Why J.J. Abrams is far more than a ‘safe’ pick


J.J. Abrams has just accepted an assignment that’s a far Wookiee cry from what he delivered just two years ago.

Now that Abrams has been announced as the new director of “Star Wars: Episode IX,” fans of the franchise are weighing in, as their opinions of his 2015 film, “The Force Awakens,” color their expectations of his 2019 Star Wars project. Yet making too many comparisons between these Star Wars trilogy bookends is a fraught endeavor.

From geek websites to The Washington Post’s own comments thread Tuesday, “The Force Awakens” is being strafed anew as a “rehash” — as somehow proof that for “Episode IX,” Abrams will simply reheat a mess of old ingredients. This from a filmmaker who is widely being called the “safe” choice to land the sequel trilogy’s big finish.

Let’s step back for a moment, though, and remember where “Star Wars” was in the fall of 2015.

Just a decade earlier, George Lucas had delivered “Revenge of the Sith” (aka “Episode III”), wrapping up his Clone Wars prequel trilogy with a film that landed like an acid test for Lucas fans. To this day, the movie gets an audience score of a relatively low 65 percent on Rotten Tomatoes — compared with 89 percent for “The Force Awakens.”

Abrams’ mission upon new owner Disney’s reboot of the “Star Wars” galaxy wasn’t simply to deliver a compelling movie that could kick off fresh sequels. Abrams was tasked with resuscitating fan interest by reviving the joy that we felt for Lucas’s original trilogy.

One weapon that Abrams chose to deploy liberally, of course, was nostalgia. The sandy terrain was littered with feel-good callbacks (what the “South Park” creators might call “member berries”). This was the “barn door” approach to winning back fans, as Abrams cast the excavated Millennium Falcon’s entry doors as shamelessly wide as possible to get us all back on board the franchise.

Having succeeded at winning that massive fan return — to a $2 billion-plus gross worldwide — Abrams is freed up to take bigger chances. Nostalgia can be burned off like a first-stage rocket, allowing “Episode IX” to focus on further elevating its next-gen heroes (especially as the film alters its plans to spotlight the late Carrie Fisher’s Leia).

Abrams, too, surely learned valuable space-sequel lessons from his second “Star Trek” film, “Into Darkness,” which was inventive but also included a studio compromise or two that he later said he regretted. Only wiser, he grows.

Yes, Abrams was a “safer” pick by Kathleen Kennedy, the Lucasfilm president. But that speaks more of their creative harmony (and “Star Wars” is no longer an auteur’s ride). They are on this journey together, as producers of an enterprise that, while worth billions, is allowing them the growing clout to take chances with the trilogy’s finish.

The franchise’s main films will likely never afford the creative risks that the “Star Wars” one-offs can take. But Abrams — working with writer Chris “Argo” Terrio, among others, with Lawrence Kasdan always hovering — is not going to play everything “safe.” He just wants to play it smart.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Living

Stolen Van Halen guitar returned to Hard Rock Cafe in Texas
Stolen Van Halen guitar returned to Hard Rock Cafe in Texas

A guitar owned by rock ’n’ roll legend Eddie Van Halen worth more than $100,000 was recovered Friday, hours after it was stolen from a Hard Rock Cafe in San Antonio, Texas, KSAT reported. The guitar, nicknamed “Frankenstrat,” had been reported stolen around 1 a.m. Friday. It was returned later in the day, but it is unclear how...
Sugarland confirms reunion and plans for new music
Sugarland confirms reunion and plans for new music

Concert review: Randy Newman spikes Atlanta show with humor and heart
Concert review: Randy Newman spikes Atlanta show with humor and heart

The setting was perfect. A guy who only needs his piano and the sharp, sardonic voice in his head sat at the keyboard of his ebony grand piano, unfurling his 1979 album opener, “It’s Money That I Love.” Randy Newman played two sets of songs from his 40-year career. Photo: Melissa Ruggieri/AJC Solid-color lighting shaded...
Author Events Nov. 19-25
Author Events Nov. 19-25

Rafi Kohan, “The Arena” and Gary Belsky, “Up Your Game.” In a fascinating, addictive look at the places we go to yell our lungs out, Sportswriter Kohan crisscrosses the country, bringing the modern American sports stadium to life. Belsky, the former editor-in-chief of ESPN The Magazine, offers the ultimate sports handbook: a...
Liar, liar, pants on fire
Liar, liar, pants on fire

In a post-truth America, poet Kevin Young, most recently author of “Blue Laws: Selected and Uncollected Poems 1995-2015,” assumes the daunting task of cataloguing America’s obsession with deception in his new nonfiction book, recently long-listed for the National Book Award, “Bunk: The Rise of Hoaxes, Humbug, Plagiarists, Phonies...
More Stories