charges in the death of 23-year-old Anthony Terrell Tavarez. Dunn was the third and final suspect to be...
More Stories