Criminal case dropped, but cost was high for ex-Tech professor


Next month will be the seventh anniversary of the darkest moment in Joy Laskar’s life.

It was when Georgia Bureau of Investigation agents raided his Atlanta home and office. Laskar, a celebrated, tenured professor of electrical engineering at the Georgia Tech, was eventually fired and indicted by a state grand jury, accused of misusing university funds and other resources to benefit his private startup. He faced decades in prison and a hefty fine if convicted.

The case never came to a trial. Judge Robert C. I. McBurney tossed it out In October 2016, ruling the five-year statute of limitations had expired; the state had simply brought it too late. It was an unceremonious end to an episode that highlighted how entrepreneurial initiatives in academia can go very wrong.

Laskar decided to speak publicly about the dismissal last week. He had previously remained silent to avoid antagonizing prosecutors, who still hold family items with sentimental value, including a laptop with the only copies of childhood photographs of his three daughters and an unfinished novel by his wife.

“It has been devastating personally, professionally,” Laskar said by phone. The case against him has “had a huge imprint on us as a family to this day. It will never go away.”

Georgia Tech had no comment on the criminal case, but a statement from the university said Laskar’s dismissal came after a faculty committee’s recommendation and then a hearing before a special faculty committee.

“The committee found violations sufficiently egregious to warrant termination. President (G. P. “Bud”) Peterson received the committee’s report and terminated Laskar’s employment. The Board of Regents upheld the Institute’s decision. Laskar’s subsequent employment lawsuit was dismissed by the Federal District Court and the dismissal was affirmed by the Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeals,” Tech’s statement said.

Nick Genesi, a spokesman for the attorney general of Georgia, did not respond to multiple requests from The New York Times for comment.

Laskar had been a high-profile professor who brought in tens of millions of dollars in grants and research contracts from companies and government agencies.

He started chip companies on the side, which Tech encouraged, eager to see successful university spinoffs that had showered riches and prestige on Stanford, MIT and other top computer engineering schools.

His relationship with the university was ruptured when an audit led it to accuse him of using university money improperly to help produce prototype chips for one of his startups, Sayana Wireless. Laskar denied wrongdoing, saying the chips originally served academic purposes.

The indictment on racketeering charges didn’t come until late December 2014, more than four and a half years after the raids on Laskar’s home and office in May 2010.

David S. Ricketts, a professor of electrical engineering at North Carolina State University and a friend of Laskar’s, said the case was “widely discussed in the academic community.” He called Georgia Tech’s response an overreaction.

Professors sometimes operate in an ambiguous middle ground where it can be difficult to separate entrepreneurial and academic work, with graduate students, laboratory space and equipment shared between the two. Unless there is blatant theft, professors who step over the line are usually counseled, not fired and indicted.

“This wouldn’t have happened at MIT or Carnegie Mellon,” said Ricketts, who has worked at both universities, as well as Harvard. “Not because it wouldn’t have happened — they would basically have handled it internally. It became so politically charged.”

Though Laskar never got a chance to rebut the state’s accusations at a trial, he believes dismissal of the case will be helpful.

“We won in the first inning,” said Craig Gillen, his attorney. “If we had had to play the second inning, we would have won in the second inning.”

Now Laskar, 53, lives in Silicon Valley, where he’s working on another wireless chip startup, Maja Systems. He said he had exhausted his family’s savings paying legal fees and couldn’t seek another job in academia with the legal cloud hanging over him. He said it had come up in meetings related to his new startup.

“I think there are some doors that were closed, if you will,” he said, “but overall we’ve been able to move forward.”



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Education

Some candidates for school turnaround chief worked in Atlanta
Some candidates for school turnaround chief worked in Atlanta

The three finalists to lead Georgia’s experiment to improve its lowest-performing public schools are working in Kentucky, Texas and Virginia, and two have experience as school administrators in metro Atlanta. Monday’s announcement by the Georgia Department of Education comes just ahead of the public interview of the finalists to be conducted...
He couldn’t afford Morehouse; now he’ll be its president
He couldn’t afford Morehouse; now he’ll be its president

David A. Thomas admired the Rev. Martin Luther King Jr. and wanted to attend Morehouse College, the Atlanta school where King earned his undergraduate degree in 1948. His childhood dream didn’t become a reality because Thomas didn’t receive any financial aid. He went to Yale College instead on a scholarship. Decades later, Thomas, 61, is...
To get more girls in math, should we get more men in the classroom?
To get more girls in math, should we get more men in the classroom?

My husband attended his Harvard University reunion this weekend where he was one of the few grads who wasn’t a hedge fund manager or titan of industry. (He’s a journalist, too.) He told me about a fascinating discussion with a fellow alum who is a mathematician and computer scientist with a radical notion about how...
Rare Martin Luther writing found at Emory University
Rare Martin Luther writing found at Emory University

A retired professor from Germany made an interesting discovery recently at Emory University. He found a rare writing by Martin Luther, the theologian who began the Protestant Reformation in 16th-century Europe. Ulrich Bubenheimer, a retired professor from Georg-August-Universität in Göttingen, Germany, and a leading expert on Luther...
DeKalb Schools’ ‘Curriculum Road Show’ to make stops in Dunwoody, Clarkston 
DeKalb Schools’ ‘Curriculum Road Show’ to make stops in Dunwoody, Clarkston 

DeKalb County school officials will continue presenting the district’s new curriculum to parents and others at public events geared to give insight into the revamped learning process, officials said. The “Curriculum Road Show,” as it’s been dubbed, will make a stop at Dunwoody High School, 5035 Vermack Road in Dunwoody...
More Stories