Kempner: Atlanta airport spends jaw-dropping money for fancy umbrella


The domestic terminal at the world’s busiest airport isn’t exactly a looker from the outside.

Most travelers probably are too focused on making their flights or trying to remember if they brought the travel-size toothpaste to care about street aesthetics outside Hartsfield-Jackson Atlanta We-Can’t-Even-Remember-What-It Looks-Like-From-The-Outside International Airport.

Hartsfield and city leaders, though, apparently are convinced that looks matter. Plus they want to keep their customers out of the rain for a few more steps.

Which is why the airport is spending — brace yourself — $265 million on work near the entrances of the airport. The biggest chunk of that — something north of $134 million — is to install soaring canopies between the domestic terminal (North and South sides) and the parking decks, over several lanes of traffic in passenger pickup and drop off areas.

That will keep us snowflakes dry as we cross the lanes, a walk of about 25 seconds (I timed it), a bit of which is already covered on a center island. We’ll also be dry while unloading or picking up passengers curbside.

That’s just good, basic customer service. But do we need to be so extravagant in how we go about providing a fashion statement/mammoth umbrella?

Hartsfield-Jackson happens to have access to a cargo-load of public money that can only be spent on airport projects. I suppose that makes it easier to sink a bunch of it into a fashion statement/mammoth umbrella.

How about loaner umbrellas?

Hey, it’s only money.

Your money. The airport is owned by the city of Atlanta. Among its biggest sources of funding are public parking, concessions, land and building rentals and, the big daddy, ticket fees. That last one, $4.50 for each leg of a flight, generated $201 million for the Atlanta airport in the fiscal year ending in mid 2016.

In a previous column about the airport’s spending I suggested a more human-scale alternative to the planned canopies: “Couldn’t we just hire people with umbrellas to walk visitors across and maybe say welcoming things?”

Or how about just setting up baskets of loaner Hartsfield-branded umbrellas?

Maybe I’m being cheap. So I asked some travelers about their views during a recent rainstorm, which should have been a slam-dunk for canopy love.

“I don’t want to get wet, but I’ll get over it,” a well-dressed woman told me. She travels almost every week and has mapped out her rainy-day route from the parking deck: Go to the deck’s lower level and cross into the domestic terminal building under cover.

I stopped a couple pushing a baby in a stroller outside.

“Save the money,” the dad, Vaughn Allen of Midtown, told me.

The mom, Katie Allen, said the same. When it comes to airport exteriors, “I don’t care about looks.”

Another passenger, who was carrying an umbrella on her trip just to deal with the Atlanta rain, told me she likes the idea of making the outside of Hartsfield look better and her path less wet. But she said she didn’t know if it would be worth the price.

Larry Hermann, a contractor who lives in Hiram, had not such qualms.

“Keep people comfortable,” he told me. “It’s the busiest airport anywhere. It should bear the expense of a canopy.”

The North canopy is supposed to be in place by May, with the South one following in the Spring of 2019.

Crucially, the project’s price tag doesn’t include planned overhead pedestrian bridges. The raised walkways, which ostensibly will be added later, would avoid the need for pedestrians to cross streets at the main curbside passenger drop-off and pick-up areas. That ought to make things safer for them and smoother for the traffic flow.

The airport couldn’t immediately give me a price tag or timetable for the bridges, but I wouldn’t be surprised if they cost tens of millions of dollars more.

Concrete-mush looks

Airport officials already have and are spending a lot to dress up the inside of buildings to improve passenger amenities. They have a $6 billion, 20-year plan for modernization and expansion. 

That includes the new canopies, festooned with lighting that changes colors. They should add pizzazz to a building with concrete-mush looks.

The canopies apparently won’t create a skyline feature visible from miles away. They’ll be the kind of thing you see when you get up close. Connecting travelers — a big chunk of Hartsfield-Jackson’s flyers — probably won’t see it at all.

But Atlanta Mayor Kasim Reed in speech assured that the addition will “create a dramatic gateway” for us.

In fact, he said that when the work is done, the world’s busiest airport also “is going to be the most attractive.”

That would be nice.

Aaron Betsky, an architecture critic and president of the School of Architecture at Taliesin (formerly the Frank Lloyd Wright School of Architecture), wrote a column about Hartsfield-Jackson a few years back in Architect magazine. He described the airport “the single ugliest, most unpleasant semi-public space I have the forced occasion to use.”

He suggested we tear it down. His biggest criticisms seemed to focus on the airport’s layout, passenger comfort and the Plane Train.

I wondered if the planned canopies might temper his conclusions, at least about the airport’s exterior. I sent him a rendering. He looked at others online.

“I don’t think they look particularly wonderful,” he said, referring to the shaped canopies as “these curvy wurvies.”

He suggested instead a good sign or some kind of facade work coupled with less expansive and more affordable weather protection than the canopy project now underway.

“I’m a little baffled,” he said, “why they would spend that much money on it.”

Related columns:

Delta gives Atlanta passengers new reason to squirm

World’s busiest airport planned to ease off the “b” word

Atlanta airport launches pricey underground adventure

Find Matt on Facebook (https://www.facebook.com/mattkempnercolumnist) and Twitter (@MattKempner) or email him at mkempner@ajc.com.

Other Kempner’s Unofficial Business columns: http://www.myajc.com/news/opinion/matt-kempner-unofficial-business/j9F7R2mOGomS5FMjfhho2O/

MYAJC.COM: REAL JOURNALISM. REAL LOCAL IMPACT.

AJC Unofficial Business columnist Matt Kempner offers you a unique look at the business scene in metro Atlanta and beyond. You'll find more on myAJC.com, including these columns:

Never miss a minute of what's happening in local business news. Subscribe to myAJC.com.

In other Airlines news:


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Business

Kempner: Amazon, thanks for sort of picking Atlanta, but …
Kempner: Amazon, thanks for sort of picking Atlanta, but …

Amazon, it’s not that we’re ungrateful for Atlanta being one of your Top 20 choices for your second headquarters and 50,000 delicious jobs. We’ll hold off celebrating or feeling like we’ve gotten some kind of affirmation until we figure out if you just like us a good bit or really love us. Yes, we do think we are all that...
New Chick-fil-A opens in Vine City, part of revitalization efforts
New Chick-fil-A opens in Vine City, part of revitalization efforts

Chick-fil-A has opened a new restaurant in Vine City, as part of an ongoing effort to revitalize the Westside area of Atlanta. The new restaurant located on MLK Drive, has provided 90 jobs, seventy percent of which went to Westside residents and also includes a conference room for people to hold community meetings. “This restaurant serves as...
Atlanta survives the first cut in Amazon’s HQ2 sweepstakes
Atlanta survives the first cut in Amazon’s HQ2 sweepstakes

Amazon narrowed its list of potential communities for its massive second headquarters on Thursday to a final grouping that includes Atlanta and 19 others in the U.S. and Canada, setting off a battle royale for a project promising prestige and 50,000 high-paying jobs. Georgia and metro Atlanta leaders hailed the news, while noting much work remains...
Georgia ends 2017 with modest job growth, slowest of past five years
Georgia ends 2017 with modest job growth, slowest of past five years

Georgia’s economy added 5,600 jobs last month, providing an upbeat but unspectacular ending to year of modest growth across most employment sectors. In 2017, the state finished the year with 83,200 more jobs than the year before, according to a report Thursday from Georgia’s Labor Department . “As we look back at the year, it was...
Best gifts for the home chef
Best gifts for the home chef

There are all sorts of new gizmos for people whose relationship with food comes in all forms. Here are four of our favorite new devices for the cook and the kitchen. ——— Amazon Dash Wand Product Review: https://www.cnet.com/products/amazon-dash-wand-with-alexa-2017/review/#ftag=CAD187281f CNET rating: 4.0 stars out of 5 (Excellent)...
More Stories