Artists, landowners sue Atlanta over crackdown on murals

Plaintiffs say they’re facing a June 9 deadline from city

A group of artists and property owners on Tuesday filed a federal lawsuit against the city of Atlanta to halt the city’s regulation of murals on private property.

The lawsuit says landowners have been told they must now go through a multi-step application process for art that already exists or face possible prosecution — plus destruction of the art on their own property.

» Photos: Murals listed in the lawsuit

For future works, artists must go through an even more arduous application process: approval from five separate city offices, including the mayor and the City Council, the suit says. The public art ordinance also provides no time limits for the approval process, the suit said.

“Atlanta simply cannot constitutionally set undefined hoops and hurdles for display of art on a citizen’s own private property,” said Gerry Weber, a lawyer for the artists and property owners. “Because of this, a lot of great pieces of art around the city are at risk of being painted over.”

“The city has not yet been served with the suit,” said a statement Tuesday afternoon by the city’s office of communications. “Accordingly, we are unable to comment at this time.”

Among the plaintiffs are Fabian Williams, a street artist who makes murals under the name “Occasional Superstar”; Peter Ferrari, “PLF”; Benito Ferro, “Yoyo Ferro”; and Atlanta bar owner Grant Henry.

“Over the past 10 years this city has become an oasis for every type of artist,” Ferrari said. “I hope the city will continue to acknowledge the value we bring to Atlanta and continue to allow us to grow as a community.”

The city recently notified a number of artists and property owners that they had until June 9 to comply with the ordinance’s requirements or have their murals removed and be cited for violations, Weber said. The lawsuit seeks an expedited court order that prevents enforcement of the ordinance and damages for the artists and property owners involved.

The ordinance, which has been on the city’s books since 1982, has a criminal provision with up to $1,000 in fines and six months of confinement. The ordinance also has an “amnesty provision” regarding existing artwork. It requires:

  • Certification that the artwork will not be a traffic hazard or dangerous distraction to motorists or pedestrians.
  • Certification that the work is not primarily intended to convey a commercial message.
  • Certification from the bureau of cultural affairs that the work “is not inconsistent” with the city’s public art program and does not “negatively affect the public interest related to aesthetics, additional sign clutter and public safety.”

But this grandfather provision and the requirements for new artwork are not acceptable, said the lawsuit, which alleges a violation of free speech rights and unconstitutional “takings.”

“The public art ordinance requires government pre-approval before anyone can engage in any artistic expression anywhere in the city that might be visible to the public,” said Zack Greenamyre, another attorney representing the artists. “That’s simply not consistent with our cultural freedoms.”

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Local

Ex-city purchasing director to be charged in Atlanta bribery probe
Ex-city purchasing director to be charged in Atlanta bribery probe

The city of Atlanta’s former top purchasing official is expected to be charged Tuesday in U.S. District Court as part the long-running federal bribery investigation of City Hall, a person familiar with the situation told The Atlanta Journal-Constitution. Adam Smith, the former procurement chief, is expected to be charged with a single count of...
BREAKING: Suspect in Cobb woman’s slaying captured in Texas
BREAKING: Suspect in Cobb woman’s slaying captured in Texas

After a weeklong search, a man wanted in connection with the death of a Smyrna woman has been captured in Texas.  Brian Marsh Semrinec, 24, of Smyrna, was taken into custody without incident Monday night in Dallas, Texas, Cobb County police Sgt. Dana Pierce said. Authorities had been looking for Semrinec since Sept. 18, when they found 28-year-old ...
Isakson open to bipartisan health talks as latest repeal effort sputters
Isakson open to bipartisan health talks as latest repeal effort sputters

WASHINGTON — Georgia’s senior U.S. Sen. Johnny Isakson says he is open to resuming bipartisan talks to stabilize Obamacare’s health insurance markets as his party’s last-ditch effort to replace the 7-year-old law hovers on the verge of collapse. The three-term Republican indicated on Monday evening that...
Temps could flirt with record high again
Temps could flirt with record high again

Today: Partly cloudy. High: 88 Tonight: Mostly clear. Low: 69 Tomorrow: Hot. High: 90 Temperatures in metro Atlanta could flirt with a record high again, according to Channel 2 Action News. Temps on Monday fell just short of the 93-degree record set in 2010. And it looks like Tuesday could play out the same way, Channel 2 meteorologist...
Abrams campaign blasts Kemp for ‘abusing his office’ with voting probe
Abrams campaign blasts Kemp for ‘abusing his office’ with voting probe

Democrat Stacey Abrams and Republican Brian Kemp are running for Georgia governor. AJC file. Secretary of State Brian Kemp has continuously blasted Democrat Stacey Abrams since both entered the governor’s race, even as his office oversaw a complicated fraud investigation into a voter registration group founded by Abrams. The Republican...
More Stories