Cobb mother’s death raises concerns over 911 delays


Neighbors of a Cobb woman who died Wednesday after a house fire say their calls to 911 are routinely transferred or dropped, resulting in critical time lost.

Cherriee Carter, 59, is survived by her son, who was trapped inside the burning house on Oakdale Road with her.

“I could hear the man screaming,” said Elizabeth Rutledge, a neighbor who tried calling 911 twice. “I couldn’t even tell him the fire department was on their way because I wasn’t able to get through.”

The Oakdale neighborhood sits at the border of Atlanta, Smyrna and Mableton in unincorporated Cobb County. As a result, 911 calls from cell phones may get picked up by towers in any of those three jurisdictions. 

Cobb Public Safety Director Sam Heaton said the Cobb 911 center received several calls about the fire Tuesday, including transferred calls.

“ ... Due to the fact this area is adjacent to the city of Atlanta by less than 400 feet, it is entirely possible that one or more of the callers hit on cell towers in the City of Atlanta,” he wrote in an email. “This in itself is not failure of any system, it is how cell phones and E911 have been designed.”

He added that the fire department’s eight-minute response time was a result of the closest fire engine being on another call. 

According to the county’s records, the address of the house that caught fire is within unincorporated Cobb County, he said.

Neighbors on either side of the Oakdale Road home say they pay Smyrna taxes. 

Rutledge lives on Evadale Trace to the north, while Ashley and Adam Gibby live on Haddon Place to the south.

The Gibbys said they have also had problems with emergency services.

Adam Gibby called 911 recently when his car was broken into, and has called in the past to report dangerous drivers cutting through their neighborhood.

He said he was routed to Atlanta before being placed on hold and then transferred to Cobb County and, finally, to Smyrna.

“Two minutes is a long time to wait if you have to report something,” Gibby said. 

His wife agreed.

“It could have been a matter of life or death,” she said.

Officer Louis Defense, spokesperson for the Smyrna Police Department, said the problem is not with the city’s 911 service, but rather the cell towers.

“We really have no control over where that call is sent,” he said.

MYAJC.COM: REAL JOURNALISM. REAL LOCAL IMPACT.

The AJC's Meris Lutz keeps you updated on the latest happenings in Cobb County government and politics. You'll find more on myAJC.com, including these stories:

Never miss a minute of what's happening in Cobb politics. Subscribe to myAJC.com.


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Getting ready for metro Atlanta’s next transportation revolution
Getting ready for metro Atlanta’s next transportation revolution

An electric driverless shuttle produced by EasyMile drives, as part of an experiment, in Paris on Friday. The fully electric autonomous vehicle is made by French company EasyMile, one of multiple French driverless car projects. AP/Christophe Ena Please seal this column in an envelope and give it a place on a back shelf for the next 20...
Cops: DUI crash leaves motorcyclist in hospital with life-threatening injuries
Cops: DUI crash leaves motorcyclist in hospital with life-threatening injuries

An alleged drunken driver is in the Cobb County jail after police say he hit a motorcyclist outside an apartment complex. Clarence Blackshear, 47, of Marietta, is accused of hitting Jacob Schirm, 20, of Alpharetta, outside the Silver Creek Apartments on Roswell Road about 9:30 p.m. Thursday, Marietta police Officer Jared Rakestraw said.  Blackshear...
Former Atlanta fire chief claims discrimination in civil rights suit
Former Atlanta fire chief claims discrimination in civil rights suit

A federal judge on Friday had questions about why Mayor Kasim Reed dismissed Atlanta’s fire chief in 2015, asking attorneys representing the city if the decision was based primarily on the contents of the chief’s controversial book or his insubordination. Fire chief Kelvin Cochran was terminated after he wrote and distributed a book that...
Recount shows Michael Julian Bond might retain Atlanta Council seat
Recount shows Michael Julian Bond might retain Atlanta Council seat

Michael Julian Bond will apparently retain his at-large council seat, but just barely, according to the unofficial results of a Fulton County vote recount on Friday. For the past couple of weeks, the outcome of the race wasn’t clear. First, there was supposed to be a recount, then a runoff, then a recount again. Earlier this week, election officials...
‘Political Rewind’ replay: Shirley Franklin on the ATL race for mayor

With former mayor Shirley Franklin in the house, today’s edition of GPB’s “Political Rewind” couldn’t help but start out with a look at the Atlanta mayor’s race between Keisha Lance Bottoms and Mary Norwood. Franklin repeated her contention that trust was a basic issue in the campaign &ndash...
More Stories