Live-action ‘Beauty and the Beast’ can’t decide what it wants to be


Disney’s live-action remake of “Beauty and the Beast,” starring Emma Watson and Dan Stevens as, well, the beauty and the beast, feeds on the nostalgia audiences have for the 1991 animated feature. As exciting as it might be to watch actors inhabit this beloved story, the film itself, directed by Bill Condon, seems profoundly confused, and confusing.

The fairy tale was written in 18th century France, and the setting, culture and costumes are faithful to that period. But the film also has to wrangle a 1990s era girl power heroine, as well as the all-inclusive identity politics of our current times. The result is a bit of a mess, lacking a unique cinematic identity and cohesive internal reality. But then again, this is a film that features a singing candelabra and a barking ottoman, so it’s best to check disbelief at the door.

In this update, “Beauty and the Beast” can’t decide between complete faithfulness to the original (the line readings are almost identical) and story innovation.

Many of the story additions are unnecessary; they mostly have to do with character development, and no, this isn’t about LeFou (the much touted “gay” moment is a blink-and-you’ll-miss-it punchline). There’s a short song from the young prince about his dying mother, meant to illustrate the wounded child inside the arrogant, selfish prince turned angry, introverted Beast. There’s a fantastical trip to Belle’s childhood hovel in Paris to color in her family backstory, but it only serves to underscore Disney’s persistent “dead mom” fixation.

Of all the new elements, Emma Watson as Belle is delightfully winsome, and she carries the film with her intelligent charm. There is something thrilling about watching this story come to life with real actors, which will be a pleasure for those adults who grew up with the animated film. But it may likely go over the heads of the kids in the audience.

The songs by Alan Menken and Howard Ashman remain stirring and cleverly written, particularly the opening number, “Belle.” Josh Gad’s LeFou brings a much needed levity with humorous asides added to the script, but Luke Evans strains to fill the formidable britches of Gaston. Was Joe Manganiello not available?

The gruff relationship between the feisty, smart Belle and the initially aggressive Beast hasn’t changed at all over the last 26 years, which may give some pause. The Beast is practically a bully, despite his bonding with Belle over books, and Stevens’ baby blues and half-hearted gestures toward his psychology don’t offset much. There’s a complicated jumble of gender politics at hand, and any attempt at modernizing the dynamic is more of a random piling on rather than a thoughtful incorporation.

Retreads of old movies powered by nostalgia and fond childhood memories are clearly popular cash cows for Hollywood. But are they worthy of our time? As “Beauty and the Beast” proves, without careful craft and consideration for the way these stories are told, the answer is tricky at best.

MOVIE REVIEW

“Beauty and the Beast”

Grade: C+

Starring Emma Watson, Dan Stevens and Luke Evans. Directed by Bill Condon.

Rated PG for some action violence, peril and frightening images. Check listings for theaters. 2 hours, 9 minutes.

Bottom line: The film is confused and confusing



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Living

Plans underway to make Gregg Allman’s Macon burial site a ‘family plot’
Plans underway to make Gregg Allman’s Macon burial site a ‘family plot’

BY MELISSA RUGGIERI/AJC Music Scene When Gregg Allman was buried on the first sun-soaked Saturday of June , fans filled Rose Hill Cemetery in Macon to get a glimpse of the freshly churned gravesite, a few feet and a thin fence away from his brother Duane and Allman Brothers Band bassist Berry Oakley. Ideally, the Allman team...
Aretha Franklin will return to the Fox Theatre this fall
Aretha Franklin will return to the Fox Theatre this fall

Aretha Franklin, performing in April 2016. (AP Photo/Carolyn Kaster, File) BY MELISSA RUGGIERI/AJC Music Scene Nearly three years since her last Atlanta appearance , Aretha Franklin will return to the Fox Theatre. The Queen of Soul will perform at 8 p.m. Oct. 13. Tickets start at $69.50 and will go on sale at noon Aug. 25 via ...
Catching up with ‘American Idol’ singers Diana DeGarmo and Ace Young
Catching up with ‘American Idol’ singers Diana DeGarmo and Ace Young

Ace Young and Diana DeGarmo have been married four years. CREDIT: Rodney Ho/rho@ajc.com This was posted on Saturday, August 19, 2017 by RODNEY HO/rho@ajc.com on his AJC Radio & TV Talk blog WSB-TV Saturday held an “Atlanta Idol” promotional contest promoting the show’s move to Atlanta and Tuesday’s bus auditions ...
Ten Atlanta radio/TV personalities who made comebacks like Paul Ossmann
Ten Atlanta radio/TV personalities who made comebacks like Paul Ossmann

Comeback kids in Atlanta media: (Top left, clockwise): Kim “The Kimmer” Peterson, Eric Von Haessler, Porsche Foxx, Amanda Davis, Jeff Hullinger, Christopher “Crash” Clark. This was posted Frida y, August 18, 2017 by RODNEY HO/rho@ajc.com on his AJC Radio & TV Talk blog People love...
The University of Texas moves Confederate statues

The University of Texas has moved statues depicting Confederate Gens. Robert E. Lee and  Albert Sidney Johnston, John Reagan, who served as postmaster during the Civil War and former Texas Gov. James Stephen Hogg, whose father was a Confederate brigadier general, from its campus. The Lee, Johnston and Reagan statues...
More Stories