AJC Watchdog: Tara Grinstead podcast challenges secrecy in criminal investigations


An Atlanta-based podcaster who spent months digging into the 2005 disappearance of Ocilla school teacher Tara Grinstead is asking why state law kept the official investigation secret.

Payne Lindsey, whose “Up and Vanished” podcast quickly became one of the nation’s most popular downloads after he started it last August, said he tried to get the official file into Grinstead’s disappearance from the Georgia Bureau of Investigation, but he had no luck. State open records law allows police to withhold files in pending investigations.

“My reasoning was how can you claim this is an open investigation?” he said.

Grinstead went missing nearly 12 years ago and when he started the podcast there seemed to be little prospect the case would be solved. Nancy Grace, a former prosecutor and talk show host, agrees with Lindsey that cold case files should be open when she appeared as a guest on his podcast.

“I think that we have closed investigative files for a reason,” Grace said. “However, once a case goes cold and police aren’t getting answers I really don’t see why the entire case file is kept secret.”

Last month, the GBI announced they had arrested a suspect based on a fresh tip. A second arrest of an alleged accomplice came shortly thereafter. Neither man had been among those formerly considered suspects.

For more on how “Up and Vanished” is challenging Georgia’s secret criminal files, read this week’s AJC Watchdog column here.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Atlanta police officer hurt in four-car crash
Atlanta police officer hurt in four-car crash

An Atlanta police officer has been taken to a hospital after a four-car crash, officials said. The incident happened in the area of Lee Street at Donnelly Avenue in southwest Atlanta, according to Channel 2 Action News.  The officer was taken to the hospital complaining of neck and back pain.  Two other adults and one child were in the car...
Girlfriend: Man shot 11 times ‘helped people, so it doesn’t make sense’
Girlfriend: Man shot 11 times ‘helped people, so it doesn’t make sense’

Stephanie Moore said she heard each of the 11 shots fired at her boyfriend, who was killed while checking his flat tires. Justin Edwards is being remembered as not only a loving father to the couple’s 4-year-old son, Austin, but also a hard-working logistics manager at Lockheed Martin who was working on a master’s degree. “I was the...
Cops: Thief used oxygen tank to blow up ATM
Cops: Thief used oxygen tank to blow up ATM

Courtney Brimanson and her husband were sound asleep when they heard an explosion miles away from their Mableton home.  “It just woke me up, out of a dead sleep,” she told Channel 2 Action News, “and I was trying to figure out what had happened.”  That explosion was a thief using an oxygen tank to blow up an ATM on...
Flu hospitalizations in metro Atlanta reach record levels 
Flu hospitalizations in metro Atlanta reach record levels 

The total number of flu-related hospitalizations in metro Atlanta has now reached a new high at 1,801 during this flu season — and it’s not over yet.  This figure —1,801 — is already higher than any total for a flu season since the Georgia Department of Public Health starting using this tracking system in 2009. ...
Second Henry Co. deputy heads home after shooting that killed Chase Maddox
Second Henry Co. deputy heads home after shooting that killed Chase Maddox

Two Henry County deputies shot during a fatal gun battle while serving an arrest warrant are both recovering at home now, officials said. Deputy Michael Corley has been recuperating at home and Deputy Ralph “Sid” Callaway was released from Atlanta Medical Center following the memorial service for Locust Grove police Officer Chase Maddox...
More Stories