Fifth-grade APS dress-code crusader: Clothes are not ‘distraction’


Two Atlanta fifth-grade girls who want to wear leggings to school are trying to change the student dress code, which bans “extremely tight” and “distracting” clothing.

The Atlanta Board of Education on Monday reviewed potential changes to its decade-old policy that would emphasize that clothing rules must be consistently and equitably enforced.

The board’s policy review committee will continue the discussion at a 4 p.m. Nov. 28 meeting. The full board could vote on the updated policy Dec. 4, though a final decision may be delayed until January if public input is extensive.

Falyn Handley, a 10-year-old student at Springdale Park Elementary School, gathered more than 1,000 signatures on an online petition seeking to remove the word “distracting” from the dress code policy.

“This is a label applied to girls’ clothing. I do not believe that clothing is a distraction. It is just the reaction that matters,” she told the board Monday. “I should not be punished for other people’s behavior. I am not a distraction.”

Some students and parents have complained that the clothing restrictions unfairly target girls and contend that dress-code violators have been removed from class, missing instruction time because of what they’re wearing.

The district’s proposed update maintains modesty requirements but stresses that students who attend schools where a uniform is not required should be able to wear what they want “without fear of unnecessary discipline.”

The suggested rewrite still states that “clothing, hairstyles, and jewelry must not be distracting.”

That language is antiquated and should be dropped, said Falyn’s mother, Honora Handley.

“The conversation is not about what you wore, not about what you wore to provoke, not about what you wore to entice, and not about what you wore to distract,” she said. “This is an opportunity for APS to take a leadership stance and build gender equity into this particular policy.”

Not everyone thinks the board should devote time to dress code changes. Valerie Williams, who describes herself as an advocate for students in the Washington cluster, said the district has ignored other requests — such as televising public comments during board meetings and rezoning attendance areas “equitably” — from residents in the district’s south and west sides.

“I believe that APS has more important work to do than … for this to be a priority,” she said.

Superintendent Meria Carstarphen said the board reviews all policies on a cycle, and sometimes those reviews take place at the same time the public raises an issue.

Questions about the dress code have come from across the district, said Eshé Collins, the board member who leads the policy committee.

Both Falyn and fellow Springdale Park fifth-grader Ruby Segerman sported leggings while addressing the school board. Ruby said they are affordable, comfortable and make up “90 percent of my closet.”

“I don’t believe that leggings are a distraction,” she said. “I would be very annoyed and embarrassed to be called a distraction. The dress code policy should remove that word.”

In other Education news:



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Education

This Life with Gracie: Druid Hills Fulbright scholar headed to Greece
This Life with Gracie: Druid Hills Fulbright scholar headed to Greece

At the end of another school day early this month, I met Vincent Gray again in the teacher’s lounge at Druid Hills High School. It was the second time in just two years. The first time, a parent had reached out to tell me what a great teacher Gray is, the kind that not only teaches students facts, but how to think critically. After just six years...
17 Atlanta school police admit test cheating, investigator finds
17 Atlanta school police admit test cheating, investigator finds

Atlanta Public Schools is dealing with another cheating investigation. A quarter of the police officers in the district’s recently sworn-in force admitted receiving answers on a state-administered test. Disciplinary proceedings are coming for at least 18 employees. One dispatcher allegedly fed answers to 17 officers while they took the open-book...
Emory University to offer free tuition to some students from Puerto Rico
Emory University to offer free tuition to some students from Puerto Rico

Emory University announced Friday it will allow nearly three dozen eligible students who’ve had their studies interrupted by last summer’s hurricane damage to Puerto Rico to study here for free next semester. The 32 students will also receive application fee waivers and expedited processing. Those accepted will be able to enroll in credit-bearing...
Who got into University of Georgia today?
Who got into University of Georgia today?

From UGA: Nearly 15,000 students applied for early action admission to the University of Georgia’s Class of 2022, bringing record academic qualifications to the birthplace of public higher education. This year more than 8,000 students are being offered early action admission to UGA, and their average GPA of 4.11 reflects ...
Pulling both ends of the rope on campus free speech
Pulling both ends of the rope on campus free speech

College students, including those on Georgia campuses, are battling for free speech, challenging school administrators on limits to protests and demonstrations. At the same time, students can be the first in line to try to shut down speakers they don’t like. Witness what happened to Ann Coulter at Berkeley earlier this...
More Stories