Artists, landowners sue Atlanta over crackdown on murals

Plaintiffs say they’re facing a June 9 deadline from city

A group of artists and property owners on Tuesday filed a federal lawsuit against the city of Atlanta to halt the city’s regulation of murals on private property.

The lawsuit says landowners have been told they must now go through a multi-step application process for art that already exists or face possible prosecution — plus destruction of the art on their own property.

» Photos: Murals listed in the lawsuit

For future works, artists must go through an even more arduous application process: approval from five separate city offices, including the mayor and the City Council, the suit says. The public art ordinance also provides no time limits for the approval process, the suit said.

“Atlanta simply cannot constitutionally set undefined hoops and hurdles for display of art on a citizen’s own private property,” said Gerry Weber, a lawyer for the artists and property owners. “Because of this, a lot of great pieces of art around the city are at risk of being painted over.”

“The city has not yet been served with the suit,” said a statement Tuesday afternoon by the city’s office of communications. “Accordingly, we are unable to comment at this time.”

Among the plaintiffs are Fabian Williams, a street artist who makes murals under the name “Occasional Superstar”; Peter Ferrari, “PLF”; Benito Ferro, “Yoyo Ferro”; and Atlanta bar owner Grant Henry.

“Over the past 10 years this city has become an oasis for every type of artist,” Ferrari said. “I hope the city will continue to acknowledge the value we bring to Atlanta and continue to allow us to grow as a community.”

The city recently notified a number of artists and property owners that they had until June 9 to comply with the ordinance’s requirements or have their murals removed and be cited for violations, Weber said. The lawsuit seeks an expedited court order that prevents enforcement of the ordinance and damages for the artists and property owners involved.

The ordinance, which has been on the city’s books since 1982, has a criminal provision with up to $1,000 in fines and six months of confinement. The ordinance also has an “amnesty provision” regarding existing artwork. It requires:

  • Certification that the artwork will not be a traffic hazard or dangerous distraction to motorists or pedestrians.
  • Certification that the work is not primarily intended to convey a commercial message.
  • Certification from the bureau of cultural affairs that the work “is not inconsistent” with the city’s public art program and does not “negatively affect the public interest related to aesthetics, additional sign clutter and public safety.”

But this grandfather provision and the requirements for new artwork are not acceptable, said the lawsuit, which alleges a violation of free speech rights and unconstitutional “takings.”

“The public art ordinance requires government pre-approval before anyone can engage in any artistic expression anywhere in the city that might be visible to the public,” said Zack Greenamyre, another attorney representing the artists. “That’s simply not consistent with our cultural freedoms.”

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Local

UPDATE: 24-year-old woman dies in 11-vehicle pileup in Gainesville
UPDATE: 24-year-old woman dies in 11-vehicle pileup in Gainesville

A woman has died as a result of Monday’s 11-vehicle crash in Gainesville. Nicole Rocafort, 24, of Cumming, died Wednesday from injuries she received in the accident that sent nine people to the hospital, Gainesville police said. Rocafort was stopped at a traffic signal at Queen City Parkway and West Ridge Road when an 18-wheeler heading north...
11/19 Mike Luckovich: White privilege.
11/19 Mike Luckovich: White privilege.

$10M Cobb library set to open soon with no funding beyond first year
$10M Cobb library set to open soon with no funding beyond first year

With no set plan for funding beyond its first year, the $10 million Sewell Mill Library and Cultural Center will open Dec. 4. The 28,000-square-foot facility was built at 2051 Lower Roswell Road on the site of the former East Marietta Library, which was demolished after 50 years. Where the old library was is now the entrance and parking space...
7 APS campuses ranked among best in Georgia for student success
7 APS campuses ranked among best in Georgia for student success

Seven Atlanta Public Schools were recognized for generating some of the best student achievement statewide in 2017, Governor Nathan Deal announced Friday.  The 2017 Single Statewide Accountability System awards is a listing of Georgia schools that have exhibited high student performance or academic growth. It’s measured by the College and...
Ex-Gwinnett firefighter uses billboard to protest ‘mandatory overtime’
Ex-Gwinnett firefighter uses billboard to protest ‘mandatory overtime’

The signs, two panels of a rotating digital billboard that loom over one of Gwinnett County’s most traveled intersections, cut straight to the chase. “Firefighters have families,” one says in all caps. “Over $15 million tax dollars spent on mandatory overtime in 34 months.” “Stop Mandatory Overtime in the Fire Dept!&rdquo...
More Stories