Atlanta school board candidate sues district over election job rule


An Atlanta school board candidate sued Atlanta Public Schools and the board members she hopes to join over a rule that bars employees of other local school districts from serving on the board. 

Patreece Hutcherson is running in the November election for the Atlanta Board of Education District 6 seat, which represents south Atlanta. 

The ninth-grade school counselor, who is employed by the Douglas County Board of Education, filed a federal lawsuit Tuesday against APS, superintendent Meria Carstarphen, all nine current school board members, and Rhonda Dauphin Johnson, Atlanta’s election superintendent and municipal clerk. 

The suit takes issue with the school district’s charter which states that a person cannot be an employee of APS or “any other local board of education” to qualify for election to the Atlanta school board. 

The municipal clerk’s office informed Hutcherson that if she won the election she would be required to resign her Douglas County position, according to the suit. 

Carstarphen confirmed to Hutcherson that the requirement cannot be waived because it is a part of the state legislature-approved charter.

Hutcherson cannot afford to quit her job should she win. The suit notes that she doesn’t supervise any other employees in her job and maintains “there is little potential” for a conflict of interest. 

Atlanta school board members make $15,170 a year. 

“The policy requirements impose an unjustified and unconstitutional procedural barrier to citizens holding office on the Atlanta Board of Education,” the suit states. 

Hutcherson has support from the Georgia Association of Educators, which is providing her legal counsel. 

“Georgia’s teachers are always, and must continue to be, engaged in the political process. And like Ms. Hutcherson, they are uniquely situated to provide informed and effective leadership for, in this case, Atlanta’s Board of Education. This restriction just makes no sense and illegally restricts local educators’ ability to become part of the solution,” said Mike McGonigle, the association’s legal services director, in a written statement. 

APS spokeswoman Pat St. Claire declined to comment on pending litigation. 

Hutcherson wants the court to declare the requirement unconstitutional and to prohibit the district from enforcing the requirement. She also seeks damages and attorney fees.

In other APS news:


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Education

Letters at Emory are window into the mind of younger Barack Obama
Letters at Emory are window into the mind of younger Barack Obama

Barack Obama was trying to figure it all out — life, love, his future. It was the early 1980s. The future president was a college student and shared his thoughts with his then-girlfriend, Alexandra McNear, in nine handwritten letters that are part of a special Emory University collection that will available for public viewing for the first time...
Cherokee teacher in Trump T-shirt incident resigns after threats on life, attacks on character
Cherokee teacher in Trump T-shirt incident resigns after threats on life, attacks on character

Cherokee County math teacher Lyn Orletsky announced today she is resigning after her request to two boys to turn their Trump Make America Great Again T-shirts inside out exploded into a social media maelstrom and led to her suspension. She made the request only after students in her pre-algebra class voiced concerns about the message...
Board of Regents to review KSU handling of cheerleaders’ protest
Board of Regents to review KSU handling of cheerleaders’ protest

The Georgia Board of Regents will conduct a special review of how Kennesaw State University responded to the decision by five African-American cheerleaders to kneel during the national anthem in silent protest of police misconduct and racial inequality. The Atlanta Journal-Constitution reported Tuesday that Cobb County Sheriff Neil Warren and...
Cherokee teacher involved in Trump dispute resigns
Cherokee teacher involved in Trump dispute resigns

Lyn Orletsky, the Cherokee County high school teacher who stirred a social media uproar when she told two students to turn their “Make America Great Again” T-shirts inside out, has submitted her resignation, a district spokeswoman said. “Ms. Orletsky this week requested that the school board accept her resignation and release her...
Atlanta school board candidate files ethics complaint against incumbent
Atlanta school board candidate files ethics complaint against incumbent

Weeks before the Nov. 7 election, an Atlanta school board candidate filed an ethics complaint against his opponent, an incumbent whom he alleges offered his campaign worker a job with Atlanta Public Schools.  The Atlanta Board of Education’s Ethics Commission will meet at 10 a.m. Thursday to discuss if it will investigate the complaint filed...
More Stories