'Breakdown’ S02 Ep. 5: A jury of his peers, with some preconceived notions


We’re still in the throes of jury selection in the Justin Ross Harris hot-car murder case, although it appears to be slogging toward a conclusion.

In this phase, Cobb Superior Court Judge Mary Staley is qualifying a large panel of prospective jurors – a panel from which the final 12 and some alternates will be selected. Staley hasn’t said how many alternates she wants, and the number will affect how much longer jury selection will take.

Among those citizens qualified already, nearly a third have expressed the view that Harris is guilty. Several of them, but not all, said they could set aside their opinions and impartially evaluate the evidence laid before them.

The question, ultimately, is whether they really can, whether Harris can receive a fair trial from a jury on which some members admitted to a bias against Harris at the outset. The judge obviously believes that he can. Lead defense attorney Maddox Kilgore seems to have his doubts.

While arguing one of his challenges, he declared, his voice rising higher and higher: “We’re actually arguing over somebody who’s sat right there and said, ‘I think he’s guilty. I’m not impartial. I did not presume he’s innocent.’”

But a presumption of innocence is sometimes proving elusive among the prospective jurors in the Harris case.  


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Police: Man uses fishing line to steal change from car washes
Police: Man uses fishing line to steal change from car washes

Ohio police are looking for a man who they say is reeling in money illegally from local car washes, WKBN reported. According to Boardman police, a man used a $20 bill attached to a fishing line to steal hundreds of dollars in change from car wash coin box machines. Police said that according to surveillance camera video, the suspect is as...
Documents: Unsanitary conditions long ignored at Ga. prison hospital
Documents: Unsanitary conditions long ignored at Ga. prison hospital

Bags of garbage have piled up outside the operating room, attracting flies and mosquitoes. During surgery, dealing with the insects has become one of the occupational hazards for doctors and nurses. Mold has contaminated the ceiling in the dental unit and a wall in a second-floor corridor of the hospital. In the dialysis center, water has dripped under...
At Issue: Who owns monument in Decatur Square?
At Issue: Who owns monument in Decatur Square?

In the past two months the Confederate monument on Decatur’s square has probably received more attention than ever, at least since it was commemorated in April 1908. This 30-foot tall obelisk, like monuments everywhere, is unquestionably a symbol. But a symbol of what? For those who erected it, nearly 43 years to the day after Appomattox, the...
Community Voices: Saving the Chattahoochee River Line
Community Voices: Saving the Chattahoochee River Line

Barry Brown remembers growing up in southeast Cobb County when fortifications from a long-ago war extended six miles along the north bank of the Chattahoochee River. A series of Civil War forts or “shoupades” – dirt mounds forming curious triangular shapes in the woods – made up the river line, constructed by 1,000 slaves in...
Sunday Conversation with Chris Stafford and Hunter Cunningham
Sunday Conversation with Chris Stafford and Hunter Cunningham

Chris Stafford and Hunter Cunningham have a lot in common. They run toward danger and away from the spotlight. Stafford is a deputy with the Paulding County Sheriff’s Office while Cunningham recently completed his training to be an emergency medical technician and fireman. In July, the men, who did not know each other at the time, were off work...
More Stories