Gwinnett judge resigns after controversial Confederate monument posts


The Gwinnett County judge suspended Tuesday for controversial Facebook comments about Confederate monuments and protesters has now resigned.

Jim Hinkle, a part-time magistrate judge for 14 years, tendered his resignation Wednesday, Chief Magistrate Judge Kristina Hammer Blum said in an emailed statement released through a Gwinnett County spokesman.

“For 14 years, Judge Hinkle has dutifully served this court,” Blum’s statement said. “He is a lifelong public servant and former Marine. However, he has acknowledged that his statements on social media have disrupted the mission of this Court, which is to provide justice for all.”

MORE: PHOTOS: Controversial Facebook posts by suspended Gwinnett judge

MORE: KKK is denied request to burn cross at Stone Mountain  

Hinkle — who also served as mayor of the city of Grayson for more than two decades before retiring in 2013 — took to Facebook on Saturday to label those protesting against white supremacists rallying in Charlottesville, Virginia, as “snowflakes” with “no concept of history.” 

On Tuesday morning, he followed that missive with another post, this one comparing “the nut cases tearing down monuments” to the so-called Islamic State. 

Blum previously told The AJC she had not been familiar with those inflammatory posts and other until she was asked for comment. Reached by phone Tuesday, Hinkle told The AJC that he didn’t think his Facebook posts were controversial but declined further comment.

“My decision to accept Judge Hinkle’s resignation is not a comment on his personal opinions; he is entitled to those,” Blum’s statement said. “While, thankfully, our Constitution protects the right of all citizens to express their opinions, Judges are held to a more stringent standard by the Judicial Canons.”

Those canons say, in part, that judges should “act at all times in a manner that promote public confidence in the independence, integrity and impartiality of the judiciary.” They also urge judges to avoid creating even the appearance of a bias.

MORE: APD Chief: Arrests should’ve followed statue desecration

In addition to his posts about Confederate monuments and protesters, Hinkle also made several posts in recent years that could be construed as anti-Islamic, The AJC found.

Hinkle has been a member off the Georgia bar since 1969. He was 80 years old when he retired in 2013 after his second stint as Grayson’s mayor.

In Gwinnett, magistrate court judges manage cases that involve civil claims and county ordinance violations. They also sign arrest and search warrants and handle preliminary hearings in cases involving a range of alleged offenses, including felonies.


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Train-truck crashes too familiar in this Gwinnett city
Train-truck crashes too familiar in this Gwinnett city

The sights and sounds of a train crashing into a tractor-trailer Friday night in Gwinnett County were not new to people in that area. Just over a year ago, a train hit a truck on the tracks a short distance away, The Atlanta Journal-Constitution reported. Friday’s incident was at Holcomb Bridge Road at Thrasher Street, and the November 2016 incident...
Disappointed tourists visit (mostly) closed King historic site
Disappointed tourists visit (mostly) closed King historic site

A smattering of people wandered the grounds of the Martin Luther King Jr. National Park, trying to figure out what to do since most of the grounds were closed due to the government shutdown.  Freedom Hall, which is privately owned, remained open Saturday for visitors to take in exhibits about Rosa Parks, Ghandi and Kng and his wife, Coretta...
Armed robbery suspect dies after being shot by officer
Armed robbery suspect dies after being shot by officer

A man who robbed a Kroger store at gunpoint was later shot by a Dunwoody officer and died at a hospital, according to a police statement Saturday. The man was shot in a parking lot of a shopping center in the 5000 block of Winters Chapel Road, Dunwoody police said in a news release.  About 7:45 a.m., the man forced his way into a register at a...
Police: Maine man punches himself in face to avoid sobriety test 
Police: Maine man punches himself in face to avoid sobriety test 

Police have accused a Maine man of punching himself several times in the face to avoid a Breathalyzer test, The Bangor Daily News reported. Police suspected Brian Fogg, 27, of Belfast, to be intoxicated when they were called to a residence on Jan. 13 and found Fogg’s vehicle stuck in a ditch, police said. Belfast police said Fogg and...
Temp reaches 60s; ‘we have earned it’
Temp reaches 60s; ‘we have earned it’

Today:  Sunshine, clouds. High: 58 Tonight: Clear. Low: 35 Tomorrow: Mostly sunny. High: 63 One day after some metro Atlanta school systems remained closed due to effects of the snow and ice storm, the temperature moved into the 60s. And it’s supposed to stay in that range for a while. “It is going to be an...
More Stories