Atlanta housing agency: $120M windfall for developer in disputed deal

A controversial deal to require the city’s low-income housing authority to sell prime parcels of vacant land to a developer would hand them over at a $120 million discount, according to estimates obtained by The Atlanta Journal-Constitution.

If the sale goes through, it could amount to a king-sized subsidy towards the construction of high-end, market-rate homes, and harm the city’s efforts to create more affordable housing, public housing officials and affordable housing advocates said. Atlanta Housing Authority would give up control of one third of its vacant land, or about 100 acres, according to agency estimates, and there is no requirement that affordable housing be built on it.

The 2011 deal between the AHA and Integral Group came under scrutiny in March after the AJC raised questions about its terms. The deal gave Integral several years to exercise options to purchase the properties, and pricing was to be determined by a complicated formula weighted toward values that were years out of date.

Integral Chairman and CEO Egbert Perry told the AJC previously that he intended to sell homes he builds on the land at market prices.

AHA CEO Catherine Buell, who inherited the option deal with Integral, said moving forward with it would be bad housing policy for the city.

“Affordable housing is disappearing at alarming rates, and allowing a private developer to purchase our land to build condos for the wealthy exacerbates the housing crisis and pushes low-income residents even further to the margins of our city,” Buell said in a statement to the AJC.

Integral spokeswoman Shauna Grovell said in a written statement that she could not say whether AHA’s estimate is valid.

“Without a formal appraisal, frankly, no one can be certain of those values,” Grovell said.

Expert’s analysis: land worth $138 million

Perry previously argued that he deserves the discount because the properties were worth nothing until he and AHA redeveloped nearby parcels with mixed-income apartments. He informed AHA of Integral’s intention to exercise its options late last year.

Under Buell’s leadership, AHA filed suit in August asking a judge to kill the series of complicated contracts, which were signed as then-agency head Renee Glover faced pressure to leave her post. AHA would retain partial ownership of the properties, but Integral would have control over their development.

“The Atlanta Housing Authority is not a land bank for private developers to purchase land at rock-bottom prices,” Buell told the AJC.

An expert hired by AHA gave a September estimate for the land’s value at $138 million, according to more than two dozen pages of records obtained by the AJC that detail the calculations and methodology.

Integral Properties would purchase the parcels for about $17.5 million, the records state.

Whether or not AHA’s price estimate is accurate, the city’s affordability crisis makes it a bad time to lose control of acres of public land that could be used for homes, said housing expert Dan Immergluck, a Georgia State University professor.

“On its face, it’s concerning,” Immergluck said of the estimates. “Where there is room for housing, we should be building affordable housing, that’s for sure.”

The deal has sparked outrage among local affordable housing advocates with the Housing Justice League. The league’s members protested outside a speaking engagement by Perry on affordable housing at the Center for Civil and Human Rights in September. They also launched a petition drive that garnered 1,200 signatures and demanded that the developer immediately stop the deal.

“I am horrified,” said organizer Tim Franzen. “We’re not in a crisis of resources. We’re in a crisis of moral authority. This deal shows us this.”

Optioned parcels in hot neighborhoods

The deal now under dispute arranged for AHA to hold the property at the former Carver, Capitol, Grady, and Harris homes tax-free as Integral decided whether to purchase it. The terms specified that sales prices would be based in part on much lower property values that date to when Integral and the AHA first built mixed-income housing on these sites in the late 1990s and 2000s.

AHA demolished nearly all of its public housing projects during those years as part of its nationally recognized, two-decade effort to replace low-income housing through the federal HOPE VI program. It encouraged public housing authorities to form partnerships with private developers to build mixed-income housing.

AHA board members who served at the time of the deal told the AJC that they did not approve the options, and there is no evidence in U.S. Housing and Urban Development documents obtained by the AJC through a Freedom of Information Act request of a 2011 approval.

The September pricing estimates, made by a real estate expert hired by the authority, are not formal appraisals. Instead, the analysis uses historical sales records, holding costs and other data to make complicated calculations of sales prices for more than 100 authority parcels scattered across the city.

These plots include some of AHA’s most coveted properties. Some are located blocks from the Old Fourth Ward’s popular bars and restaurants. Others are near the former Turner Field, which is slated for redevelopment, or along to the southern leg of the massive Beltline project, where prices are expected to skyrocket.

Land values have climbed since the early 2000s at all of the sites involved in the options deal. At the former Grady and Capitol sites they have nearly doubled, the March AJC investigation found.

Perry said previously that he might be open to building affordable housing, but argued that there is already too much of it at these sites.

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Local

Q&A on the News

Q: Who was the first college football coach to make $1 million? At what point were football coaches valued at $1 million-plus salaries? —Bob Markert, Roswell A: Former Florida State coach Bobby Bowden is credited as the first college football coach to earn $1 million a year with a deal in November 1995, according to published reports. Steve Spurrier...
Pet groomer faces more animal cruelty charges
Pet groomer faces more animal cruelty charges

A Forsyth County pet grooming business owner is now facing an additional charge of animal cruelty as well as an investigation into other possible incidents, police said. Michelle Louise Root, owner of Paw’sh Paws in Cumming, turned herself in Wednesday night at the Forsyth County jail, Cumming Deputy police Chief Aletha Barrett told The Atlanta...
Atlanta races for another ‘Olympic moment’ with Amazon bid
Atlanta races for another ‘Olympic moment’ with Amazon bid

The pitches are in, but the work to land Amazon’s second headquarters is far from over. On Thursday, a Georgia official hand-delivered hardbound copies of what insiders call a “formidable” package for “HQ2,” a 50,000-job, $5 billion bonanza with the potential to alter the economic landscape of the winning bidder. The state...
Fugitive turns himself in, with doughnuts, after issuing challenge to police
Fugitive turns himself in, with doughnuts, after issuing challenge to police

A man made good on his promise to turn himself in to police in Michigan this week with a box of doughnuts in-hand after he challenged officers to get a Facebook post shared 1,000 times after taunting the department on social media. “You guys suck!” wrote 21-year-old Michael Zaydel, who goes by the name “Champagne Torino” on...
Calvin ‘Cal’ Carter, former Atlanta aviation commissioner, dies at 92
Calvin ‘Cal’ Carter, former Atlanta aviation commissioner, dies at 92

Calvin “Cal” Carter, Atlanta’s aviation commissioner from 1983 until 1990, has died at the age of 92. Carter worked for the city of Atlanta for 19 years under three mayors before retiring from the aviation commissioner position at the age of 65. He was the first African-American commissioner of the Atlanta airport, and last year during...
More Stories