Court asked to expand discrimination protections to gays, lesbians


The federal appeals court in Atlanta was asked Thursday to expand workplace discrimination protections to members of the LGBT community.

The potential landmark case was argued on behalf of Jameka Evans, a former security guard at Georgia Regional Hospital. She sued the hospital last year, alleging it harassed and fired her because she is a lesbian. A federal judge dismissed her suit on grounds the Civil Rights Act of 1964 does not protect discrimination based on sexual orientation.

The appeal was argued before a three-judge panel of the 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals. Georgia Regional chose not to present its arguments, leaving only Lambda Legal attorney Greg Nevins and an Equal Employment Opportunity Commission attorney to argue on Evans’ behalf.

At the outset, Judge Bill Pryor noted that a 1979 decision issued by the court, and which said sexual orientation claims are not recognized, is binding precedent.

“It looks to me we’re bound by that precedent on that point,” Pryor said.

Nevins disagreed. “This court can, and must, revisit that,” he said. “I think this court should reassess that decision.”

Judge Robin Rosenbaum appeared to agree with Nevins that the 11th Circuit can recognize sexual orientation clams. The third judge, visiting judge Jose Martinez, did not ask any questions.

Evans, who lives in Savannah, attended the arguments.

“I’m confident and I hope that everything will go well,” she said.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Atlanta mayoral candidates feel the heat at Spelman debate
Atlanta mayoral candidates feel the heat at Spelman debate

The AJC’s Stephen Deere keeps you updated on the latest in the Atlanta mayoral race and everything else going on at City Hall. You'll find more on myAJC.com, including these stories:  Atlanta mayoral candidates battle for city's progressive vote  Atlanta mayoral runoff candidates seek support of former opponents  Bottoms...
Getting ready for metro Atlanta’s next transportation revolution
Getting ready for metro Atlanta’s next transportation revolution

An electric driverless shuttle produced by EasyMile drives, as part of an experiment, in Paris on Friday. The fully electric autonomous vehicle is made by French company EasyMile, one of multiple French driverless car projects. AP/Christophe Ena Please seal this column in an envelope and give it a place on a back shelf for the next 20...
Cops: DUI crash leaves motorcyclist in hospital with life-threatening injuries
Cops: DUI crash leaves motorcyclist in hospital with life-threatening injuries

An alleged drunken driver is in the Cobb County jail after police say he hit a motorcyclist outside an apartment complex. Clarence Blackshear, 47, of Marietta, is accused of hitting Jacob Schirm, 20, of Alpharetta, outside the Silver Creek Apartments on Roswell Road about 9:30 p.m. Thursday, Marietta police Officer Jared Rakestraw said.  Blackshear...
Former Atlanta fire chief claims discrimination in civil rights suit
Former Atlanta fire chief claims discrimination in civil rights suit

A federal judge on Friday had questions about why Mayor Kasim Reed dismissed Atlanta’s fire chief in 2015, asking attorneys representing the city if the decision was based primarily on the contents of the chief’s controversial book or his insubordination. Fire chief Kelvin Cochran was terminated after he wrote and distributed a book that...
Recount shows Michael Julian Bond might retain Atlanta Council seat
Recount shows Michael Julian Bond might retain Atlanta Council seat

Michael Julian Bond will apparently retain his at-large council seat, but just barely, according to the unofficial results of a Fulton County vote recount on Friday. For the past couple of weeks, the outcome of the race wasn’t clear. First, there was supposed to be a recount, then a runoff, then a recount again. Earlier this week, election officials...
More Stories