Body search of students leads to sexual battery charge for Ga. sheriff

A south Georgia grand jury indicted Worth County Sheriff Jeff Hobby on Tuesday for sexual battery, false imprisonment and violation of oath of office after he ordered a school-wide search of hundreds of high school students. Deputies allegedly touched girls’ vaginas and breasts and groped boys in their groin area during the search at the Worth County High School April 14.

Two of Hobby’s deputies were also indicted Tuesday in connection with the case.

The controversial search drew national attention because of its scope and how deputies conducted it under the guise of a drug search that produced no drugs or arrests. Deputies locked down the school, located 30 miles east of Albany, for more than four hours and searched nearly 800 students.

The indictment from the Worth County grand jury accuses Hobby of one count of violating his oath of office and two counts of false imprisonment — all felony charges. He was also indicted on one count of sexual battery, a misdemeanor.

Deputy Tyler Turner was indicted on one felony count of violation of his oath of office and one misdemeanor count of sexual battery. Deputy Deidra Whiddon was indicted for one felony count of violation of her oath of office.

In all, District Attorney Paul Bowden sought charges against the sheriff and five of his deputies. He presented a 36-count indictment for grand jurors to consider and they returned charges on six counts. In 24 of the potential charges, grand jurors cleared the officers with a no bill and in six instances they tabled the charges. Bowden said he has no plans at this time to bring the no billed or tabled charges back before another grand jury for consideration.

He said he spent two full days presenting evidence to grand jurors from the case, which was investigated by the Georgia Bureau of Investigation.

“Evidence was exhaustively presented to the grand jury,” he said.

In addition to the criminal case, the sheriff is facing a federal civil rights lawsuit filed in June by nine students who were subjected to the invasive searchesOne of the parents of the students said Wednesday she was glad the sheriff now also faces accountability in criminal court. The deputy who allegedly touched her daughter’s vagina through her jean pockets and lifted up her bra and touched her breasts was mentioned in the indictment, but grand jurors did not implicate her.

“I’m disappointed that the deputy that violated my daughter was not indicted,” said Amaryllis Coleman. “I don’t know how I’m going to tell this to my daughter.”

Officers did not testify

Under Georgia law, a police officer or sheriff accused of a crime related to their official duties can appear before a grand jury to give a statement. Private citizens facing criminal charges do not get this privilege. But the sheriff and his deputies chose not to invoke that privilege. All stayed out of the grand jury room. That’s at least in part due to a new law that curbed some of the unique privileges officers previously had to sway grand jurors.

Under a new law that took effect last year, officers would have been subject to cross examination and wouldn’t have been able to rebut statements made by prosecutors during that cross-examination.

“It’s not a balanced proceeding,” said Norman Crowe Jr., the sheriff’s attorney.

Crowe said the sheriff jurors get to hear his side of the story when case moves to its trial phase. He said the sheriff was at the school the day of the search, but did not personally search students.

“The sheriff’s position is that he’s not guilty,” Crowe said. “He’s committed no crime.”

Prosecutions of law enforcement officers are rare in Georgia, given that prosecutors often depend on police and sheriff’s deputies to help them make cases.

Still, Bowden said he never felt political pressure from the sheriff or his supporters not to pursue the case.

“It’s not a pleasant circumstance for them or for us,” he said.

Charges to be forwarded to governor

Bowden said he is preparing to send the indictment and a summary of the charges against Hobby to Gov. Nathan Deal, who has authority to suspend the sheriff. In June, Deal suspended DeKalb County Sheriff Jeffrey Mann for 40 days after he was accused of exposing himself in Piedmont Park. Deal suspended Walton County Sheriff Joe Chapman last month after allegations surfaced that he failed to report an arrest at a Florida bar last year.

In addition to any action by Deal, state law requires a police officer or sheriff charged with a felony to temporarily lose their police certification until the case is resolved. The Georgia Peace Officer Standards and Training Council (POST) received the indictment Wednesday afternoon and hours later had already moved under an emergency action to suspend the sheriff’s law enforcement certification. Both Turner and Whiddon will also have their law enforcement licenses suspended until the case is resolved. Vance said POST would also review the other three deputies mentioned in the presented indictment who were not charged for possible action related to their police certification.

Under POST guidelines, a sheriff is allowed to continue his administrative duties even if his police certification has been suspended. During his suspension, Hobby will be stripped of all his law enforcement and arrest powers, Vance said.

“Three felonies and a misdemeanor — that’s pretty serious,” Vance said. “He does have due process rights. This is something that will have to be decided in the courts. Until then, his license will be suspended.”

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Local

Four-legged 'Santa' a savior during Battle of the Bulge
Four-legged 'Santa' a savior during Battle of the Bulge

Tucked between dollar bills, nestled next to a black-and-white photograph of his wife Gloria, Stan Saltz pulls out a second snapshot, the one of him as a 19-year-old Army private and survivor of the bloodiest battle in the second World War. But the photo isn’t about the Florida resident. It’s about the German shepherd, a four-legged...
Power restored at Atlanta’s airport
Power restored at Atlanta’s airport

The crowd in the atrium at Hartsfield-Jackson International Airport erupted with cheers when power came on after a 10-hour outage. The airport atrium, Concourses T, A, and B and terminals were passengers check in and retrieve baggage powered up at roughly 11:20 p.m. Concourse F had been brought back online earlier in the evening. Mayor Kasim Reed...
Airport scenes: Those caught in the power outage
Airport scenes: Those caught in the power outage

Rick and Tammy Horton had spent 10 days in Georgia celebrating Tammy’s 60th birthday. First, there was a snowy weekend in the mountains. Then, they traveled to Tybee Island and Savannah. On Sunday, they were supposed to fly to Minneapolis so they could drive back to home. That was before the world’s busiest airport came to a standstill...
Atlanta Mayor Kasim Reed apologizes for airport power outage
Atlanta Mayor Kasim Reed apologizes for airport power outage

Mayor Kasim Reed started off an evening news conference with an apology. “First and most importantly, I was to express my sincere apologies to the thousands of passengers whose day has been disrupted in this manner,” he said. “We certainly understand that the outage has caused frustration and anger, and we’re doing everything...
Here’s what we know about the Atlanta airport outage
Here’s what we know about the Atlanta airport outage

The cause of the fire that knocked out power to the world’s busiest airport still isn’t known, but Atlanta Mayor Kasim Reed offered the city’s apologies to stranded passengers at a Sunday night press conference.    Reed and Hartsfield-Jackson International Airport General Manager Roosevelt Council said crews are working...
More Stories