AJC Watchdog: Tara Grinstead podcast challenges secrecy in criminal investigations


An Atlanta-based podcaster who spent months digging into the 2005 disappearance of Ocilla school teacher Tara Grinstead is asking why state law kept the official investigation secret.

Payne Lindsey, whose “Up and Vanished” podcast quickly became one of the nation’s most popular downloads after he started it last August, said he tried to get the official file into Grinstead’s disappearance from the Georgia Bureau of Investigation, but he had no luck. State open records law allows police to withhold files in pending investigations.

“My reasoning was how can you claim this is an open investigation?” he said.

Grinstead went missing nearly 12 years ago and when he started the podcast there seemed to be little prospect the case would be solved. Nancy Grace, a former prosecutor and talk show host, agrees with Lindsey that cold case files should be open when she appeared as a guest on his podcast.

“I think that we have closed investigative files for a reason,” Grace said. “However, once a case goes cold and police aren’t getting answers I really don’t see why the entire case file is kept secret.”

Last month, the GBI announced they had arrested a suspect based on a fresh tip. A second arrest of an alleged accomplice came shortly thereafter. Neither man had been among those formerly considered suspects.

For more on how “Up and Vanished” is challenging Georgia’s secret criminal files, read this week’s AJC Watchdog column here.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Deputies: Florida man had pickup repainted to avoid hit-and-run death charge
Deputies: Florida man had pickup repainted to avoid hit-and-run death charge

A Florida man accused of hitting a pedestrian while driving a pickup truck allegedly attempted to have the vehicle repainted to avoid prosecution, authorities said. Henry Earl Riner, 71, of Seffner, was arrested Monday and charged with leaving the scene of a crash with death, tampering with physical evidence and driving while his license was permanently...
Ohio dealer ordered to pay funeral expenses for drug user who overdosed
Ohio dealer ordered to pay funeral expenses for drug user who overdosed

As part of his sentence, an Ohio drug dealer was ordered to cover the funeral expenses for a user who overdosed, WLWT reported. Michael Chandler, 29, of Cincinnati, was sentenced in U.S. District Court to 200 months in prison for distributing fentanyl. Chandler also was ordered to pay more than $9,000 to cover the costs of a user’s death...
103-year-old woman's secret to long life: 'Lots and lots of chocolate'
103-year-old woman's secret to long life: 'Lots and lots of chocolate'

The fictional film character Forrest Gump famously noted that “My mom always said life was like a box of chocolates. You never know what you're gonna get.” In the case of a Washington State resident, it was longevity. Mable Smith of Yakima turned 103 on Nov. 13 and credited her long life to chocolate, KIMA reported. Smith celebrated...
Georgia high school girls basketball coach charged with sexual assault
Georgia high school girls basketball coach charged with sexual assault

Investigators said an alleged sexual assault that resulted in the arrest of a Georgia high school coach happened before a basketball game on campus. “It's very disturbing. We're talking about an adult and a child. It's not only illegal, it's inappropriate. It's wrong,” said Lt. Scott Ware of the Hall County Sheriff’s Office. Webster...
Community Lens for Nov. 24
Community Lens for Nov. 24

“Life is like a camera. Just focus on what’s important and capture the good times, develop from the negatives and if things don’t work out, just take another shot.” — Unknown As this weekend reminds us to be thankful for what we have and appreciate loved ones, the County by county staff found some favorite reader-submitted...
More Stories