Review: Aurora, Outfit re-up on ‘Hunchback of Notre Dame’

As musicalizations of Victor Hugo go, “The Hunchback of Notre Dame” is no “Les Miserables.” The good folks at Lawrenceville’s Aurora Theatre probably already know as much, having produced an ambitious (if necessarily pared-down) undertaking of the acclaimed Boublil-Schonberg sung-through version of that latter literary classic —  to such considerable fanfare in 2013 that the company revived it again two years later, with equally popular results.

Although more attuned to the simplistic 1996 Disney animated movie than the epic 1831 Hugo novel, “Hunchback” is appropriately darker in tone than, say, other stage adaptations of Disney’s “The Little Mermaid,” “Beauty and the Beast” or “Aladdin,” all of which also include scores composed by Alan Menken. Still, tellingly, after a couple of regional theater renditions in 2014 and 2015, plans were eventually abandoned to mount “Hunchback” (with song lyrics by Stephen Schwartz and a script by Peter Parnell) on Broadway.

Unfortunately, too, as the third annual season-opening collaboration between Aurora and Atlanta’s Theatrical Outfit, it’s no “Memphis” or “In the Heights,” either. All three are mainstream musical entertainments, but where those previous shows told more contemporary and socially relevant stories, this one is a swashbuckling period piece that’s less intimate and rather fantastical in nature, replete with a chorus of imaginary friends in the form of singing gargoyle puppets.

RELATED: Co-productions let metro Atlanta theaters split costs, extend reach

Directed by the unmistakably qualified Justin Anderson — and sumptuously designed (set by Shannon Robert, costumes by Alan Yeong, and particularly atmospheric lighting by Maria Cristina Fuste) — the co-production continues at Aurora through Aug. 27, before the Outfit transfers it to the Rialto Center for the Arts in downtown Atlanta Sept. 7-17.

The show’s larger musical numbers, choreographed by Ricardo Aponte, are energetically executed by an ensemble of two dozen dancers and singers, under the music direction of Ann-Carol Pence (on keyboards) and a band of eight additional musicians.

Haden Rider, who most recently starred as Atlanta Lyric’s “Jesus Christ Superstar,” is an unquestionable talent in his own right, a fine actor and a gifted vocalist who nevertheless seems miscast here, playing the title role of the grotesquely deformed bell ringer, Quasimodo. He affects a raspy quality to deliver his dialogue, and then performs his songs (“Out There,” “Heaven’s Light”) with a beautiful tenor voice. He distorts his handsome face, but that’s hardly enough to be truly believed as a character so often described as an “ugly monster.”

Seen to greater advantage are the lovely Julissa Sabino as the gypsy love interest, Esmeralda, and the accomplished David de Vries as the nefarious Dom Claude Frollo. She confirms her status as one of our brightest musical stars, in work as wide-ranging as “Rent” (at Actor’s Express) and “The Toxic Avenger” (at Horizon). Long renowned locally as a dramatic actor (and, of late, director), his out-of-town credits include stints on Broadway and on tour in “Beauty and the Beast” and “Wicked” — so how wonderful to finally witness for ourselves his own singing skills.

Otherwise, the combined triumphs of “Les Miz,” “Memphis” and “In the Heights” ultimately prove to be a hard act for this “Hunchback” to follow.


“The Hunchback of Notre Dame”

Grade: B-

Through Aug. 27 at Aurora Theatre, 128 E. Pike St., Lawrenceville. 8 p.m. Tuesdays-Saturdays; 2:30 p.m. Saturdays-Sundays; 10 a.m. Tuesdays (Aug. 1 and 15 only). $24-$65. 678-226-6222,

Sept. 7-17 at the Rialto Center for the Arts, 80 Forsyth St. SW, Atlanta. 7:30 p.m. Wednesdays-Saturdays; 2:30 p.m. Saturdays-Sundays; 11 a.m. Thursday (Sept. 14 only). $18-$51. 678-528-1500,

Bottom line: The third time is less of a charm.

In other news:

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Living

Aaron Carter checks into rehab after turbulent few months
Aaron Carter checks into rehab after turbulent few months

Aaron Carter told his fans Friday night on Twitter that he would be “disappearing for a while.” The singer and former teen heartthrob Carter tweeted the news shortly after checking into rehab. Carter’s publicist confirmed the news in a statement to People. “Aaron has decided to enter a facility to improve his health and work...
Ryan Seacrest blaming Mariah Carey for bombing New Year’s Eve performance
Ryan Seacrest blaming Mariah Carey for bombing New Year’s Eve performance

Almost ten months after Mariah Carey’s infamous New Year’s Eve debacle, Ryan Seacrest is coming to the crew’s defense after the singer placed the blame for the mishap on Dick Clark Productions. “What was going through my head [in that moment] was and is: That crew, that team, that staff is the best in the business...
J-Lo, other stars add pleas for relief to Puerto Rico
J-Lo, other stars add pleas for relief to Puerto Rico

Jennifer Lopez said Thursday night that she still hasn’t heard from her family in Puerto Rico – two days after Hurricane Maria slammed into the island and left millions without power, People reported. Maria’s 155-mph winds ripped trees from the ground, tore roofs from buildings, and caused massive flooding. >> Read...
Renovations, reuse on display during fall home tours
Renovations, reuse on display during fall home tours

As temperatures cool, many homeowners bring out the wreaths and harvest decor, but for some Atlanta area communities, it’s time to bring their A-game. Fall home tours are a tradition that allow people to see what local neighborhoods have to offer both in community spirit, architecture and personal style. Here’s a look at two upcoming tours...
Where can I find it?
Where can I find it?

Q: I have an Old Testament bible with a handwritten note indicating the bible was a gift on Nov. 10, 1900. I also have a New Testament bible with a printed date of 1901. Both bibles were donated to our neighborhood swim club. Can you tell me where in Atlanta I can have these bibles appraised? I tried an online “Just Answer” site, which...
More Stories