Test Kitchen tips for cooking a whole turkey


A whole turkey is probably the biggest thing most of us will ever cook.

Here are answers to the questions that pop up every year when tackling that Thanksgiving feast: 

Q: What size turkey should I buy? 

A: Tally the number of guests and figure about 1 pound of turkey per person or 11/2 pounds if you want leftovers. A 15-pound turkey should be enough for 10 people. If your guests prefer more breast meat, buy a larger turkey. They generally have more breast meat. 

Q: How do I thaw the turkey? 

A: Allow at least 24 hours of thawing time for each 5 pounds of turkey. 

Always thaw the bird in the refrigerator in its original wrapping, never at room temperature. Warm temperatures promote bacteria growth. 

If you forget to take the turkey out of the freezer in time to thaw it in the refrigerator, here’s a safe cold-water thawing method. 

Place the turkey in its unopened packaging in the sink and cover it completely with cold water. Change the water every 30 minutes. Rotate the bird occasionally and allow 30 minutes of thawing time per pound. A 10-pound turkey will take at least 5 hours to thaw using this method. 

Q: What about a fresh turkey? 

A: No thawing necessary, obviously. But the USDA says you must cook a fresh turkey within two days of purchase or freeze it. 

Q: How do I prepare the turkey for roasting? 

A: Take the turkey out of the refrigerator and remove the wrapping. Remove the neck and giblets from inside the bird. Thoroughly rinse the turkey, inside and out, with cold water. Pat dry with paper towels. 

Preheat the oven to 325 degrees. 

Lift the wing tips up and over the back and tuck under the bird. Or tie them to the body with kitchen string. 

Place the turkey, breast side up, on a rack in a shallow roasting pan. The rack should be a least a half-inch from the bottom of the pan. The pan needs to be shallow for heat to circulate properly around the turkey. 

Season the turkey cavity with salt and pepper. Tie the legs together with kitchen string. Brush the turkey with vegetable oil or rub with unsalted butter. Season the exterior of the turkey with salt and pepper. 

Q: When should I stuff the bird? 

A: If you’re going to stuff the turkey, now’s the time. Always stuff just before popping the bird in the oven, never before. 

Also, mix the stuffing ingredients together just before you’re ready to stuff the turkey. Loosely spoon the stuffing into the cavity, allowing about ¾ cup per pound. Don’t overdo it. A 10-pound turkey should hold about 7 cups of stuffing. 

Q: Should I roast the bird covered or uncovered? 

A: The Butterball folks recommend cooking the turkey uncovered in a roasting pan. 

Two-thirds of the way through cooking, Butterball says foil can be placed over the breast area to prevent it from drying out. 

If you put foil on the breast, remove it about 30-45 minutes before the turkey is done to allow the breast to brown. 

Q: Should I baste and when? 

A: Start basting with a bulb baster after the turkey has been in the oven about an hour by drawing up the pan juices. If you wrapped the breast in foil, you’ll need to lift the foil to baste. Baste quickly because each time you open the oven door, heat escapes and can affect the cooking time. Add a cup or two of turkey stock or chicken broth to the roasting pan to supplement the pan juices for basting. 

Q: How will I know when the turkey is done? 

A: Roasting times vary with the size of the turkey, whether it is stuffed and the oven temperature. This is where using oven-safe meat thermometers or instant-read thermometers comes in handy. 

The turkey is done when the internal temperature reaches 165 degrees. 

If you don’t have a thermometer, check the turkey at the estimated time by piercing it in several places with a fork. The turkey is done when the juices run clear. Let it rest at least 20 minutes before carving for easier slicing. 

TIPS FOR SIDE DISHES 

While there are no set rules as to how many to have, one or two is fine to go along with the mashed potatoes and stuffing. Here are a few side dish tips: 

Peel potatoes in the morning or several hours in advance for mashed potatoes. Put them in a bowl of cold water and refrigerate. 

Clean and prep vegetables to be used in casseroles or on their own the day before. Chop, slice or dice them and store in plastic sealable bags in the refrigerator. You can, if needed, blanch (slightly precook) the day before. Be sure they are good and dry before storing them. 

Think about things you don’t eat often and try something new. It can be as simple as freshening up glazed carrots with fresh herbs such as thyme or rosemary. Or perk up those potatoes by adding mashed rutabaga or parsnips for a different flavor. 

Make stuffing in advance by sautéing onions and celery and any meats the night before. Cool and store them in plastic bags. Then, on Thursday morning, reheat the vegetables to make the stuffing. 

Some casserole-type dishes such as potato gratins can be assembled the day before baking. Plan on adding an extra 10 to 15 minutes baking time for the chilled dishes. 

Running out of oven space? Don’t forget about the outdoor grill. It’s like having an extra oven. Keep it on low (200 degrees) to keep things warm. Cover whatever you are keeping warm so it doesn’t dry out. 

— Susan Selasky 

TIPS FOR MAKING PIE DOUGH 

Have all the ingredients well-chilled, including the flour. Cut the butter and shortening in pieces and stick them in the freezer to chill them. 

If using a food processor, place plastic wrap over the work bowl. This way the flour won’t fly all over. 

Add only enough liquid so the dough comes together. 

Shape the dough into a disk — not a ball — wrap in plastic wrap and refrigerate it. 

Roll out the dough between pieces of plastic wrap or wax paper to make transferring it to the pie pan simple. 

To prevent soggy-bottom crusts, brush with beaten egg white before adding the filling and bake the pie in the lower third of the oven. 

— Susan Selasky 

CALL OR GO ONLINE FOR HELP 

Here are a few sources for holiday cooking help: 

The U.S. Department of Agriculture Meat and Poultry Hotline is staffed year-round 10 a.m.-6 p.m. Eastern weekdays. 888-674-6854. It will be open from 8 a.m.-2 p.m. Eastern on Thanksgiving. Virtual help is available at www.fsis.USDA.gov 

Butterball Turkey Talk Line: 800-288-8372 or www.butterball.com 

Ocean Spray: 800-662-3263 or www.oceanspray.com 

National Turkey Federation: www.eatturkey.com 

HoneySuckle White Turkey Line: 800-810-6325 or www.honeysucklewhite.com 

Reynolds Turkey Tips helpline: www.reynoldskitchens.com 

Fleischmann’s Yeast: www.breadworld.com 

Compiled by Susan Selasky


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Cooking and Recipes

Malbec Monday means half off bottles at this Midtown steakhouse
Malbec Monday means half off bottles at this Midtown steakhouse

  Malbec Monday means half off bottles at STK Atlanta. Photo credit: Caren West PR. STK Atlanta offers half off bottles of Terrazas de los Andes Malbec in the lounge and dining room every Monday. An ideal complement to this favorite varietal, executive chef Andrea Montobbio recently unveiled new seasonal...
What wine to serve at Thanksgiving? Try one or more of these strategies.
What wine to serve at Thanksgiving? Try one or more of these strategies.

It's that time of year again. It gets light later and dark earlier, the leaves surrender and fall from the trees, and everything at Trader Joe's transforms into pumpkin spice. That can mean only one thing: It's time to choose wines for Thanksgiving. The wine industry would have you fret over what wine to serve with your turkey and trimmings. Yams with...
Low-sodium lo mein can be cooked in just a few minutes at home
Low-sodium lo mein can be cooked in just a few minutes at home

Quick, how fast can you make lo mein?  Some recipes say 15 minutes. Others stretch it out to 20. But The Kansas City Star’s Speedy Chicken Lo Mein is faster than it would take you to order it at a Chinese restaurant.  Speed things up by using frozen stir-fry blend and broccoli slaw available in the produce aisle.  Bonus points...
An American feast in London, with cranberries
An American feast in London, with cranberries

My English friends never really got it, and that was fine. “No presents? No religion? Just ... supper?” they would ask, befuddled by a holiday meal that you attended because you wanted to, no strings attached. The British schools did not get the day off — which made sense, since at heart Thanksgiving celebrates the early Americans&rsquo...
Turkey: the one essential guest
Turkey: the one essential guest

I don’t like turkey. I mean, I do. But I don’t like it on Thanksgiving. I don’t need it. There are about 20 other dishes that get put on a table or a counter or that stay warming on the stove that I’d rather eat than turkey. But every year, there the turkey is. And every year, I fork some into a valley I built for it amid hillocks...
More Stories