Which Atlanta bars are best for a classic cocktail?

Elder classics like the brandy crusta can be traced to the 1862 “Bartenders Guide” by Jerry Thomas while others span the post-Prohibition decades and include modern classics like the scotch-based Penicillin created in 2005 by Sam Ross. Here are six timeless drinks and our picks on where to enjoy them.

Old Fashioned

Considered the original cocktail with roots dating to 1806, the old fashioned is a simple, stirred concoction of whiskey, sugar, bitters and water. The simplicity of the classic is mastered at the Pinewood (254 W. Ponce de Leon Ave., Decatur. 404-373-5507, pinewoodtr.com). It also happens to be on draft. When the Toasted Old Fashioned hit the menu at Gunshow and then at Revival (129 Church St., Decatur. 470-225-6770, revivaldecatur.com), chef Kevin Gillespie’s favorite cocktail of bourbon, burnt sugar and brûléed cinnamon was an instant hit with guests. The “Goonies”-inspired Chester Copperpot at Ration and Dram (130 Arizona Ave. NE, Atlanta. 678-974-8380, rationanddram.com) is a permanent fixture on the menu made with Plantation Pineapple rum and creme de noyaux (almond liqueur).


This three-ingredient, stirred cocktail of rye or bourbon, sweet vermouth and bitters is thought to have been created at the Manhattan Club in New York City around 1880. The Mercury (Ponce City Market, 675 Ponce de Leon Ave. NE, Atlanta. 404-500-5253, themercuryatl.com) offers a classic Manhattan as one of its “tableside for four” cocktails served in a pitcher. Bring three of your friends and drink your way through the pitcher. At Wrecking Bar (292 Moreland Ave. NE, Atlanta. 404-221-2600, wreckingbarbrewpub.com), long-standing favorite the barrel-aged Manhattan is rested for six weeks in a small, 5-gallon barrel.


The origins of the martini date to the 1880s when Italian vermouth was becoming popular in cocktails and Old Tom gin was the spirit of choice for the classic. The martini is enjoying renewed popularity. Kimball House (303 E. Howard Ave., Decatur. 404-378-3502, kimball-house.com) makes a mean made-to-order martini, but try their beautifully balanced 50/50 aptly named Kimball House with gin, Cocchi Americano, French vermouth and orange bitters. The cocktail comes with proper garnish service: a choice of two olives or a lemon twist. 8Arm (710 Ponce de Leon Ave. NE, Atlanta. 470-875-5856, 8armatl.com) reintroduced Atlanta to the glory of the Gibson, a super subtle dirty martini of two parts gin and one part vermouth with a house-made pickled onion.


The equal parts cocktail of gin, Campari and sweet vermouth was likely created in Florence, Italy, by Count Camillo Negroni in 1919. Newly opened in Westside’s Stockyards, Donetto (976 Brady Ave. NW, Atlanta. 404-445-6867, donettoatlanta.com), like its sister Colletta at Alpharetta’s Avalon, offers a beautiful barrel-rested Negroni on draft. The mezcal Negroni at Muss & Turner’s backroom speakeasy Eleanor’s (1675 Cumberland Parkway SE, Smyrna. 770-434-1114, mussandturners.com/smyrna/eleanors) is smoky with a bittersweet mixture of the herbaceous St. George Bruto Americano amaro and sweet vermouth. An excellent Negroni for whiskey and scotch drinkers.


Thought to have been created sometime around the end of World War I, the sidecar is a simple sour cocktail of cognac or brandy, orange liqueur like triple sec and fresh lemon juice. It resembles the much older brandy crusta, which, in addition to the above ingredients, also contains simple syrup, maraschino and angostura bitters. Marcel (1170 Howell Mill Road, Atlanta. 404-665-4555, marcelatl.com) offers a lovely version that straddles the line between the classic sidecar and the ancient brandy crusta made with calvados (French apple brandy), combier, lemon juice and lemon bitters and garnished with a sugar rim.


The earliest known reference to this elegant French cocktail was in 1930 in “The Savoy Cocktail Book.” A possible variation on the sidecar, the Champs-Elysees was originally listed as a six-person drink to be served tableside. Its popularity has waxed and waned over the years, but Bread & Butterfly (290 Elizabeth St. NE, Atlanta. 678-515-4536, bread-and-butterfly.com) is giving the cocktail of cognac, green chartreuse, lemon, sugar and bitters new life.

Check out what the AJC Fall Dining Guide 2017 has to offer:

•What do you think of these restaurants? 10 reader-requested reviews for Atlanta and beyond 

•How can I meet people who love to eat? Atlanta dinner clubs combine chatter with chow 

•What’s your favorite metro Atlanta restaurant? AJC food editor Ligaya Figueras answers 

•What are the hottest cocktail trends in Atlanta? 

•Which Atlanta bars are best for a classic cocktail? 

•Which new bars in Atlanta will most tempt you? 

•How are Atlanta breweries changing for the better? 

•What’s the deal with...all the metro Atlanta food halls? 

•What’s the deal with...all the metro Atlanta rolled ice cream?

•What’s the deal with...the metro Atlanta steakhouse boom? 

•What’s the deal with...all the poké in metro Atlanta? 

•Video: Burning questions with Bob Bost

•Video: Burning questions with Tiffanie Barriere

•Video: Burning questions with Bryan Furman

•360 Video tour of Bacchanalia

•360 Video tour of Kimball House

•360 Video tour of Gunshow

•360 Video tour of Spring

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Food

Seven Day Menu Planner
Seven Day Menu Planner

12/ 3 Family Sunday Make today’s family meal as simple as possible with your Roasted Turkey Breast. Alongside, enjoy Quinoa Salad With Sugar Snap Peas (see recipe), steamed sliced carrots, red-tipped lettuce salad and sourdough bread. Slice angel food cake and top the...
This comfort food leads a double life, but only some of us know the secret.
This comfort food leads a double life, but only some of us know the secret.

It was one of those volunteer duties, the one where you agree to talk to your kid’s class about your job. I figured it would be easy: I’d ask the kids what their family eats at Thanksgiving and we’d do a middle-school version of Brillat-Savarin’s old saw, “Tell me what you eat and I’ll tell you who you are.&rdquo...
Asian-American chefs are changing our palate
Asian-American chefs are changing our palate

As an Asian-American born in Los Angeles and raised in Honolulu, I’ve thought a lot about what it means to grow up in multiple cultures at once — my Filipino mother’s, my British father’s, and my America. For a recent piece on how Asian-American chefs are changing the American palate, I spoke with some two dozen chefs and restaurateurs...
Straight from frozen: A rock-solid plan for your rock-solid Thanksgiving bird
Straight from frozen: A rock-solid plan for your rock-solid Thanksgiving bird

When producing a Thanksgiving meal becomes a last-minute affair - and there are plenty of reasons that happens, no judging - you might think getting a bronzed bird on the table presents the toughest challenge.  Nah, you've got this. Cooking a whole turkey from a rock-solid, frozen state can yield respectable results. If you stick it in the oven...
These five wines will see you through the holidays
These five wines will see you through the holidays

Here are five delicious wines that will complement your Thanksgiving feast - or any dinner party for that matter: We have two outstanding sparkling wines from Oregon, a delightful pinot blanc from Michigan's Old Mission Peninsula, a surprising pinotage from Mendocino and a rich syrah from California's Central Coast. 3 stars Willamette Valley, Oregon...
More Stories