'Breakdown’ S02 Ep. 5: A jury of his peers, with some preconceived notions


We’re still in the throes of jury selection in the Justin Ross Harris hot-car murder case, although it appears to be slogging toward a conclusion.

In this phase, Cobb Superior Court Judge Mary Staley is qualifying a large panel of prospective jurors – a panel from which the final 12 and some alternates will be selected. Staley hasn’t said how many alternates she wants, and the number will affect how much longer jury selection will take.

Among those citizens qualified already, nearly a third have expressed the view that Harris is guilty. Several of them, but not all, said they could set aside their opinions and impartially evaluate the evidence laid before them.

The question, ultimately, is whether they really can, whether Harris can receive a fair trial from a jury on which some members admitted to a bias against Harris at the outset. The judge obviously believes that he can. Lead defense attorney Maddox Kilgore seems to have his doubts.

While arguing one of his challenges, he declared, his voice rising higher and higher: “We’re actually arguing over somebody who’s sat right there and said, ‘I think he’s guilty. I’m not impartial. I did not presume he’s innocent.’”

But a presumption of innocence is sometimes proving elusive among the prospective jurors in the Harris case.  


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Uber driver charged in rape of 16-year-old girl
Uber driver charged in rape of 16-year-old girl

An Uber driver in Georgia was arrested Thursday after a 16-year-old girl said she was raped in suburban Atlanta, police said. Abdoulie Jagne, 58, of College Park, was identified as the man police said allegedly raped a girl in the Gwinnett County city of Norcross, Gwinnett police spokeswoman Cpl. Michele Pihera said.  Uber officials said Jagne...
Firefighter dies battling California blaze
Firefighter dies battling California blaze

A California firefighter died Thursday while battling the Thomas Fire in Ventura County, KSWB reported. Cory Iverson, 32, of Escondido died near Fillmore while helping to battle the 10-day-old fire, which has burned more than 249,500 acres and destroyed more than 1,000 structures. Iverson had been with the Cal Fire department since 2009....
Eighth planet found orbiting distant star
Eighth planet found orbiting distant star

An eighth planet has been discovered orbiting a star 2,545 light-years from Earth, NASA announced Thursday. The star, called Kepler-90, is located in the Draco constellation. It is the first known star to have as many planets orbiting it as our solar system does, NASA said. NASA scientists had known about seven planets orbiting Kepler-90. The...
Watch: He’s going to Harvard, and Louisiana student’s reaction is priceless
Watch: He’s going to Harvard, and Louisiana student’s reaction is priceless

It has been quite a week for two Louisiana brothers. Both were accepted into big-name colleges, and separate videos of their reactions have gone viral. On Tuesday, 16-year-old Ayrton Little and his classmates at T.M. Landry College Preparatory waited as he opened his email to see if he had been accepted into Harvard University’s 2019-2020 class...
Anonymous donor pays $40,000 in layaway bills at Pennsylvania Walmart
Anonymous donor pays $40,000 in layaway bills at Pennsylvania Walmart

“Santa B” has struck again, and more than 200 families received a wonderful Christmas gift. For the second straight year, an anonymous donor paid for all of the items on layaway for 200 families at a Pennsylvania Walmart, WJAC reported.  According to the staff of the Walmart store in Everett, “Santa B” paid more than...
More Stories