SunTrust: SEC may hit investment unit with fraud charge


Federal regulators are considering fraud charges against SunTrust Banks over allegations that its investment business steered customers into costly mutual funds when cheaper options were available.

The Atlanta bank said in a filing that the Securities and Exchange Commission’s enforcement division “made a preliminary determination to recommend … an enforcement action” against SunTrust Investment Services, the bank’s broker-dealer and insurance arm.

The probe was disclosed last week in SunTrust’s annual report filed with the SEC.

If found guilty, the bank could face not only fines but the potential loss of some of its investment business income and its fast-track status for issuing new bonds and other securities.

In late 2015, J.P. Morgan paid $267 million to settle SEC charges that it failed to disclose conflicts of interest when it steered customers into its own investment products that were more costly than alternative funds.

Last year, the SEC launched a campaign to investigate whether banks and investment firms were making self-serving investment recommendations to customers.

At the center of the SunTrust investigation is whether the bank’s investment arm bought costly mutual funds on behalf of clients that charged a type of marketing fee, called 12b-1 fees, rather than recommending cheaper mutual funds that don’t charge such fees.

Often, funds that charge the higher fees also pay higher commissions to companies and brokers that sell them.

Such actions could violate the 77-year-old Investment Advisers Act, which requires money managers registered with the SEC to act in clients’ best interests.

The U.S. Department of Labor rolled out a similar rule, set to take effect next month, for brokers, insurance agents and other investment advisers when selling or recommending investments in retirement accounts such as a 401(k).

However, President Trump is seeking to delay or repeal that new rule. Last month, he issued an executive order directing the Labor Department to delay implementation of the so-call fiduciary rule, set to take effect April 10. This week, the Labor Department proposed delaying it for 60 days.

Meanwhile, SunTrust said in its filing that its investment business, STIS, is “researching the extent to which alternate mutual fund classes existed which did not impose such fees.” The bank said fees it has collected add up to “$5 million or less,” the bank said.

However, penalties could be more costly both in dollars and tougher restrictions on SunTrust’s ability to earn fees on investment product sales, and its ability to issue new bonds or other securities to investors.

In its filing, SunTrust said that if STIS admitted or was found guilty of fraud, the bank could lose its “seasoned issuer” status that allows SunTrust to issue bonds and stocks with simplified, automatic approval by the SEC. A fraud conviction would revoke that status for three years.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Business

Georgia PSC wants hard numbers on Plant Vogtle project
Georgia PSC wants hard numbers on Plant Vogtle project

State utility regulators want Georgia Power to answer several questions — including how much more it will cost — when the Atlanta utility turns in its recommendation later this month on what to do with the troubled Plant Vogtle nuclear project. Georgia Power faces an Aug. 31 deadline to file its recommendation for the Vogtle expansion...
Georgia Power told to do its homework on Vogtle nuke options
Georgia Power told to do its homework on Vogtle nuke options

Georgia’s utility regulators want Georgia Power to answer several questions — including how much more it will cost — when the Atlanta utility turns in its recommendation later this month on what to do with its troubled Plant Vogtle nuclear project. Georgia Power faces an Aug. 31 deadline to file its recommendation on what to...
Trump tweets he knows CEOs to replace the 'grandstanders' who resigned from council
Trump tweets he knows CEOs to replace the 'grandstanders' who resigned from council

In a tweet Tuesday morning, President Donald Trump said he has other chief executives ready to succeed the "grandstanders" who stepped down from his manufacturing council in the aftermath of the violent protests in Charlottesville, Virginia. "For every CEO that drops out of the Manufacturing Council, I have many to take their place...
Home Depot profits break record; quarter’s sales also hit all-time high
Home Depot profits break record; quarter’s sales also hit all-time high

Home Depot, Georgia’s largest company and the world's largest home improvement retailer, Tuesday announced sales of $28.1 billion for the second quarter of its fiscal year. That was up 6.2 percent from the same quarter a year ago.  Home Depot profit for the quarter was $2.7 billion, up from the net earnings of $2.4 billion a year earlier...
Atlanta airport moving Uber, Lyft pickups to economy lots
Atlanta airport moving Uber, Lyft pickups to economy lots

Just months after curbside pickups by ride-share services Uber and Lyft became legal, the Atlanta airport is moving the designated pickup areas to the economy parking lots. The new pickup locations, which will require a walk across a terminal roadway and through parking garages to the economy lots, open on Wednesday. The world’s busiest airport...
More Stories