breaking news

Deadly crash shuts down I-20 East before Downtown Connector

Two executions now on hold because of cloudy drugs


For the second time in four years Georgia has decided to put a moratorium on executions after questions surfaced about the origin and effectiveness of increasingly hard to get lethal-injection drugs.

The Georgia Department of Corrections announced Tuesday that it was postponing the execution of Kelly Gissendaner indefinitely. Brian Keith Terrell’s upcoming execution was also put on hold. The state wants to test its supply of the sedative pentobarbital to be sure it’s effective. A prison system pharmacist said the dosage prepared to execute Gissendaner Monday night looked “cloudy,” and documents obtained by The Atlanta Journal-Constitution shows the prison system may have been confused about which batch of the drug had been tested.

Gissendaner, who would’ve been the first woman executed in Georgia in 70 years, had eaten her last meal, recorded a final statement and was waiting in a cell just a few steps from the death chamber before the decision to postpone was made.

The moratorium puts Georgia among several states that are struggling to acquire and maintain lethal injection drugs. Under unrelenting political pressure, big pharmacies have stopped selling drugs to states to deliver capital punishment. Georgia and other states have turned to what’s known as compounding pharmacies, smaller business that can custom produce the drugs. To shield those businesses from anti-death penalty activists, Georgia recently adopted one of the nation’s strictest laws that prevents the public from knowing details about how the state acquires its lethal injection drugs.

MyAJC.com: Gissendaner supporters heartened by delay

MyAJC.com: A timeline of lethal injection in the U.S.

Anti-death penalty groups and attorneys representing condemned inmates have challenged the efficacy of drugs produced by compounding pharmacies. A botched execution in Oklahoma last year, where an inmate convulsed and thrashed about for 43 minutes before dying, became an example of what states want to avoid.

The Georgia DOC said in statement it decided to test the drugs “out of an abundance of caution.”

An emergency legal motion filed by Gissendaner’s lawyers and obtained by the AJC suggests prison officials questioned the fitness of its drugs after Gissendaner had exhausted virtually all legal avenues to avoid the death chamber.

At 10:25 p.m. Monday officials at the prison called Gissendaner’s lawyers, according the motion, to say the execution would be postponed for several days because the pentobarbital made specifically for Gissendaner’s execution was “cloudy.

They called again five minutes later to say the execution may be carried out after all.

“The prison was no longer sure which drugs they had examined — ‘this week’s or last week’s’ — and that they were considering proceeding,” the motion said.

A state official called Gissendaner’s lawyers a third time to say “they were not planning to proceed, conceding that ‘this particular batch [of drugs] just didn’t come out like it was supposed to.’ There is simply too much uncertainty for the court to allow this execution to proceed,” Gissendaner’s lawyers wrote in the petition.

Corrections spokeswoman Gwendolyn said an independent lab had tested the drugs that would kill Gissendaner for potency and found it to be “within acceptable testing limits.” A few hours later, a DOC pharmacist noted that the pentobarbital was “cloudy.”

“There was never any confusion within the department about the drugs, which were to be used,” Hogan said Tuesday. “When an issue arose, the department took a measured approach and determined that the most prudent course of action was to postpone the execution.”

David Waisel, associate professor of anaesthesia at Harvard Medical Sch0ol, said a “cloudy” dosage could mean there were contaminants in it or the drug was not mixed well. Waisel said it it’s hard to know without information about the origin of the drug.

That’s a secret in Georgia.

The Georgia Supreme Court ruled 5-2 last May the law that keeps lethal injection information secret plays a “positive role” in the capital punishment process. It also is an issue raised in other states. For example, the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals said Arizona had to had put an execution on hold because of that state’s secrecy law but the U.S. Supreme Court said that execution could proceed.

Gissendaner’s lawyers wrote that while Georgia has asked the courts and the public to trust that they are ensuring the quality of lethal injection drugs, “now, by their own admission, those assurances are revealed as hollow.”

Before that change in state law, records made public disclosed how Georgia bought lethal injection drugs from a London pharmacy that shared an office with a driving school during a nationwide shortage of the drug. Federal regulators later seized the chemical over questions whether the state circumvented the law to get it, effectively blocking executions for months.

State Rep. Kevin Tanner, a Dawsonville Republican who sponsored the 2013 secrecy law, said the state needed to protect those who participated in executions from being harassed by opponents like the ones who asked Georgia’s medical board to revoke the license of a doctor who oversaw Georgia’s executions.

Critics who warned of the legislation two years ago now say the decision is coming back to haunt them.

“We now have a very clear example of why we should not have cordoned off that information from the public,” said state Sen. Nan Orrock, an Atlanta Democrat. “The public’s right to know is being trampled by that legislation. And here we are in a real life situation where we need to have a full understanding of the questions surround the lethal injection chemicals.”



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

THE LATEST: Deadly crash shuts down I-20 East before the Downtown Connector
THE LATEST: Deadly crash shuts down I-20 East before the Downtown Connector

One person has died and six others were taken to the hospital in a crash blocking all lanes of I-20 East just before the Downtown Connector. The 3-car crash has had the interstate shut down since just before 4 a.m., according to Channel 2 Action News. At one point, a vehicle caught fire and a person was trapped, the news station reported. Those injured...
Mercer Institute seeks to help professionals with spirituality
Mercer Institute seeks to help professionals with spirituality

During his years as an intellectual property lawyer, Paul Knowlton began thinking about how his profession could practice in a more holistic, rather than adversarial, way. “I didn’t want to be the damage control guy. I wanted to give good advice about how to avoid issues,” he said. While still running a law firm, Knowlton went back...
Day care ordered to close after leaving child asleep in van
Day care ordered to close after leaving child asleep in van

Weeks after a child was left asleep in a van, southeast Atlanta day care Elite Kindercare was ordered to close by The Georgia Department of Early Care and Learning.  “This action stems from the center leaving a child unattended on a vehicle and failing to complete required reporting to our agency,” DECAL spokesman Reg Griffin said...
Gwinnett teen indicted in man’s fatal shooting gets bond reduced
Gwinnett teen indicted in man’s fatal shooting gets bond reduced

A teen implicated in a murder was granted a bond reduction two weeks after he was indicted in the crime, Channel 2 Action News reported.  Alex Powell, 17, has been in jail since the Oct. 14 shooting that killed Akeem Turner, 21, at the Plantation Trace apartments, according to jail records. Gwinnett County court records indicate he was indicted...
Atlanta police officer questioned after girlfriend found shot inside their home
Atlanta police officer questioned after girlfriend found shot inside their home

Authorities are questioning an Atlanta police officer after his girlfriend was found shot inside their home Monday, DeKalb County police said.  About 6 p.m., officers were called to a Cavanaugh Avenue home regarding a possible attempted suicide, DeKalb police spokeswoman Shiera Campbell told The Atlanta Journal-Constitution. Investigators found...
More Stories