Decision on fate of Plant Vogtle might come by the end of the month


Recent corporate tax reforms passed by the Senate and the House could prompt a decision on the fate of embattled nuclear power plant Vogtle by the end of this year.

The decision on Vogtle was initially set for February but in letter exchanges this week between the CEO of Georgia Power Paul Bowers and the chairman of the Georgia Public Service Commission, Stan Wise, the outcome may come faster than earlier anticipated.

Bowers said in a letter to Wise that if the new tax rate takes effect in 2018, it could result in lower revenues for the company. As a result, he called on commissioners decide on the fate of the project before December 31, to enable the company take advantage of the current tax rate.

If that happens, Bowers says, the company could utilize the higher federal tax rate under an abandonment deduction which would result in the company yielding a tax benefit of $150 million.

Kurt Ebersbach a senior Attorney with the Southern Environmental Law Center which does not support Vogtle is perplexed by the sudden concern by Georgia power to get the tax benefit arguing the company spends that much in three months on Vogtle.

Ebersbach says what the rushed decision could do was leave “customers stuck with billions in more costs.” He is not convinced that Georgia Power or the commission are seriously considering abandonment.

On its part, Georgia Power argues waiting to make the decision next year means the company could lose the benefits of the current tax rate offers.

“These benefits would offset project costs and be passed along to customers through the traditional ratemaking process,” Bowers told Wise.

But the benefits Georgia Power is trying to save pale in comparison to the billions the project has cost customers over the years, leading to the conclusion this week by analysts appointed to evaluate Vogtle’s progress that the project is uneconomic.

“If it’s about saving money to customers, the decision should have been made long ago,” Ebersbach argues.

Bowers was responding to Wise’s question, in which the PSC chair sought to know how plant Vogtle would fare in the wake of the tax reforms passed by Congress.

This development comes as the commission prepares to hold hearings next week to review recent testimony by analysts appointed by the PSC to review Vogtle’s progress.

The testimony indicated completing the project was “no longer economic on a to-go basis” and that Georgia Power had managed the project and its lead contractor-Westinghouse Electric Company - poorly.

The analysts called for cancellation of the project if the commission declined their recommendations which called on the commission to disallow costs deemed unreasonable and allocate risks and costs between Georgia Company and its customers.

The analysts also highlighted design challenges, quality assurance and schedule issues that have beset the project since inception in 2009, resulting in delays and subsequent cost overruns that have been synonymous with the project.

In his response to the letter by Georgia Power CEO Bowers, PSC chairman Wise called on staff of the commission and Georgia Power to “consider revisions to the remaining schedule” to pave way for a decision by the end of the year.

“It’s difficult for me to believe that a responsible decision can be made within such a short frame of time,” said Ebersbach.

The commission resumes hearings Monday.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Business

Kempner: Gwinnett Place’s first manager staggered by mall’s decline
Kempner: Gwinnett Place’s first manager staggered by mall’s decline

Bill Gullion told me he helped throw a party for 3,000 people the night before the opening of Gwinnett Place mall, where he was the first general manager. Doormen wore tuxedos and white gloves, according to a news story at the time. The governor and Miss Georgia attended the ribbon cutting the next day, but there wasn’t enough parking to handle...
How to win an argument at work - or stop one before it starts
How to win an argument at work - or stop one before it starts

No one expects to navigate the work world without the occasional argument. And it's nice to "win" when you're in the right. »RELATED: Does birth order affect you in the workplace? But what really matters more than besting your manager or co-workers in an argument is how you handle the conflicts that are an inevitable part of work, ...
8 easy, money-making side gigs for teens 
8 easy, money-making side gigs for teens 

Whether it's the teen who'd like extra money for things like clothes or gas or a parent who'd like to see their high school or college-aged child get off the couch when school’s out, a part-time job can be a wonderful thing. »RELATED: Apple hiring for work from home positions Of course, child labor laws dictate how young is too young...
Atlanta purchasing chief gets 27 months for role in federal bribery case
Atlanta purchasing chief gets 27 months for role in federal bribery case

Adam Smith, the city of Atlanta’s former top purchasing official, was sentenced Tuesday to 27 months in prison for his part in the city’s cash-for-contracts scandal following an emotional hearing in which supporters and even the government asked for leniency in light of his cooperation and acceptance of responsibility.   ...
Lawsuit accuses Delta of discrimination in restroom run bumping
Lawsuit accuses Delta of discrimination in restroom run bumping

A lawsuit is moving forward in which a Delta Air Lines passenger, who was booted from a plane last year after an urgent restroom run before takeoff, accuses the airline of racial discrimination. The passenger, Kima Hamilton, gained widespread attention after a video posted online showed him being asked to exit the plane. An attorney seated nearby...
More Stories