Gwinnett files new motion to dismiss minority voting rights lawsuit


Gwinnett County has filed a new motion arguing for the dismissal of the federal voting rights suit brought against it more than a year ago.

The suit — filed in Atlanta’s  U.S District Court in August 2016 by the Georgia Association of Latino Elected Officials and the Georgia NAACP — argues that Gwinnett’s commission and school board districts are drawn in a way that dilutes the influence of minority voters. Despite Gwinnett having more combined black, Latino and Asian residents than white ones, the lawsuit argues, all of the county commission’s four districts have majority white populations. All but one school board district does too.

Gwinnett has never had a non-white candidate elected to the county commission or school board.

More: Here’s your last chance to weigh in on Gwinnett’s transportation plan

The county’s attorneys have tried multiple times to have the suit dismissedThey have claimed at different points that “coalitions” of multiple minority groups shouldn’t be treated the same as a single minority group under the federal Voting Rights Act; that GALEO and the NAACP lacked standing to even file the suit; and that some of their proposed solutions, which include eliminating the commission chairman role to create a new district, are tantamount to changing Gwinnett’s form of government.

On Oct. 25, Gwinnett attorneys filed another motion for dismissal, this one in response to the an amended complaint submitted by GALEO and the NAACP about two weeks prior. (Judge Amy Totenberg had permitted the advocacy group to amend their suit to address several questions posed by the county and by the court.)

More: Initial tab for Gwinnett County raises: $2.2 million or so

The new motion to dismiss makes many of the same arguments the county has posed in the past. 

“As a matter of law,” the motion says, “none of the proposed remedies is viable or proper.”

It was unclear when Totenberg might rule on the new motion to dismiss. The litigation had appeared to be nearing a conclusion, with a recently agreed upon schedule suggesting all motions be in the hands of Totenberg  — who would then issue a summary judgment — by mid-January.

In other Gwinnett news:


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Pedestrian deaths increase in Georgia, but why on the interstates?
Pedestrian deaths increase in Georgia, but why on the interstates?

Carrying a food tray in his hands, a 46-year-old man attempted to run across the westbound lanes of I-20. Tommy Lee Jenkins made it to the third lane, according to witnesses, before he tried to run back across I-20 to safety around 6:30 p.m. on a Wednesday. It was too late. A Cobb County man immediately applied the brakes when he saw Jenkins, but the...
Atlanta man accused of theft, identity fraud in DeKalb, Gwinnett counties
Atlanta man accused of theft, identity fraud in DeKalb, Gwinnett counties

A man who was arrested in October in Gwinnett County on theft charges is now being sought on identity fraud charges, Channel 2 Action News reported. “I have not taken anything from anybody,” Eugene Hunter said during his arrest in Snellville. However, South Carolina resident John Bowen and his son Eric sought help from Hunter when they...
Barcelona restaurant worker to 911: ‘Somebody’s been shot!’
Barcelona restaurant worker to 911: ‘Somebody’s been shot!’

From inside the bathroom of Barcelona Wine Bar, a sobbing employee called 911 for help. “Somebody’s been shot!” the woman told the operator. “Our boss has been shot.” It was one of four 911 calls placed early Sunday from the popular Howell Mill Road restaurant following a robbery and shooting that killed a 29-year-old...
Cops: 4 men stole $9,000 in guns, electronics from DeKalb pawn shop
Cops: 4 men stole $9,000 in guns, electronics from DeKalb pawn shop

DeKalb County police are searching for four men they say broke into a pawn shop and stole $9,000 worth of guns and electronics.  About 3:30 a.m. Monday, the men broke into the Candler Road Pawn Shop and made off with six long rifles, a replica Thompson submachine gun and two Sony PlayStation 4s, according to a DeKalb County police report. ...
Roswell sets open house on Elm St. plans
Roswell sets open house on Elm St. plans

Proposed improvements to Elm Street in Roswell’s historic district are the subject of a public open house at Roswell City Hall. The meeting is scheduled for 5 to 7 p.m. Nov. 28 in Room 220 of Roswell City Hall, 38 Hill St. Representatives of Southern Pines Construction Group LLC, a developer that has proposed subdividing a lot on Maple Street...
More Stories