Board overturns MARTA’s decision to outsource paratransit service

An arbitration board has overturned MARTA’s decision to outsource its bus service for the disabled and elderly to a private company – a move the agency says could lead to poorer service at a higher cost.

MARTA decided to outsource its paratransit service in 2015, citing the need to save money, increase efficiency and improve on-time performance rates. A private company – MV Transportation – has been operating the service since last spring.

BACKGROUND: MARTA paratransit riders voice concerns

FULTON COUNTY: MARTA plans expansion

Paratransit service allows people who can’t use regular transit service to schedule rides on special buses. Last year, the paratransit service saw more than 670,000 passenger boardings, according to Federal Transit Administration statistics.

The Feb. 3 arbitrator’s decision gives the agency 100 days to bring the operation back in house. That means the agency will need to hire hundreds of bus drivers in coming weeks – though many of its former employees now work for MV Transportation.

The decision is a victory for the Amalgamated Transit Union, which says MARTA’s decision to outsource the service violated the terms of its labor contract. Stanley Smalls, a union officer, said customers also will benefit from having experienced, well-paid drivers.

“It’s a victory for everybody that was affected by this outsourcing,” Smalls said.

In a written statement, MARTA said it is “reviewing the arbitrator’s decision before deciding next steps.” It could appeal the decision to Superior Court.

In the arbitration dispute, MARTA argued that “any effort to undo the contract with MV (Transportation) will adversely affect MARTA’s service to its most vulnerable customers.” It also said the move would “have enormous and negative financial consequences.”

It’s unclear how much money – if any – MARTA has saved by switching to a private contractor. MARTA’s paratransit budget increased 11 percent to $25.2 million this year.

In written responses to The Atlanta Journal-Constitution’s questions, MARTA said several factors – including increased ridership and rising employee wages – contributed to the budget increase.

Joseph Erves, MARTA’s senior director of operations, said the first year of outsourcing includes one-time expenses that would reduce savings.

“The full benefit of the cost savings will not be achieved until we get closer to full implementation of all changes/improvements,” Erves said in a written statement.

The agency also said cost savings were just one factor it considered when it decided to outsource the service. Other factors included improved technology that would help improve customer service.

The arbitration board voted 2-1 in favor of the union. Among other things, it cited evidence that MARTA’s chief aim in outsourcing paratransit service was saving money on employee pay and benefits – in essence, avoiding its obligations under the labor contract.

Some customers have complained for years that the service is unreliable. According to MARTA, last spring paratransit buses, on average, were late to pick up passengers one out of every five times.

In recent months, performance has improved. In November, paratransit buses arrived on time 90 percent of the time.

But problems remain. Next month, MARTA will appear in federal court to show why it shouldn’t be held in contempt for violating a provision of the federal Americans with Disabilities Act.

Ken Mitchell, a disability rights advocate and MARTA customer, said paratransit buses have been on time more often in recent months. But when they’re late, they’re often later than before, he said.

Mitchell welcomed the arbitration board’s decision. He said it’s better for the service to be operated by a public agency, rather than a private company.

“We can’t give a public service to a private entity,” he said. “Its mission is to make money, by definition. The public mission is to provide service. It’s tough to make those two mesh.”

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Local

Marietta superintendent on Parkland: ‘Our children have become numb’
Marietta superintendent on Parkland: ‘Our children have become numb’

Marietta’s superintendent Grant Rivera appeared on the “HLN Weekend Express” program this weekend to describe how to talk to children about tragedy and what he’s doing locally. His appearance came days after 14 students and three school staff were gunned down at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School by expelled...
12-year-old sister of murder victim reported missing in Florida 
12-year-old sister of murder victim reported missing in Florida 

Police in Florida are searching for a 12-year-old girl who was reported missing early Monday, seven months after her sister went missing and was found dead several days later, the Bradenton Herald reported. The Manatee County Sheriff’s Office said Jalyssa Shannon left her home around 9 p.m. Sunday. Her mother, Michelle Mosley, called deputies...
Teen arrested in connection with Instagram death threat aimed at S. Florida school
Teen arrested in connection with Instagram death threat aimed at S. Florida school

A 15-year-old Florida boy was arrested after posting a message on Instagram threatening to kill people at several Broward County schools, authorities said.  Just after midnight Friday, Broward Sheriff's Office detectives were notified about the online post from a Fort Lauderdale teen. He posted it one day after 17 people were killed during a mass...
DeKalb commissioners schedule hearing on high water bills
DeKalb commissioners schedule hearing on high water bills

DeKalb County commissioners will hold a rare evening meeting  on Tuesday to hear from the public about the county’s lingering issues with costly -- and often inaccurate -- water bills. At this “committee of the whole” meeting, the Board of Commissioners will hear from two advisory groups: one that is studying water billing issues...
Fairburn hosting homestead exemption workshop
Fairburn hosting homestead exemption workshop

Fairburn residents who may be eligible for a homestead exemption on their property tax are invited to attend a workshop 3 to 4 p.m. Thursday, Feb. 22 or 10 to 11 a.m. Saturday, Feb. 24 at Fairburn City Hall Council Chambers, 56 Malone St. SW. Those who qualify for a homestead exemption from city of Fairburn Property Tax will have the taxable value...
More Stories