Some parents refuse to allow their children to take state exams


The final scheduled day of the statewide Georgia Milestones exams is approaching, but at least 200 metro Atlanta students did not take them.

Their parents filed paperwork refusing to allow them to take the tests, which are in their second year of use. Despite state and local efforts that stress the importance of the exams as a reliable way to measure student proficiency, many parents are still skeptical about their credibility.

“It’s not a valid test,” said Keith Kirk, who refused to allow his daughter, a fifth-grader in the Gwinnett school system, to take the Milestones. “It’s never been validated. It doesn’t tell teachers anything about a child’s strengths and weaknesses.”

The Milestones measures student performance in math, science, social studies and English/Language Arts in grades 3 through 8. High school students take assessments in 10 courses, such as biology and U.S. History.

Across the nation, a movement has grown to opt children out of standardized tests — in New York last year, one-fifth of students in third to eighth grade did not take math and reading tests, The New York Times reported — but the movement has not caught fire in Georgia. And some parents and teachers have complained about various testing glitches with this year’s Georgia Milestones.

Sixty Gwinnett students opted out this year, a district official told school board members last week. Last year, 40 Gwinnett students opted out. Gwinnett has more than 176,000 students.

Fulton County was far ahead of other metro districts last year. Parents removed 909 of its 95,000 students from the exams, a district spokeswoman said. As of Thursday, the total was 145 exempted students.

Two dozen DeKalb students were not taking the exams as of last week. A Cobb school spokeswoman said the district did not have data of how many students opted out.

State education officials said nearly 4,300 exams were not taken by Georgia students last year. They did not have data for this year.

Some Georgia high school students say they’re reluctant not to take Milestones because it counts 20 percent toward their final grades. As Jordyn Seybolt, a junior at Lakeside High School in DeKalb, wrote in an op-ed for The Atlanta Journal-Constitution, “So, if I refused to take the American Literature End of Course test, I presume the state would give me a zero for that percentage, dropping my grade significantly.”

School officials note the percentage of local parents have refused to let their children take the Milestones is small. Many national opt-out leaders and activists deride these tests as part of a Common Core curriculum or complain that it adds to another problem in public education — too much testing, which takes time away from teaching and learning.

Last year’s Milestones scores did not count against a student’s final grade. This year, third-, fifth- and eighth-grade students who take the exams must score above a certain level to move to the next grade. State officials expect students to fare better on this year’s exams.

Some parents interviewed pointed to the Iowa Test of Basic Skills as a better measure of student proficiency, in part because they say the Milestones has open-ended questions that are subject to interpretation.

Gwinnett resident Kellie Phillips said she’s talked to several teachers who tell her there are too many tests, one reason she refused to allow her son to take this year’s Milestones.

“The teachers can’t be creative and do the things they want to do because they’re focusing on preparing them for the tests,” she said.

Her son, whom she said is a straight-A student in the fifth-grade, was stressed last year when he took the exams. Phillips said her son is working on a class project in his school’s computer lab rather than take the Milestones.


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Education

AJC top teacher Susan Ahmad has a chorus of fans in Fulton schools
AJC top teacher Susan Ahmad has a chorus of fans in Fulton schools

The AJC created the Celebrating Teachers Awards this year to showcase remarkable Georgia educators. More than 375 teachers were nominated in the inaugural round of the awards, and a panel of education professors chose 10 winners. These teachers share a critical trait: They go above and beyond for their students and their schools. Since...
Atlanta school board candidates to meet at forum before Dec. 5 runoff
Atlanta school board candidates to meet at forum before Dec. 5 runoff

Voters still undecided about who to support in four Atlanta school board runoff elections can hear the candidates make their cases at an upcoming forum. All eight candidates have been invited to participate in the 6:30 p.m. Nov. 30 forum at Charles R. Drew Charter School, 301 East Lake Blvd.  Voters will decide the at-large district 7 race, which...
AJC top teacher Butch Soles of Douglas goes extra mile for his young runners
AJC top teacher Butch Soles of Douglas goes extra mile for his young runners

The AJC created the Celebrating Teachers Awards this year to showcase remarkable Georgia educators. More than 375 teachers were nominated in the inaugural round of the awards, and a panel of education professors chose 10 winners. These teachers share a critical trait: They go above and beyond for their students and their schools. Since...
AJC top teacher Jill Buchanan of Douglas gave hope to parent of child with special needs
AJC top teacher Jill Buchanan of Douglas gave hope to parent of child with special needs

The AJC created the Celebrating Teachers Awards this year to showcase remarkable Georgia educators. More than 375 teachers were nominated in the inaugural round of the awards, and a panel of education professors chose 10 winners. These teachers share a common trait: They go above and beyond for their students and their schools. Since this...
Here’s Georgia education news to be thankful for
Here’s Georgia education news to be thankful for

Teachers, students and schools across metro Atlanta have notched some victories to give thanks for in 2017. Teachers, who are easy targets for politicians, pundits and parents to blame for educational failures, are driving thousands of kids to success, as evidenced by by 325 candidates put up by friends, colleagues and students for the first AJC Celebrating...
More Stories